31 Best Ice Cream Shops near Middletown

“I love going to Jak frost. my go to place every week. I love the peanut butter soft serve.“

“First off, if you’re on a budget and looking to escape the heat wave, listen up. They’re the only place in the area with snowballs (shaved ice in a styrofoam dish). And they start at like $2.75. The kids size is like a small. The small is like a medium, and so on. They have a 50 cent Elvis Presley theme pinball machine. For a quarter, a child under 100 pounds can ride Sandy the horse (an antique ride). They have Hello Kitty coloring pages and crayons. The service there is excellent. I’ve never had an unpleasant experience, and I wish more people knew about this place. It’s right next to the West Shore Theatre on Bridge Street. If you’re looking for a cost-effective and family-friendly place to hang out, their air conditioning is fantastic too.“

“Figments in Sprinkles is so much more than ice cream!! It's a top tier experience! From the fun atmosphere, excellent & friendly service, products of exceptional quality, caring and involved management - every visit is memorable. Elizabethtown is so lucky to have this gem in our town! Love this place!!“

“They have different flavors of ice cream every visit I make here. they also have books to read for your leisure and also some games on the patio and in the building as well. My family loves coming here!“

“always awesome! best soft ice cream in PA.“

“Best ice cream anywhere. Everybody that works there are fast and very friendly.“

“I'm from NJ, we have amazing little ice cream shops all over!! I'm not talking about dairy queen or cold stone (not that there is anything wrong with those places.) I haven't found a place like what I'm used to since I moved here. I happened to be in the Duncannon area a while ago and we were coming up on that location so I asked my wife to stop..It was AMAZING!! Since then I have been to this location a couple times and the funfetti dough is soo good!! The kids are nice, and very quick..they definitely work as a team which is nice to see these days.“

“Great selection of flavors and the creamiest ice cream!“

“Gigis,is a hometown favorite! So nice to live a block away. Never disappointed. Food is always on point and the ice cream is to die for! 50 and 60 vibe. Gigi is very innovative with her ideas as every year she changes up stuff on the menu and ice cream flavors as well. This place is a hidden gem!“

“We were excited to visit this highly rated Coffee Shop for the first time. When we arrived from out of town we were unable to find accessible parking. There were steps up to the entrance which also made it complicated for our 2 wheelchair guests. The place looks so unique & cool, so I’ll definitely return to scope it out on my own to see if I can come back with my physically disabled guests.“

“Best ice cream in the area, and that says a lot!“

“Stopped by CHILL Ice Creamery the other day at the Fresh Market in Hershey, Pennsylvania. I was impressed by the amount of ice cream flavors they have to offer. Their prices are competitive and reasonable. I was very impressed with the amount of ice cream flavors they had to offer, and their menu is full of other selections as well. I definitely recommend this business. Please check them out!“

“muy Buena variedad y buen precio!“

“Everything is perfect. I love everything about the farm“

“Great ice cream shop with awesome service!“

“Best frozen custard ever and Italian ice“

“Delicious ice cream from the Penn State Creamery. Grilled sticky ice cream takes me back to memories of The Diner at campus. They have cup, cones, Sundays and milkshakes too. Lots of choices!“

“yummy summer treat and friendly staff.“

“Where can I find grape sugar free Popsicles around 77503 area. Those were the best when I was in the hospital and I can't seem to find them anywhere. Ty!“

“Ice cream shop situated right at the Downtown end of the Walnut Street pedestrian bridge. Has outdoor seating. Very tasty. Order either vanilla or chocolate ice cream then add a mix-in (long list of mix-in options) to create a flavor of ice cream. Reasonably priced.“

“Love Rita’s and they were very nice 👍“

“My grand baby is making that a everyday trip for her after school. It makes her happy’. Thank you!“

“Everything! Their flavored ice is the best.“

“I love Rita’s and will continue to come here regularly but it is unacceptable and to me it should not be allowed to only have one person attending many costumers! The girl who was working today 03/12/25 was amazing and was obviously working very hard to attend to all of us but the wait time was obviously very long (45mins to be exact) and because i drove from middletown to here i waited. I hope she gets to keep all the tips to herself!!!“

“yummy summer treat and friendly staff.“

“Great service and quality products“

“We had such a lovely experience at this location today! My mom and I have dietary restrictions and need to limit our sugar intake. Today we stopped by hoping for a sugar-free option but unfortunately they didn’t have any out today. Instead, the manager offered to mix up a fresh batch of sugar free mango-peach for us! We wholeheartedly appreciate the service we recieved today The staff was friendly and the service was quick, despite us having to wait a few minutes for a fresh batch (which we didn’t mind)! We will 100% be back to this location We love Rita’s due to their sugar free options as most dessert places don’t offer sugar free options Thank you so much for accommodating us and providing us with the best customer experience possible!“

“Awesome Store!! Find Nicobi products in aisle 10!!😉“

“My daughter had a birthday party on a busy Friday night with about 40 people Our waitresses Cindy and Ava were FANTASTIC and the manager Nate even stayed to cook for the party!!!!! Huge thank you to them all for making our party a wonderful experience“