41 Best American Restaurants near New Oxford

“All I can say Wow! We just left our first time in. We were not expected to be seated as we got here at 7:40pm and they close at 8, they welcomed us with open arms! Also, Erika who was our regular waitress at another location was there and she waited on us!!! Yay. Now to the food, nothing less than fabulous. Filet was cooked perfect and my crab imperial was amazing! We will be back for sure. Thank you for not turning us away and allowing us to enjoy our meal. Anywhere else would have made us feel like we needed to rush, not here, I will recommend Inn 94 a billion times over! Oh and hiring Erika was the best thing ever!“

“Love going to this place after working all night haha. They have a huge HUGE selection of gluten free breakfast foods and sweets that are always fresh, always changing and always amazing. Their coffee is really good too. If you have celiac or just prefer gluten free, I highly recommend stopping in here!“

“Carissa was our waitress and she was excellent! Our entrees and desserts were fantastic as well, but Carissa's great personality and professionalism made us decide that we will always ask to be seated in her section!“

“Whiskey Honey Brisket with Fabulously Toasted fries ,2 Yuengling lager drafts,2 double espresso & peanut butter cake ! Only $31.00 Fabulously Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious!!Poison Whiskey Outstanding Magnifico!!!No Cover charge ! Where in the Free World God's Green Earth will ya be able to find a better deal !Thank You“

“Just passing through and we were looking for something good and simple. This is a must stop if you want outstanding service and food. The mgr Shawn was a rare bird. Extremely friendly with his greetings and exits with everybody as well as every coworker in the place. If I didn’t live 1500 miles away this would most definitely be my favorite eatery.
Thank you for making our experience exceptional.“

“What a treat. Stopped in for tea just outside of Gettysburg. Every morsal was delicious. A must if you are in the area....we will be back for sure!!“

“We stopped by for supper May 30 2025. Our waitress was Alyssa she was wonderful helping me with my food allergies very thoughtful you have a wonderful worker in her.I had the ham with baked potato and cottage cheese my husband had the 2 smoked pork chops with a baked potato and cucumber salad the meal was wonderfully cooked well and so delicious Thank you for a great experience eating at you restaurant.“

“Very good. Awesome atmosphere“

“The only real restaurant we found! Gettysburg has lots of restaurants, all geared to tourists and fast food and/or fried food. This was a real restaurant with table clothes, good and healthy options, bread with the meal, and our waitress (wish I could remember her name, a lovely woman! with short hair with highlighted tips). It is in a hotel, but doesn't feel like it at all. Made me feel good to have a non rushed sit down dinner with excellent food!“

“The food stood out as literally everything we ate being on point. Prices are a little higher but the quality matches that. Personally I had the fried shrimp and house Mac and cheese and regretted none of it! The fried pickles were also somehow juicy but did not go soggy even after sitting for a good fifteen minutes. Server was amazing and good at recommending drinks. They also had live music playing which was very enjoyable. Overall really enjoyed ourselves and can see us coming back again soon💗“

“First visit was today and it was so good! Definitely recommend!“

“Today was my first visit to Firepit and I will definitely be back! The waitress (Alexa) was friendly and knowledgeable, the chicken shawarma bowl was insanely good and the restaurant was clean and had plenty of parking. Highly recommend!“

“We ate at Pattin' before seeing a Broadway show. We were seated immediately at a quaint table for 2 overlooking the street. The wine, the food (brussel sprouts, branzino, halibut), and the dessert (creme brule) were all amazing and we'd order every single item again. The service was also spectacular! The atmosphere was romantic and we loved being able to sit and talk while we experienced dining at Pattin'.“

“Had lunch at the upstairs bar today. Everything was wonderful.“

“My husband and I order from here at least once a week. They have great food, they are convenient to our location and they meet all our exceptions when it comes to take out orders. My favorite by far is their Philly Cheese Steak Pizza! Oh my gosh...it is so good. If you like the sub you will love the pizza.“

“Very outstanding,Delicious food. Service is beyond great! Chef Neil is there please. You will want to go back to Sidney's every chance you can.“

“Authentic Mexican food. Delicious.“

“You might remember us. We had reservations at 2pm on 8-22-26, we sat in the way back. First the jumbo crabs were awesome, we were very pleased. The staff always pleasant. We were on a date and we both just had the best time. Josh, thanks for our experience being something we will remember.“

“Good food , good prices , good service😊“

“In from out of state and just happened upon this fine little “dive bar”. The bartender was amazing, the food was ridiculously fantastic! If we’re ever back on this area, we will surely stop back!“

“My waitress was very nice. She had a beautiful smile on her face the entire time. She checked on us numerous times to make sure everything was perfect. The Hostess who seated us was welcoming and nice also. She sat us quickly and being over a high chair for my grandson even though he was sleep. Kim was the hostess and Krista was our waitress. They made the experience great and I would come back anytime they are working.“

“We went last Friday to celebrate a friends birthday. We just went in for drinks and appetizers so we went downstairs to the pub. I was surprised it was not very busy. The server came to the table in a reasonable time we ordered 2 beers and 2 martinis. It took a long time to get our drinks. The complimentary chips with balsamic were very good. I was disappointed in the appetizer selection. There were 3 soups, Brussels sprouts and crab dip. I was hoping for a few more options as our friends don’t like Brussels and I didn’t want soup to snack on. So we had crab dip and a lite fair item. Everything was very good but as soon as the server found out we were not planning on having dinner she essentially ghosted us. We still tipped her very well hoping it will boost her Evening and remind her not to brush off a table just because they are not having an entree. I look forward to going back. Everything we ate and drank were very good. I am eager To try more items. It was a nice place for celebrating with friends“

