20 Best Sandwich Shops in Lancaster

Bobby Bay's Sandwich Shop Sandwich Shop • $
1878 Lincoln Hwy E, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Cali Cheesesteak Hoagie
Nashville Hot Sandwich
Bobby’S Cheesesteak
Nashville Hot Chicken
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chicken Cheesesteak
Baked Potato Salad
Caprese Sandwich
Crispy Chicken
Fries Takeout

“Sub was DELICIOUS other than the bread over baked. Will deff order again.“

4.9 Superb203 Reviews
Prince Of Subs Sandwich Shop • $
147 S Prince St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Catfish Fillet and Roll with French Fries and Cole Slaw
Large Chicken Tenders 5 with French Fries \u0026 Roll
Large Chicken Tenders 5 with French Fries & Roll
Philadelphia Cheesesteak Sub
Dinner French Fries and Roll
Fried Jumbo Butterfly Shrimp
Fresh Made Cole Slaw Small
Single Catfish Fillet
Fried Chicken Wings
Philly Cheesesteak

“Not only do you guys sell the most amazing food at reasonable prices you guys are just awesome thank you so much for everything you do in serving this community and the sad world that we live in and bringing light and love and kindness and affordable delicious food beyond words God bless“

4.7 Superb98 Reviews
The Grille Sandwich Shop • $
241 W Roseville Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich and Cheeseburger Hoagie
Philly Cheese Steak Hoagie
Cheeseburger Hoagies
Chicken Cheesesteak
Philly Cheesesteak
Pastrami Sandwich
lg Cheese Steak
Cold Sandwiches
Cheese Fries
Waffle Fries

“Ordered fish sandwiches for takeout tonight, paid over the phone and they brought the sandwiches out to the car. They were absolutely delicious!!! We go here at least once a week and are never disappointed.“

4.4 Superb106 Reviews
Savoy Truffle Sandwich Shop • $
398 Harrisburg Ave #250, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Grilled Cheese with Fries
Pulled Pork Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Strawberry Shortcake Jar Cake
Bacon Egg Cheese Sandwich
Birthday Cake
Loaded Fries
Bagel

“Absolutely amazing food great service!!! I got the loaded breakfast tot!!! 10/10 RECOMMEND!!!! Thank you savory truffle for a wonderful meal!!!“

4.5 Superb121 Reviews
Captain Gus's Steak Shop Sandwich Shop • $
600 W Orange St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Steak No Onion
Large Cheesesteak
lg Cheese Steak
Cheese Burger
French Fries
Crab Stick
Fish Sub

“great food great people that work there they're all friendly and helpful“

4.3 Superb110 Reviews
Speed's Sandwich Shop • $
318 E King St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cheese Steak
Cheesesteak and Fries
Philly Cheese Steak
Original Steak Sub
Large Cheese Steak
Small Turkey Sub
Fresh Cut Fries
Steak Sandwich
Cheeseburger
Onion Rings

“If I could leave six stars I would I went in by chance I walk past this joint every day and never noticed it til today so as I was walking back from doing some shopping in town I stopped in not knowing this place from any other steak joint as I am not from this town I am a recent arrival as of the last couple months I got back to my place of residence and I opened it up and let me tell you what I saw was a culinary masterpiece if ever one could be made of such a sandwich this is an amazing cheese steak I opted for the XL because i figured I would have a piece and save the rest for another meal boy was I wrong I already polished off half this thing and it was huge I am glad I took a picture before this is by far the best cheese steak I have had in quite a few years bar none and this is coming from someone who grew up in Philly where we are known for our cheese steaks. I will definitely be back to this place the kid at the counter and I guess the other fellow was his grandmother worked so well together the kid who took my order was very personable and helpful and even allowed me to drink my soda then have a smoke outside before I even paid for my order I am very very pleased Speeds has a new customer you will see me again just remember I am the tall handsome older gentleman heavily tattooed all over my body who was wearing the Abercrombie sweater. This place is amazing hands down if you don't know now you know better tell somebody and spread the joy ten bucks for a huge steak this thing is so heavy you could use this sandwich as a weapon if you needed to I carried it down E King Street like it was a baseball bat . Thanks guys great experience.“

4.2 Good89 Reviews
Bruno's at Greenfield Sandwich Shop • $
555 Greenfield Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

13 Spicy Italian Hoagie 1 2 Hoagie
Pastrami on Rye
Roast Beef

“We brought a Bruno's sub home from Lancashire car show today. It was best sub I've had in a while. Will have one again.“

4.2 Good46 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
2232 Lincoln Hwy E, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Roast Beef and Provolone
The Original Italian
Club Supreme

“Today I had the Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak and it did not disappoint! First of all, it was loaded with Franks Red Hot but not so much that it leaked. I was able to eat it with a minimum of napkin use. Second was the perfect layering of toppings. Most every bit was a great combination of all ingredients and, when I got down to the last couple of bits with just a little meat, I had the sauce on the sandwich wrap to dip the sandwich in! This cheesesteak was SO much better than another buffalo chicken sandwich I regularly enjoy. I will be back for reasons like this, the great customer service and friendly atmosphere as well!“

4 Good82 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
1581 Fruitville Pike Suite 2, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Cheese Steak
Club Supreme Mikes Way
Chipotle Cheese Steak
Italian Sub Mikes Way
Mikes Way Italian Sub
Turkey Sub Mikes Way
The Original Italian
Mikes Italian Sub
Chicken Cheese
Cheese Steaks

