28 Best Ice Cream Shops near Middletown

“Growing up in Middletown back in the day, Twin Kiss was the spot. I haven't had ice cream that compared since... that was until I was in town and stopped by Jak Frost!!! The mixed, vanilla/chocolate soft serve was sooooo as good and it gave me childhood feelings!!! I will definitely be back soon!!!!“

“Great experience! we were looking for someplace to get some ice cream while we were on vacation from NY. The girls working were absolutely amazing and VERY accommodating!!! we will definitely be coming back next time we are in the area!“

“We ordered a milkshake. Notified staff we had a gluten allergy. they made sure to clean/sanitize blender. Staff was very friendly! Will definitely be back“

“They are amazing and the best customer service too“

“So thankful for the dairy free options! Delicious! I stay stocked up and buy a pint at a time.“

“Fast and friendly service. Prices are reasonable. The blueberry sundae is our main reason for coming here. It never disappoints. The other ice cream is good too, but if I could only recommend one thing, it would be the blueberry sundae.

Seating is okay. Just basic picnic benches in the middle of the grass. Some are shaded. Some aren't. The ones that aren't get hot fast. Definitely recommend trying to sit in the shade.

The additional 4% charge for using a credit card is something I'm sure on paper makes sense, but it still seems like something that shouldn't be passed on to the customer in this day and age. While I appreciate the transparency, it just makes the business come off as cheap.

Parking: Finding parking when they're busy can be a little challenging, but you can find a spot if you're patient enough.“

“We requested a specialty gelato for a pickle lover. This was a tall task to begin with, but Kimberly nailed it. The pickle flavor wasn't overwhelming and was a huge hit with the group. Thanks so much for going above and beyond on this custom order, and on such short notice. Chef's kiss!“

“In a world where sweet indulgences beckon from every corner, 3B stands as a beacon of unparalleled delight, beckoning all ice cream lovers to embark on a journey of frozen euphoria. Nestled in the heart of our community, this local gem transcends the mundane, transforming the simple act of enjoying ice cream into an unforgettable experience.
The moment you step to the windows, you're greeted by an atmosphere brimming with warmth and charm. The aroma of freshly made waffle cones wafts through the air, tempting your senses and setting the stage for the culinary symphony that's about to unfold.
The menu, a testament to creativity and passion, offers a tempting array of flavors that cater to every palate. Traditionalists will find solace in classics like velvety vanilla and rich chocolate. At the same time, adventurers can embark on a flavor odyssey with innovative creations like cinnamon cookie or salted caramel pretzel. Each scoop is a masterpiece, meticulously crafted with the finest ingredients and a dash of whimsy, ensuring every bite is a revelation.
But 3B's isn't merely about ice cream; it celebrates community and connection. Whether you're sharing a sundae with loved ones or savoring a solo cone on a sunny afternoon, the friendly staff and convivial ambiance make every visit feel like coming home.
And let's remember the craftsmanship. Behind the counter, the charismatic workers work their magic, sculpting towering sundaes and artful cones with precision and flair. It's a sight to behold and reminds us of the dedication and expertise that goes into every frozen delight.
In a world where mediocrity reigns supreme, 3Bs is a shining example of excellence. It's more than just an ice cream shop; it's a destination, a sanctuary, and a source of unbridled joy. So whether you're a connoisseur or a casual fan, make your way to 3B and prepare to be enchanted. Your taste buds will thank you.

Kid-friendliness: Great for kids.“

“Food was delicious. Birch beer?? I asked my siblings to describe their food in 2 words:
"Upside down"
"Tastes great"
"Yeah itdoes"
"Quite decent"
"Very chiplike"
"Not bad"
Large variety of options. I got a burger with a giant onion ring?? They chips taste original. And Donald trump was serving us salt and pepper!????

Also...WHAT is this ice cream serving??!!“

“Great ice cream shop with awesome service!“

“We absolutely love this Rita’s location. They always have a great selection of water ice flavors and custards but they went out of their way to do a custom order for us! They provided us with 6 quarts of chocolate water ice within 24 hrs - it was amazing!!! Thanks Rita’s Palmyra for being AWESOME ?“

“Delicious ice cream from the Penn State Creamery. Grilled sticky ice cream takes me back to memories of The Diner at campus. They have cup, cones, Sundays and milkshakes too. Lots of choices!“

“Best ice cream in the area, and that says a lot!“

“muy Buena variedad y buen precio!“

“I have been to this shop numerous times, each visit more rewarding than the last. I have to say the "Cinnamon Bun Latte" is just amazing!“

“The quality and the flavor is amazing!“

“I like the gelati. The cheesecake yogurt is very good. I like how many flavors of yogurt they have. The owner Danette is very nice and kind. She is so kind to my daughter Megan . She is a wonderful woman.“

“My grand baby is making that a everyday trip for her after school. It makes her happy’. Thank you!“

“I love the location and the variety of ice, but every time we’ve been this year, it’s painfully slow. There has been maybe 2 employees and a line through the parking lot, took about an hour to get waited on each time.“

“The server folks were friendly and happy to assist.They have both Hershey's and Urban Churn ice cream. I had the Urban Churn Gingersnap flavor in a small size cup. It was fantastic! The small size is big enough to share if you just want a little bit. My Dad had the Hershey's mint chocolate chip in a small size cup and said it was excellent.“

“Ice cream shop situated right at the Downtown end of the Walnut Street pedestrian bridge. Has outdoor seating. Very tasty. Order either vanilla or chocolate ice cream then add a mix-in (long list of mix-in options) to create a flavor of ice cream. Reasonably priced.“

“Staff are sweet and prices are honestly good. They run plenty of coupons in the local mail assortment. Father's and Mother's day are both they get to eat for $1 :)

Parking: I like parking in the overflow parking lot best. It's on the backside of the building.“

“yummy summer treat and friendly staff.“

“yummy summer treat and friendly staff.“

“I just spoke to Joey over the phone and He was so quick and thorough, Even made sure they had the Pie I wanted before traveling out especially for that, and even spoke to the Baker for me, He was absolutely spectacular!!!! Thank You for such delicious, wholesome products, and Especially such Incredible customer Service because Joey was Phenomenal!!!!“

“My daughter had a birthday party on a busy Friday night with about 40 people Our waitresses Cindy and Ava were FANTASTIC and the manager Nate even stayed to cook for the party!!!!! Huge thank you to them all for making our party a wonderful experience“