50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Dallastown

“We had some errands in the area this evening and I just did not feel like cooking when we were done, however it was 8:15 on a Tuesday night. We live in Jacobus, but we were coming from Red Lion and we stopped at 5 local pizza places on the way towards home. Two closed at 8:00 one was closing at 8:30 and two weren't even open at all today. Just as I was about to give up my son mentioned Roma's on South Queen Street in Dallastown because he said he and his buddies would often go there after football practice this past fall and that the owners were really nice and the food was amazing.

By now it was 8:40 and we really wanted to sit down and eat not take it home and eat it cold, so I went in and asked the owner if he would mind if we would order in, if we tried to hurry and promised once we saw they were ready to walk out after clean up, we would scramble to get out of there so as not to keep them late.

His kindness was so amazing and he insisted I bring the rest of my family in to dine in. That included my daughter and my 4-month-old granddaughter along with my 14-year-old son. The owner and the other gentleman working with him were so friendly. Once we placed our order they just went on about their business sweeping and mopping and doing regular closing activities but both the owner and his employee took the time to make a little bit of small talk and tgey both even fussed over my granddaughter! The owner actually took the time out to come over and asked if the vacuum cleaner would scare her and was also concerned about the overhead ceiling fan being too cold for her. Of course we told him to go on about his work and the vacuum would not bother her and the ceiling fan was just fine. I was just blown away by the service we received, 20 minutes before closing time!!!

We will definitely be back that is for sure! And by the way, my fourteen-year-old was right, the food was amazing!“

“We had planned a pizza party after our lacrosse practice, but a thunderstorm threw a wrench in our outdoor plans. We called the shop to see if we could bring 25 athletes and coaches into the store instead, and they went above and beyond to accommodate us. When we arrived, the staff had reserved tables prepared and the pizzas were already set out for us. The staff was courteous, friendly, and made us feel right at home. We truly appreciate their support for local youth sports teams. It's businesses like this that make our community so special. Thank you for helping to make our event a success!“

“Great People and well done Pizza they always come thru! Been going to through them for the past 4 years! So glad they are apart of our community.“

“High praise for excellent customer service, my family are regular customers of Mignano's Pizza. My daughter lost her handmade doll a few weeks ago. Yesterday, when my wife went in to pick up a delicious stromboli the owner said, "I think I have your daughter's doll." For him to have kept this doll for weeks is so touching. My daughter cried with joy that it was found and returned home. Thank you 1000x for being the best! This is the kind of customer service that makes life long patrons.“

“Everything was good, but I asked for a side of marinara for my large cheese steak and I get a 2 oz container lol. Thanks for the one bite of marinara.“

“So I called in a pick up order of a pizza and mozzarella sticks. When I called I mentioned I had a coupon (from their menu) for a large cheese pizza for 10.99. The girl on the phone said bring it with me. So I did. I went to pick it up; gave her the coupon and she looked at her coworker and showed it to him and she said I don't think we're taking this right now. So I told her it's from the menu I had at home and her response was "we go through phases of when we take them." Didn't even bother to ask management. Now there was no expiration date on it mind you and no one said that on the phone. So what started out as a 17.00 order was now 27.00. Sometimes you have to go above and beyond to avoid these types of reviews. GREAT customer service would have been easily accepting YOUR own coupon. If you go through "phases" don't print the coupon bc the consumer doesn't know when your phases take place. This could've easily been a 4 or 5 star. The food tastes great but the "phases" comment left me floored.“

“stopped there this week for the first time and all I can say is WOW !!GREAT SERVICE AND WHAT A GOOD STROMBOLI!!! packed full. my new place!!“

“I love their food and I love their location and the staff is awesome!“

“We love this place! Very friendly staff! We love their Stromboli ! Highly recommended!“

“We had Tiffany as our server, she is absolutely a fantastic person who took excellent care of us. Highly recommended! Food and service were top notch.“

“This is my favorite place for pizza and kids food, but I had never tried their Lasagna until today! I’m really “picky” when it comes to Lasagna, but I needed to cheer myself up 😆, and I was so glad I did! The garlic bread is perfectly done and the Lasagna exceeded my expectations! Highly recommend Memory Lane!! ,“