“First time getting to go subs and won't be the last!! absolutely delicious subs !! This may be my sub go to spot😃 And the service was even better yet...Thank you“

4 Good79 Reviews
10

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
245 Centerville Rd Unit #7, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Marinara
Italian B M T
Cookies

“It's definitely the best subway I've been to. The food was good, and the employees were actually nice, which is rare, honestly. Oh, and definitely the nicest subway interior I've seen. There's a TV and a fireplace even with a couch“

4 Good44 Reviews
That Panini Place Sandwich Shop • $$
2249 Lincoln Hwy E, Lancaster

“Wonderful experience! Clean, and fun rides“

5 Superb5 Reviews
Boar's Head Sandwiches Sandwich Shop • $$
Lancaster Shopping Center, Lancaster

“I live a few minutes from Bobby Bay’s, and I am on a mission to try everything on the menu. My husband and I love the loaded fries (the horseradish in the cheese?! To die for). Thanks for bringing a great sandwich shop to this side of town. You have a loyal customer with me!“

5 Superb5 Reviews
PrimoHoagies Sandwich Shop • $
2085 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Primo Size Hoagies Only
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Sandwich
Sharp Italian
Chicken Diablo
Old Italian
Potato Chip
Bada Bing
Turkey

“Delicious hoagies everytime- and great service! Thank you!“

3.7 Good82 Reviews
Firehouse Subs Lime Spring Square Sandwich Shop • $
120 Rohrerstown Rd #8A, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Meatball Sub
Turkey Clubhouse Sandwich
Hook \u0026 Ladder Combo
Firehouse Steak & Cheese
Firehouse Meatball
Brisket Sandwich
Firehouse Steak
Hook & Ladder
Italian Sub

“We had ordered delivery last night after neither me nor my fiance felt like cooking after work, food got here and everything was actually pretty freaking good.
My big issue is that we got our daughter a kids combo that only had chocolate milk as an option for a drink, but my daughter was excited as she loves chocolate milk. That was not in any of the bags unfortunately. If they didn't have any, the store failed to communicate that to the delivery driver as we did ask.
Their kids subs are also less than a quarter size of the subs we ordered, which did not match the size of the kids sub in the pictures, so I ended up having to cook food for my daughter while I was trying to eat because it was 4 bites of bread, cheese, and meat. So my 3 year old childs food was treated like a joke while they made the rest of the food just fine.

I contacted Uber and they refunded the entire child's combo, but I still wanted to put the review so others are aware. Even if it was later in the evening, tired and ready to go home is not an excuse to completely ruin a little kids meal. Being the only meal with an issue made it seem almost intentional as well so whoever is in charge at firehouse needs to be aware if it was.“

3.7 Good99 Reviews
Isaac's Restaurant - Centerville Sandwich Shop • $
245 Centerville Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pterodactyl Sandwich with Tortellini Deli Salad
Our Famous Pepperjack Tomato Soup
Pretzel Roll Sandwich and Soup
Almond Pesto Tortellini Salad
Fudgie Wudgie Sundae
Isaac's Reuben
Club Sandwich
French Fries
Mallard
Phoenix

“In the area for a one-day business trip in the middle of the week. Stopped here for a quick lunch before a customer meeting. We had 25 minutes. We chose this place because it was near to my husband’s customer location. The service was prompt, the people are friendly and the food is excellent with good portions at a very reasonable price. My husband and I shared a large bowl of pepper jack tomato soup and The Hawaiian sub sandwich with homemade potato chips. We had plenty of food. They even cut the sandwich in half, gave us separate plates with our own portion of chips without charging us extra for sharing the meal. Highly recommend this 5-star place. You'll get your full for certain.“

3.6 Good81 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
2481 Lincoln Hwy E #2, Lancaster

“Great quality food, always friendly service and clean place. Only reason for 4 stars is every time I go, there is only 1 person doing everything. Same person taking orders in restaurant, doing drive thru and making subs. Really should have at least 2-3 people especially during lunch hours. Takes awhile for 1 person to do all of that.“

3.5 Good32 Reviews
Isaac's Craft Kitchen & Brewery - Greenfield Sandwich Shop • $
565 Greenfield Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pepper Jack Tomato Soup
Smoked Turkey Sandwich
Reuben Sandwich
Finch Sandwich
Isaac's Reuben
Mallard

“In this area full of large stomach filling meals, you just want soup and a sandwich and with out the feeling that its mass made. This particular Isaacs even has BREWS! I highly recommend this restaurant!“

3.5 Good91 Reviews
18

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
1581-1583 Manheim Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Italian
Chicken

“Visited the Subway on Manheim Pike, and ordered 4 subs, all different. Two young guys (I think they said their names were Anthony and Efron, excuse spelling) took our order and were incredibly pleasant and helpful. Always a great experience at this location!“

3.2 Average37 Reviews
19

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
796 New Holland Ave Suite C, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Savory Rotisserie-Style Chicken Caesar Signature Wrap
Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki
Cold Cut Combo
Spicy Italian
Cookies

“I was there last night, March 28 around 7pm after a long day and I have to say the young man behind the counter was so kind. I stopped to get a foot long tuna and the guy was so awesome the way he talked to me, treated me and just so kind. He helped me quickly but was wonderful to talk to. I wanted to make sure he got the recognition. Sadly I didn't get his name.“

3.2 Average42 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
1835 Oregon Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sub

“Tried the Lulu sub yesterday. Delicious! I usually get the Italian Night Club. Grateful for freaky fast service too!“

3.3 Good65 Reviews

You May Also Like