22 Best Ice Cream Shops near Bainbridge

“You won’t find a better deal to take your family out for dinner and ice cream. The portion sizes are amazingly generous, especially for the ice cream and fries. Remember cash, since that’s all they accept. Gigi makes fantastic sides herself!Kid-friendliness: If you plan ahead and dine inside, there are lunch boxes filled with fun old school toys and activities.“

“We ordered a milkshake. Notified staff we had a gluten allergy. they made sure to clean/sanitize blender. Staff was very friendly! Will definitely be back“

“tried mango ice cream, mango coconut ice cream, tequila ice cream and all soooo good. lots of unique flavors that you dont see in other ice cream shops. also if you go you NEED to get the horchata it might be my favorite thing i got from there id drink their horchata instead of water if i could. and not sure of exact hours or days but when i went over a weekend they had a food truck out and i got 2 steak tacos with js the cilantro and onion and they were so so good and very affordable too. next time im probably gonna try the quesabirria which id imagine is even better !!! if youre in the area you neeedddd to go here !!!!!!!! staff is so so soo kind and patient and offer countless samples, even kinda insisting you try more flavors even if you have one picked already. atmosphere was very nice and friendly and supportive too, the one lady who i believe is the owner treated customers as if her own family and was very sweet. fs would recommend. i was sad when the coffee shop that used to be at this location had closed but im so glad it got taken over by such a nice place!“

“Great ice cream! And friendly staff. Was there tonight and had a flight of ice cream!“

“The owner is super friendly and accommodating to my 3 kids who can never make up their minds! She is understanding that my one son only like sherbet! The prices are affordable for what an ice cream shop should be, and portion sizes are perfect for myself and kids so hardly any waste! The menu is massive and the flavors change weekly but always are posted so you know ahead of time! It’s our favorite shop! The seating area is quaint and beautiful with plants and plenty of tables! They have dog treats and a water bowl available for dogs! This is a hidden gem!“

“Friendly staff & Great ice cream!“

“Everything about the Masonic Village Farm Market is fun. The expansive pick-your-own orchard (pears, peaches, apples, and pumpkins) is an annual family event for us. We visit the indoor market store year-round for produce, baked goods, and meat. There is a counter service Cafe here too. Beautiful setting in the country.“

“Just had couch potato at food truck Friday and it was the best ice cream I’ve ever had!“

“polite and ice.cream is good“

“Fun suprise to find. Feel like you dont see it right away. So many fun flavors to try. Super nice owner, good prices, making homemade syrups and flavors, true entrepreneurs.Get out and support local businesses all around PA.OPEN ALL YEAR ROUNDALOHA SUMMER ?Parking: Not a super big parking lot or spaces but free and close to building.“

“I love the cookies. I just wish we had one up here in Hanover, Pennsylvania in my area, instead of me running the whole way to York P. ADietary restrictions: Okay, for the dietary one um. Cookies that are bariatric surgery related for us. That cannot eat a lotKid-friendliness: Make more cookies that children would likeWheelchair accessibility: There needs to be more accessibility into the store and out of the store“

“Awesome place to stop in for ice cream! Scoops were enormous and delicious! Tons of flavors. My buddy got a milk shake (which apparently they're known for) and said it was delicious.Lots of picnic tables to sit at outside as well as activities like arcade and nice looking mini-golf course. Highly recommend and definitely looking forward to returning for more of their ice cream! 2 scoops is plenty!! (though I got three :)“

“Family oriented ice cream experience in a parking lot for what looks like an agway-type place. Tucked away neatly, you can find your way and see all the goodness that lies therein. The ice cream is superb and the flavor options are fantastic. My favorite has been (Irish Creme, Coconut, Lavender honey...a few others) on a pretzel cone. You will not be disappointed. My family and I love it here. Out of BBBs, any Hershey ice cream places, or even Meadows in Ephrata area (another one we love), this is our favorite.“

“I stop by to thank Zoe for preparing my Blizzard just the way I like it! I only have one recommendation and it is for the store, I think they should update their system to be able to place the order through the app. I really don't come here because I don't accumulate points and I always have to order here. Much success and blessings!“

“We just spent the weekend there with our daughter and her family. 4 adults 2 kids. Plenty of room for all of us. Our granddaughters were so excited to stay in the “ shoe house”. We reached out to the owners and had immediate response. Very welcoming and making sure your visit is the best. We visit Maple City Donuts but besides that we stayed and had a blast at the shoe house!! Love the way they have preserve memorabilia. Highly recommend this as a place to stay!“

“I love it there so friendly and great service also great ice cream“

“Thought I would see what this is all about when I was driving past. Asked about flavors that did not have any high fructose corn syrup in them and one of the kids at the register recommended their dragon fruit flavored icy. I was eyeballing the Gelatis, so I asked if they could make my dragon fruit icy "Gelati" style. Even on a cool day, the dessert was just what I wanted. The icy was refreshing and not too sweet. The custard, a wonderful creamy texture and also lightly sweet. Very happy with this experience.“

“It's been a good while, and I miss Rita's !! Swedish Fish Galeto with Vanilla Custard and Sprinkles, is my ultimate Fave ..yummyThe strawberry cheesecake concrete is delish too ! Go give them a try before their closed for the season.“

“Amidst a pandemic, we as consumers are making decisions for where we are comfortable shopping and spending our money. I haven't been to many in the past three months but those where I have, I want to recognize how they've supported their customers. In short, I showed up on a very hot Saturday (July 4th) and was met by a nice young woman who helped me quickly and with care of social distancing (plexiglass, offering to take napkins myself, etc). I ended up dumping two of my gelatis before getting them into my kids' hands in the car and only one was salvageable. The manager was kind in replacing for free. Thanks and keep up the excellent customer service. A bad interaction at this time can send consumers away forever. We go out for customer service, ease and a great experience and you delivered that!“

“There's always a long line at this Rita's and that shows just how popular it is. I'm an occasional customer there. The workers are always friendly and they're as fast as can be. The Swedish fish flavored ice is the best thing Rita's ever created imo. Great place to go when it's a hot day.“

“All the staff where very friendly and accommodating. I wish we still have one in Hanover Pa“

“Everything! Their flavored ice is the best.“