“Joe has good food and great service. Place is always clean.“

“We get pizza al bacio AT LEAST once a week. Love that it’s close, delicious and fast! Never disappointed and salads are always fresh!“

“Literally one of the best pizza spots I’ve been to. Everything is always so fresh and SO good. The pizza is amazing, wings are incredible, and you can genuinely tell they care about the quality of the food. The portions are great also. I’ve had an incredible experience every time. The staff is always super nice and welcoming which makes it that much better! ive also gotten to know the owners and they’re the most generous people ever!! Definitely one of those places you try once and keep coming back to. 10/10 every single time!!!“

“Kylie took good care of us tonight. The food was delicious, as always, and very reasonably priced. We even had some pizza and stromboli left to take along home with us for another meal.“

“I cannot even begin to express how grateful we are for the kindness and exceptional service provided by Jim & Nena's. After a failed delivery with GrubHub it was much needed!! They were patient with GrubHub and my husband as all 3 worked together in rectifying the situation (which was no fault of the restaurant). They not only offered to deliver our order themselves (so we could stop dealing with GrubHub), but also gave us an additional pizza!! Ps. The bacon cheese fries were LOADED in cheese & bacon & they were absolutely delicious. We will certainly be stopping here more often (rather than ordering through GrubHub).“

“Delicious subs! My husband raved about the Joe’s Special Cheesesteak and my son said he’s never had a better fish sub. The owners were incredibly friendly and kind. Would definitely order from here again.“

“I wish you guys were close to us in Va. your food is amazing and the staff is friendly!!!!“

“Bagels are delicious! AND she puts the right amount of cream cheese on it!! Go get some 😋“

“We order from Wrightsville Pizza often. We are so pleased every time with the PERFECT flavors in the crust and sauce. Always baked to our liking. Customer Service is 5 stars, always. Highly recommend these guys for your Friday and Saturday weekly pizza needs. Well, any day really.“

“We have never been to this restaurant before but it was recommended by a friend of ours. Since we was in the area last night we called in a order. The guy who took my order was very pleasant. I just want to say that their food is excellent. I got the gizmo cheeseburger sub and my husband got the tuna boat. My sub was the best cheeseburger sub that I have ever had . I had a bite of my husband's sub and I would definitely get one of those also. It's a little pricey but it is well worth the price. It is not small portions, they give you your money's worth. I would highly recommend this place. We will be back!!“

“Thank you for feeding my goalie weekly! Your smoothies are SO good and your menu keeps things fresh. We appreciate you!“

“Visiting York from out of town. I had an inch to eat some Stromboli like one does in Pennsylvania. We were lucky enough Shakey Jakes was open until 11. My team and I visited and most of us ordered a Boli. We were told a small would feed one person. So I ordered a large. Holy Stromboli, this thing was huge. I only got through half but I brought it home so I can enjoy it for the next two days. It was so good I felt like it was sent from heaven above. This was EASILY the best food I have ever eaten in Pennsylvania. I can't recommend Shakey Jakes enough. Can't wait to go there again in 3 days when I finally finish my large Boli.“

“Good variety and great tasting pizza“

“I don’t come here often, but every time I do, the experience is amazing! The employees are so kind and weren’t just bland people with no emotion. They were all really helpful at making sure we were satisfied with our order. The place is really clean too and well maintained. There is a bathroom at the end of the building, which is also very clean. The pizza was quick at being made and tasted really good. The crust for mostly all the pizza is very thin though, so keep that in mind.“

“Great pies and excellent meatballs. Thanks Maria“

“I had an online order. When I got to Mod on Pauline Drive, the staff were very kind and friendly! It was definitely a different atmosphere than other Mods that I’ve been to. The prices are getting expensive, but coming to this Mod pizza was definitely worth it! Thank you!“

“Absolutely love this place! The pizza is always fresh, perfectly baked, and loaded with flavor. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the atmosphere makes it a great spot to relax with friends or grab a quick bite. Easily one of the best pizza shops in town! (I live in Lancaster by the way and it’s ALWAYS worth the drive) check it out you won’t regret it!“

