23 Best Ice Cream Shops near Loganville

“I moved from York County over 30 years ago, it is great see that something this good is still around, and as wonderful as it was then.“

“Love this local, family owned business. They are a huge part of our local community and we appreciate everything you do! Love your chocolate milk and ice cream. 🩷“

“Amazing flavor variety. Staff is friendly and goes above and beyond to help! Ice cream is (the best, in my opinion) the soft more custard consistency and every bite is delicious! I will be here all the time now!“

“perfect everything was amazing and I'd go here again would recommend to anyone“

“the kids absolutely love their ice cream and going upstairs to play games. told the girl behind the counter to surprise me with a good coffee but it had to be sugar free.....she did amazing....highly recommend this cozy little gem“

“We come all the way from Massachusetts and always stop for ice cream and breakfast! The food is always so delicious and of course the ice cream! The staff is so nice and we love seeing them every year! We even get the best souvenirs to bring home! Johnny is hilarious and always so fun to have as our waiter! And you can't forget about Laura one of the most kind,caring person❤️! Be sure to check out the wall of pictures we are on there!! Till next year❤️“

“Loved since we moved to PA in 2002, near the Stewartstown area, back when it was Summer’s. Young people, high school & college age, work there. They are very nice. When I order my milkshake extra thick, they listen. Soooo, yummy. Our kids, grandkids, my mom, and dog love it. Bubby always orders the Puppy Cup, even though he’s 12 now. Rita’s and Baskin Robbin’s are good, but nothing beats Bonkey’s.“

“Loved since we moved to PA in 2002, near the Stewartstown area, back when it was Summer’s. Young people, high school & college age, work there. They are very nice. When I order my milkshake extra thick, they listen. Soooo, yummy. Our kids, grandkids, my mom, and dog love it. Bubby always orders the Puppy Cup, even though he’s 12 now. Rita’s and Baskin Robbin’s are good, but nothing beats Bonkey’s.“

“Hands down the best ice cream in York. Even with long lines. They move you through pretty quickly. Highly recommend the blue monster or New York cheesecake“

“Best roll ice cream and lots of drink options.“

“I stop by to thank Zoe for preparing my Blizzard just the way I like it! I only have one recommendation and it is for the store, I think they should update their system to be able to place the order through the app. I really don't come here because I don't accumulate points and I always have to order here. Much success and blessings!“

“I love thier ice cream & the people are very respectful!!“

“If I am in the area, I always stop at Sarah's Creamery. My son graduated from Penn State, and we got hooked on Penn State Ice Cream. Sarah's is the only place I know that has Penn State Ice Cream other than Penn State! My favorite is "Peachy Paterno"! I stopped in Sarah's Creamery today and got my Peachy Paterno Ice cream cone. It's the best treat ever! If you are ever in the area, you must stop in Sarah's Creamery and try the Penn State Ice Cream!“

“My granddaughter wanted to go to Rita’s so we stopped here. Of course the dessert was great. She always gets hers with the ice cream on the top and the bottom!!!
It was a nice treat for warm and sunny day. The server was very friendly and quick.“

“it's awesome they should make a store all year. we go to east York and loucks everybody is so awesome. the lady in east York let's us try the ice in case we don't like it she goes above and beyond. They should make Christmas kinds also. see you all next year thank you Rita's my daughter loves this place“

“Very friendly staff. Great place.“

“The service depends on employees and how far you are sitted from bar. Locals get all the speedy service and conversation which makes waiting on our meals more irritating.“

“Great place to visit on a hot day. Fast service and cold shaved ice treats 🍧“

“I had a great experience at this Dunkin' Donuts! Gabby, who waited on us, was incredibly sweet and kind — she really made our visit extra special. The facility was spotless, and I was especially impressed by how accessible it was. My friend is handicapped, and the ramp was conveniently located right next to the parking area, which made everything so easy for us. It was such a pleasant visit, and I’ll definitely be coming back again. Thank you, Gabby and the team! The one on Queen Street in Dallastown!“

“Yummmmm. Very good 👍 will be back!!“

“I love this crumbl so much and good service everything was good

Parking: It was kind of full when i went to go buy cookies but it was worth the drive

Kid-friendliness: I love this crumbl cookie they were so nice and helpful and i just love it“

“Everyone on their staff serves with smiles! 😃 Their fun social media keeps the public informed of yummy new things to try. 🍓 With Italian ice made fresh daily, and options for individuals to large events, this spot is great for all occasions! 🍦“

“After a certain number of purchases, you are entitled to a "free" cup. My "free cup cost me over $6. The "free"cup is up to a $5 value. The price is based on weight. We usually go when there is a $5 fill up. When the cashier said you still owe 6+dollars, I almost said forget it. By that point, it is difficult to just walk away. Suppose it was my own fault but I felt a little taken advantage . The Shrewsbury location will just give it to you, no charge. Perhaps, that has changed.I shouldn't complain for something free, right, but I can get a gut busting banana split for $6.50 at Mack's.The multitude of toppings and flavors makes for an excellent custom made dessert to your liking. Just sign up for texts so you know it is a $5 fill-up day. A family of 4 could easily spend $40 to $50 for an ice cream treat otherwise.“