26 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shrewsbury

“Vincent’s Deli is an absolute gem! The food was incredibly delicious—fresh, flavorful, and made with care. Every bite exceeded my expectations. The service was equally impressive—friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming from start to finish. You can tell they truly care about their customers and take pride in what they do. Highly recommend!“

“Son of Sicily is a excellent place to eat, food is excellent and the staff is always friendly and welcoming. The main reason for this review is the excellent pizza I just ate. I just had the Grandma pizza with bacon and banana peppers, my favorite combo. It was so delicious, everything was perfect. I just found my new favorite pizza. I’ve had the same toppings on a regular pizza, but on the Grandma the sauce is sweeter and more savory. Definitely a winner! Thanks Sons of Sicily crew!“

“One of the best pizza joints in York“

“The pizza was surprisingly good. I haven’t had Little Caesars in a couple years so decided to try them out. I will say the only thing is there needs to be more pizza sauce, but other than that the pizza was good and you can’t beat the prices. They have the cheapest pizza around. My kids loved the pizza too.“

“Yesterday was our last time ordering from Sal's. We have had issues for the past year. I'm very disappointed because Sal's used to be my favorite restaurant for over a decade. However, I will not be suggesting your restaurant anymore. Our pizza was dry and burnt in the crust, the salad was bad, the chicken on it was also dry and had no flavor .. no dressing was packed in the bag, Additionally, the buffalo chicken wrap had watered down sauce buffalo sauce and maybe blue cheese dressing??? Not a crumble. The whole wrap was a soggy mess. It was a weekday order...early evening, not a busy time.“

“Great service and very nice young man waiting on us good pizza“

“High praise for excellent customer service, my family are regular customers of Mignano's Pizza. My daughter lost her handmade doll a few weeks ago. Yesterday, when my wife went in to pick up a delicious stromboli the owner said, "I think I have your daughter's doll." For him to have kept this doll for weeks is so touching. My daughter cried with joy that it was found and returned home. Thank you 1000x for being the best! This is the kind of customer service that makes life long patrons.“

“One of the newest pizza/boli shops in York is one of it's most unique. It's tucked back in the ever changing Olde Tollgate Village. The layout and decor is warm and inviting once you get past the construction in the lobby.

We tried a plain cheese pizza and a chicken parmeson stromboli. The dough/crust is pillowy and fluffy with firmness on the outside similar to a focaccia. The first thing to hit is the size. This is a huge stromboli with a perfect amount of filling that comes with two containers of sauce. So many places screw up the boli to sauce ratio. There is a parmesan herb mix sprinkled on the top which was great. Absolutely the best stromboli I have had in the entire York area.

The pizza was perfectly cheesy with a good amount of sauce. Most of the pizza was fantastic, however, there's a twist that while it looks amazing to have cheese overflow the crust it's not what you expect. Its a large amount of melted Asiago cheese which can be overpowering. The most popular pizzerias in all of New York typically sprinkle a little finely grated as a finisher before serving. The edge of the crust here is buried in it. The strong flavor is not for everyone.

If I could give them 4.5 stars I would. I'm going with 4 until they dial back the asiago.“

“Joe has good food and great service. Place is always clean.“

“Came into this place on a whim today, and SO glad I did! The thin crust pizza was amazing - brought home half and it crisped right back up when I reheated it. Also had a cheese steak Stromboli which was delish. The Italian sub I had needed more meat and cheese inside of it, but good flavors. The waitress was super friendly and attentive. We will definitely be back!“

“Never disappointed - Good food, fairly priced, friendly service!“

“The best !!!! I highly recommend everything, we love the Pizza, cheesesteaks and The Mediterranean salads. A true gem of York.“

“Not only does Melania Pizza have great food (with amazing homemade bread), but the owner is amazing to work with on our large sub orders that we do for our co-op. Highly recommend!!“

“Absolutely love this place! The pizza is always fresh, perfectly baked, and loaded with flavor. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the atmosphere makes it a great spot to relax with friends or grab a quick bite. Easily one of the best pizza shops in town! (I live in Lancaster by the way and it’s ALWAYS worth the drive) check it out you won’t regret it!“

“all I can say is I love doing what I did I love doing what I do and I am just so happy that Matt shover shover is doing such a wonderful job and keeping our family tradition extending more than five generations he's doing a wonderful job and I appreciate everyone who ever walked through them my door just like myself I know Matt and his family welcome you through his doors thank you.“

“The food is always hot, made quickly, and ready as expected. Friendly people! The only time I got a wrong sandwich, they made things right the next visit. AMAZING pizza, and sandwiches with that delicious, authentic bread, just so yummy! We have been going there for awhile, highly recommend!“

“I always always always stop in here when I’m in York to pick up a large cheese. The pizza is always solid which I appreciate. It’s kind of a no frills joint with a lot of Italian options. The service is fast and the staff is always pretty pleasant“

“Great pies and excellent meatballs. Thanks Maria“

“After a difficult day I wanted to treat myself to one of my favorite local meals… the decadent Fettuccine Alfredo at Paesano’s. I was greeted with a bright-eyed smile by Sara, and when she recognized my trials- she offered a hug & prayers. I won’t soon forget that! I already loved this restaurant, but having Sara to greet guests is a bonus! Thank you for showing exactly what’s great about supporting small businesses.“

“I would like to Thank your Company for donating pizza to DASD to hand out for lunch during the COVID 19 quarantine. You have made 3 kiddos very happy.“

“The food is always delicious and served hot. We been eating there for 20 years.“

“If you call in an order take your birth certificate, social security card, passport, and photo ID. Your name and exact order will not do. Owner told me to get off his property. Heard other customers say the same“

“We always order never eat in or pick up. The pizza is always good. They offer coupons and rewards so we never pay full price. Emad delivers and is an absolute joy of a delivery person. We have a family of four and it’s cheaper than McDonald’s AND they deliver! No door dash fees!! We love this place!!“

“We had planned a pizza party after our lacrosse practice, but a thunderstorm threw a wrench in our outdoor plans. We called the shop to see if we could bring 25 athletes and coaches into the store instead, and they went above and beyond to accommodate us. When we arrived, the staff had reserved tables prepared and the pizzas were already set out for us. The staff was courteous, friendly, and made us feel right at home. We truly appreciate their support for local youth sports teams. It's businesses like this that make our community so special. Thank you for helping to make our event a success!“

“I ordered tonight's dinner for the family in a pinch because I didn't have the chance to grocery shop today (Busy).First thing the food was made lightning quick so always a good start. The food was ON POINT, Also want to mention it was made exactly how I ordered it. Light sauce was actually light sauce and cooked well done as asked also. I would have taken better pictures for the review but the food didn't survive long. A+ keep up the good work. Btw the pick 2 for 6.99 each is killer it your not trying to kill your wallet.“

“although I still recommend domino's because they're usually good, tonight was the first time we ever got lousy food. maybe they were short staffed? too busy? just plain lazy? idk. But our pizza was missing 2 toppings and the crust was charred black, the cheesy bread was like a sponge full of grease, and the cheesesteak was so salty in was almost inedible. what gives you guys? we never got food this bad before, ever. seems like we got tricked instead of treated. step it up guys and girls because we can take our business elsewhere. 🙄“