“I really love the food here, and never had a bad meal. We love going for breakfast and glad you changed from home fries to hash browns. But we don`t get there for breakfast much because you changed your hours. For us 10am is to late when you get up around 6am.Please try to open around 8am. I hate to have to go some place else for breakfast. Thank you“

“Tried it for the first time got the classic burger with bacon pieces and it was absolutely amazing and I let my daughter have a bite a she wanted to eat my whole burger… started running around the house yelling burger.. 😂 also ordered the Pierogi’s and they were good as well.. definitely worth trying. Although should have meal options… and more options period I saw other pics other ppl posted of other menus.. good place !“

“We went last Friday to celebrate a friends birthday. We just went in for drinks and appetizers so we went downstairs to the pub. I was surprised it was not very busy. The server came to the table in a reasonable time we ordered 2 beers and 2 martinis. It took a long time to get our drinks. The complimentary chips with balsamic were very good. I was disappointed in the appetizer selection. There were 3 soups, Brussels sprouts and crab dip. I was hoping for a few more options as our friends don’t like Brussels and I didn’t want soup to snack on. So we had crab dip and a lite fair item. Everything was very good but as soon as the server found out we were not planning on having dinner she essentially ghosted us. We still tipped her very well hoping it will boost her Evening and remind her not to brush off a table just because they are not having an entree. I look forward to going back. Everything we ate and drank were very good. I am eager To try more items. It was a nice place for celebrating with friends“

“We came here for dinner on a Saturday evening in September. We saw on Facebook that a musician we like was performing. Facebook has this listed as Center Square Brewing but the sign outside still says underside bar.

We sat at the bar. We ordered drinks and then dinner. I had the cashew crusted chicken and it was good. It came with two pieces of chicken and I took one home as leftovers. The steak meal was very good as well.

The bartender was friendly and attentive. There weren’t too many people down there. The atmosphere felt like a basement - I mean, it’s a little dark because it’s down stairs and there is no windows and everything is brown or dark colors. It was casual and relaxed. Prices were comparable to most other local places we go.

Parking was a free paved lot adjacent to the building.“

“My family and I visited Avalon Ale House not long ago and I felt I needed to share. The friendly staff was very attentive to our table. The exceptional food selection was a plus! I would recommend this to someone who has not visited and we will definitely be back again! Keep up the good work!!“

“Always go for breakfast and it’s always great! Excellent friendly service! Restaurant is very clean and plenty of parking.“

“We had a wonderful experience! The food was absolutely delicious, and my family really enjoyed everything. Our server, Emily, was exceptional! She was incredibly nice, pleasant, attentive, and made us feel so welcome throughout our entire meal.

Emily truly made an already great experience even better. Her wonderful personality and excellent service really stood out. We left happy, satisfied, and already looking forward to coming back!

Thank you, Emily, for making our family’s visit so enjoyable! We highly recommend this restaurant! ❤

-Alberto and fam“

“had another great experience at Dylan’s Bar in East Berlin! I ordered the ribs with mac and cheese and curly fries, and everything was absolutely excellent. The ribs were tender, flavorful, and cooked perfectly—they were just as good as the first time I came here and ordered them before. The mac and cheese was rich and delicious, and the curly fries were crispy and seasoned perfectly.

It’s always nice finding a place that stays consistent with both quality and service, and Dylan’s Bar definitely does that. The atmosphere was welcoming, and the staff was friendly and attentive throughout the visit.

After having such a great experience both times, I can confidently say I’ll definitely be coming back again. Highly recommend to anyone looking for great food and a great dining experience! 10/10 if you want amazing food you have to go!“

“Great bartender! Love Missy, so friendly! Very nice atmosphere! Good food!“

“Delicious Texas weiner and fries. Very fast and friendly service.“

“food was fresh and delicious minus missing hash browns“

“Finally had the opportunity to stop in for lunch with the wife and I can 100% see why this place has been around for over 100 years! The "Everything" dogs were fantastic! We will definitely be back!“

“We had a buffet style meal for 32 people and it was just awesome. The food was hot and delicious the server was a gem. Definitely would recommend for your gatherings.“

“What a night! I finally took Cooper for his 1st Lobster. After watching lots of “Coyote Peterson” uTube videos for a couple months, he’d been asking me to take him to eat one. Today was the day. Thank you to Hanovers Red Lobster & their General Manager Michael, he gave us the ultimate educational experience & even sat down with us & showed Cooper how to eat it. Mike got the meat out while Cooper ate it 😂😂. Cooper loved every bite of it & dipped it in his “hot warm butter”. He suggested his 8 year old friend Mia, try a “no thank you bite” ( that’s my rule ! 😂) And, she liked it! It was so funny! Had a great time. Cooper had a blast & enjoyed having Mia join him too!! Thanks so much Michael, for accommodating my request, you’re the best👍😀“

“Food was good, service great. Drinks delish!!“

“We have been to Taphouse 6 twice and we weren't disappointed. The food is amazing and the waitstaff is wonderful! Terry, our waitress, is pretty awesome too! We highly recommend 👌“

“Steak was done right. Nice and tender BUT it was sooooo salty. Never had one like this. Potato had extra salt on skin also. Waiter acted like he didnt even care.“

“Great place to watch football games 🏈“

“I am a regular at this Denny's. Not just because of the food, but the staff here. Nicole, Heather and Eric always make me feel welcome, like my presence is truly appreciated. They have a warm, pleasant personality, and are always very apologetic if they're temporarily out of something I order. I always look forward to seeing the crew at this location, and will keep coming back here because of them.“