9 Best American Restaurants near Bendersville

“Visited on Mother’s Day, even though it was crowded we were seated quickly. The food was excellent with staff attentive and very friendly“

“Stayed for the first time and it will not be the last. The history and preservation being done by the new owners truly honors the past. Our room was beautiful and breakfast was great. The owners were fantastic and knew a lot of the history. Highly recommend a stay here.“

“Delicious family-style dining and exceptional service at Hickory Bridge Farm made for quite an evening out with friends.

The menu changes daily, but no matter what they are serving, I can guarantee it's going to be phenomenal.

On the evening of our visit, our meal began with fresh bread with apple butter, and a side salad topped with a warm bacon vinaigrette dressing. Then the main event began. The entrees that evening consisted of fried chicken, roasted pork, and crab imperial. There were so many sides as well ranging from broccoli with white cheese sauce, fried apples, hush puppies, glazed sliced carrots, and more. After an enormous feast you got to choose a delicious dessert from a separate menu.

Everything was fantastic, and the best part is, it's all-you-care-to-eat. So, if there is something you enjoyed, you can ask for more.

Our server was friendly, knowledgeable, and matched our vibe perfectly. I wish I could remember her name as she deserves a proper shout out, but I forgot it by the time I sat down to write this review.

The aesthetic of the restaurant itself is warm and cozy. It is a rustic design and so comforting that even in a packed out restaurant, everything just sort of dissipates around you. It reminded me of something out of a Hallmark Christmas movie. That's the best way I can describe it.

There is ample free parking available onsite as well.

Hickory Bridge Farm is a hidden gem just nine short miles from historic Gettysburg. They do have a cocktail menu as well; featuring craft made adult beverages, wines, and a small assortment of local brews.

If you are considering this restaurant, do yourself a favor and move it to the top of your list. You won't be disappointed.“

“I eat at Family two or three times a week. I've never had a ad meal there and the servers ad staff greet us every time, with a hi and a smile.“

“In from out of state and just happened upon this fine little “dive bar”. The bartender was amazing, the food was ridiculously fantastic! If we’re ever back on this area, we will surely stop back!“

“This place was fantastic. Stacy was very friendly and took great care of me. I had a steak and crab cake and everything was cooked to perfection. They were not busy and the inside is very quaint and comfortable, I suggest you you try it. The dessert was also yummy.“

“Great food but I would rather order my food online instead of having to order over the phone. Even when the online ordering website did work it didn't include ordering wings just the other food items. Sometimes it's hard to understand the person over the phone when the place is loud.“

“Went to dinner Sunday nite. Had a great server Stephanie. Good was good. When we were leaving we ask to speak to the manager on duty to tell her what a great server we had. The girl that had sat us came back and said the manager was to busy doing inventory but she told her the reason we wanted to see her. We believe in telling management when the have a good person working for them but obviously the manager needs to take lessons from her server! Very rude!“

“We had no wait for a table at this Ruby Tuesday on a Friday evening at dinner time. We were seated right away and greeted promptly by our server, Carly, who took our drink orders, explained what the specials were, and gave us time to look over the large variety of items on the menu. Once we decided what to order, our food came out very promptly and was fresh and hot when brought to our table. I had a 6 oz ribeye with a baked potato ($18.49). My husband had one of the specials, which was a 6 oz. ribeye, shrimp, and 1/2 rack of ribs with fries ($23.99). Steaks were prepared as ordered and were larger than we were expecting. Baked potato was also quite large. Ribs had plenty of sauce and were tender and tasty. Carly did a great job checking back with us frequently to see if we needed anything else and keeping our drinks refilled for us. Dining room was clean and tidy and tables were cleared promptly when other guests were finished dining. We did not eat from the salad bar with our meals, but did notice that it seemed to offer a lot of variety and many guests were making trips to the salad bar. We will definitely dine here again and plan to try some of the burgers and other sandwiches next time.“