“Alex and his team are awesome. They were great hosts for our team meal, and went above & beyond to take care of our group. Great food and even better people. We will be having more team meals there over the course of the year. Thank you for your hospitality!“

“We love eating at Touch of Italy. Never disappointed!! It's time to take a road trip to Hallam PA.“

“Friendly...welcomed as soon as I walked in. Extremely clean..prep bar exceptionally clean. Service was awesome....Tania was very nice...answered all my questions when asked options and ssssoooooo many to choose from!!!!... She was extremely polite.. I will visit this resturant if I am ever in the area because the service was amazing... and Tania's positivity!!!! Great job, MOD pizza!!!! BTW....the pizza was delicious!!!😀“

“I love the chunky marinara pasta so much. It has big cloves of garlic in it and it’s absolutely delicious. I also really enjoyed their strawberry cosmopolitans, I love that they send out text coupons and I will definitely always come here for a good authentic Italian dinner.“

“Absolutely delicious, the pizza was super goodness that I haven't had in a long time. Crew is efficient and friendly.

Note... if you are a single guy, just go here the ladies from the beauty school walk down and eat lunch here. You are bound to meet someone.“

“One of the best pizza joints in York“

“We were looking for a new pizza place that had wood fired and/or brick oven pizza options. This place came up. We tried it and it was great. I’ve been to this location when it was a different restaurant but haven’t been back in years. I will definitely be coming back soon!“

“Their pizza and staff are awesome.“

“they have the greatest subs around and the people are amazing I love them!“

“We ordered a large works pizza for lunch today, we wanted to try a new place. Excellent service and personality and the pizza is at the top of my favorites, excellent, excellent, excellent. 10 out of 10. Highly recommend everyone try them out. You won’t be disappointed!!!!!!!“

“This was our first time at this restaurant in East Prospect. We were amazed at the quality of the Build Your Own Cheese Steaks.... plenty of met and tons a we requested. In fact, we will actually have two meals out of these sandwiches. The flavor was great on both subs and the cheese curds. We will go back for more!“

“Great food ,service is fantastic ,owners and staff are the best. Highly recommend Marcello’s.“

“Great service and the pizza and wings are amazing“

“Waiters were extremely professional and on point with service. Pleasantly surprised with service considering these are younger generation workers. Kudos! We will be going back every Christmas Eve!“

“The food is always delicious and served hot. We been eating there for 20 years.“

“Any time I have a craving for some late night pizza after a long day at work this is my go to. They NEVER disappoint. Toppings on my pizza are always a decent amount. Its hard to find that quality anymore these days and Red Rose has always brought top notch quality and service. Ill always say this is my favorite spot to eat pizza.“

“Ww went today for the first time as we were visiting York College. Everything was hot and delicious. Can't wait to go back and try something different as there were many options.“

“walked in the door and sat to the right the kid behind the counter watched us walk in and sit down. 5 minutes later he delivered a drink to a table on the other side of the room he looked over at us and went back behind the counter we sat there for almost 10 more minutes so we walked out. he never said one word to us at all“

“I ordered through door dash as opposed to them directly and my ordered got delayed a little bit because of an error on the drivers end. Once I did finally get my pizza , EVEN A LITTLE COLD the pizza was PHENOMENAL… i can’t get over how great it tasted and was suprised I never ordered there before… definitely got a new customer with my family… was told their pretzel boil is a must try and will be the next thing I order…
Def would recommend to everyone.“

“If you’re looking for amazing pizza in York, you have to try Pizza Boli’s! 🍕 The pizza was absolutely delicious—fresh, hot, and full of flavor. We enjoyed every bite and will definitely be coming back. It was a wonderful experience. Thank you, Pizza Boli’s! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“We always order never eat in or pick up. The pizza is always good. They offer coupons and rewards so we never pay full price. Emad delivers and is an absolute joy of a delivery person. We have a family of four and it’s cheaper than McDonald’s AND they deliver! No door dash fees!! We love this place!!“

“Had a great lunch today from Marcello’s in Red Lion. Thanks for the great food and quick service!! #BuyLocal #SupportLocal“