21 Best Italian Restaurants in Whitby

“This was our first time coming to the Whitby location and it was fantastic! We came to celebrate my belated birthday and the food was so delicious and our waitress was so lovely. From start to finish everything was superb. We will definitely come back!“

“Brutal, service rather lack of, is absolutely horrible. Do not go unless you have a few hours! So poor.“

“My first visit to your restaurant...and it certainly will not be the last! Exquisite! Michael....thank you for a beautiful dining experience.“

“Amazing food! T is Super friendly and helpful and accommodated my requests. Staff is really friendly also! Thank you!! If you haven’t tried wings from here and reading this, you have to try them!! Thank you T !“

“The food is excellent! We love getting family combos for our family gatherings and skip the cooking and just enjoy ourselves. It is so delicious! We especially love the lasagna as well as chicken rose penne. The shepherds pie is excellent too. Honestly everything tastes great!“

“The meal was the most authentic Italian meal we have had in a long time. The sauce was perfect! Highly recommend and don't forget to have the homemade pasta!“

“First time here. Absolutely a fantastic dinner. Our sever Pam was excellent. Very friendly, fun and professional. Helped us with the menu. The pizza was amazing!!! Best we have ever had. We will be returning many times. Great atmosphere and owner Marco even stopped and chatted with diners. Can’t wait to go back!! CHEERS!!!“

“Right off Baldwin and there is a lot of street parking.
Lots of staff and seating at this place which is great.
Lot of wine options as well as draft beers. They have an upstairs and patio dining.
Pizza was really tasty and they were generous on toppings and cheese for the Don Corrado. The Chicken Puttanesca had two nicely done chicken breast with a bit of a kick to the dish and just the right amount of pasta and sauce.
The Tiramisu was tasty and the Chocolate Truffle Cake was surprisingly not heavy. We paired dessert with coffees but unfortunately the coffee were a bit weak. Server and staff were really nice and we enjoyed ourselves.“

“from my son ... YUM YUM YUM YUMMLE YUMMEL recommend the veal Parm👍 the meatballs are HUGE“

“Another delicious meal thanks to Chef José and his team! Gracias!!“

“The service was excellent! The Afghan staff were very kind, respectful, and professional. The food was fresh and delicious, and everything was served on time. I really appreciate their hard work and great customer service. Highly recommended!“

“On Thursday, September 18, 2025, at 12:30 pm, after a mix-up with our reservation at a nearby restaurant, we decided to try Tuscan Wolf Pizzeria. At first, it didn’t seem particularly remarkable, but we were pleasantly surprised. Our waitress, whom I believe was named Lianne, was incredibly friendly and took the time to carefully explain the various menu options to us. The pizza was outstanding and truly reminiscent of what you’d find in southern Italy. We highly recommend this restaurant to anyone seeking excellent service and an authentic Italian pizza experience.“

“I just moved down the street from this Pizza Pizza location and I am SO happy I decided to order from them!! I have ordered from so many restaurants trying to find a decent plant based Pizza that even slightly resembles the flavor and texture of a regular dairy and pepperoni Pizza that I used to enjoy 8 years ago before changing my lifestyle...even restaurants that are 100% vegan can't top the Plant Based Pepperoni I ordered from this location!! It was SO GOOD!! I completely understand that cooking and baking with plant based ingredients like the dairy free cheese and pepperoni etc can be a bit tricky as they do not cook or melt the same as regular, and so many takeout plant based Pizzas I have tried were just awful BUT this Pizza Pizza Location has figured it out!! It was so good I just picked up another one for lunch today! Ontop of the pizza being very tasty and fresh, it was prepared fast and the staff are wonderful and very friendly. I highly recommend checking them out!!

Vegetarian options: Lots of fresh veggies toppings to choose from, dairy free plant based
cheese and delicious plant based pepperoni for the pizza.

Dietary restrictions: They use Daiya dairy free cheese which tastes great in my opinion.“

“The quintessential hole in the wall that delivers deep and well thought out food. Colin - Chef/owner is a top fella! Very accommodating“

“We ordered out from Navona Pizzeria Oshawa and we were so pleased with the quality of food. They have a variety of food that is made fresh on site. We have used delivery for a few orders. Both drivers are so nice and super fast. We have also done pick up and the owners are so friendly. The employees are so kind and very helpful. Our pizza was so happy with the food quality. We love the pizza, wings, lasagna, breadsticks and cheesecake.“

“pizzas are always fresh , vegetables are fresh their wings are cooked perfect , I recommend this place 💯.“

“Mancini's is the best place for pizza in Whitby 'Hands Down'...changed from other places that took half the weight out of their product, like we wouldn't notice! We changed to Mancini's and won't go back!! Very clean and lovely family business, Thank you Mancini's !! Susan and Bruce Whitby“

“We ordered the oh rasta chicken penne for a dinner party and it did not disappoint! The serving size was amazing; it was advertised as serving 10 and it easily served 15 of us with lots of leftovers. We are looking forward to going back and trying out some other menu options!“

“The nasi goreng (chicken and shrimp) was delicious, but be aware that the spice level may exceed expectations. We requested regular spice, but it turned out spicier. Nonetheless, the amazing taste made up for it. The fried chicken kothu roti was good, earning a 7/10 rating

It’s a takeout place.“

“Every time I visit this Pizza Pizza location (which isn’t very often) it’s usually pretty quiet, but always clean, and the staff are consistently friendly and welcoming.

Today, our family of four stopped by. I had placed an order through the app for a medium pepperoni pizza but forgot to select the option for half cheese, half pepperoni. When I mentioned the mistake to the staff, they were incredibly accommodating, even though the pizza was already in the oven. They didn’t show the slightest bit of annoyance and quickly found a way to make it right.

My husband ordered a chicken sandwich that unfortunately had a strange texture. It didn’t look undercooked, but something about the taste and feel was off. When he politely shared his concern with the staff, they listened without giving any attitude or resistance. They immediately took the sandwich back and offered him something else instead.

We truly appreciated the professionalism, friendliness, and accountability shown by the staff today. Thank you for making our visit a positive one!“