16 Best Ice Cream Shops near Palmyra

“We absolutely love this Rita’s location. They always have a great selection of water ice flavors and custards but they went out of their way to do a custom order for us! They provided us with 6 quarts of chocolate water ice within 24 hrs - it was amazing!!! Thanks Rita’s Palmyra for being AWESOME ?“

“I would drive by this place, and without fail, it was always really busy. I figured it had to be a great place since it's always so busy. I also appreciate any local place that is not a large chain place. They make their own creations, and you can't compare what you get here for other places because it's truly so different. I will let you know they only take cash, but the gas station across the street has an ATM. I usually get their M&M Artic Creation. One time, I opted for a banana split, but I was truly unable to eat all of it. I felt like it weighed at least 3 to 5 lbs. If it was around when I would get ice cream with my grandma back in IA, it would have been a game changer. We always were able to get anything we wanted as long as we could eat it all. I ate my first banana split at 5 yrs old. I would never have been able to eat this banana split ever by myself. It's a great option if you are looking to share with others. Still look forward to going back and trying new things from time to time. Great staff too!!“

“Drive through is slow. Very slow. I ordered a small strawberry milkshake. I played pulled up to the next window and waited and waited. Finally it came. It was smooth but IMO they need bigger straws. The strawberries were too big to fit through.?“

“Great food and great staff !!“

“They have different flavors of ice cream every visit I make here. they also have books to read for your leisure and also some games on the patio and in the building as well. My family loves coming here!“

“So thankful for the dairy free options! Delicious! I stay stocked up and buy a pint at a time.“

“Delicious, affordable and amazing amount of ice cream!“

“Fantastic gelato. As good or better than what I've had in Italy. Bonus points for simplicity and traditional flavors with reasonable portion sizes.“

“The server folks were friendly and happy to assist.They have both Hershey's and Urban Churn ice cream. I had the Urban Churn Gingersnap flavor in a small size cup. It was fantastic! The small size is big enough to share if you just want a little bit. My Dad had the Hershey's mint chocolate chip in a small size cup and said it was excellent.“

“I love the location and the variety of ice, but every time we’ve been this year, it’s painfully slow. There has been maybe 2 employees and a line through the parking lot, took about an hour to get waited on each time.“

“Great food. Love the chicken Ceasar salad and sweet potato fries. Reasonably priced as well.“

“Mint Chocolate Chip was on their menu tonight, however they just ran out of it when I ordered at the drive thru. The owner was there and said give me 6 minutes and I'll make a new batch for you. I said it wasn't necessary but he insisted...and this was at 8pm!!! He went above and beyond to make sure I had my favorite flavor misto shake tonight. Thank you, it was delicious!“

“Don't listen to zach. This place is insanely good. 3 dollars for a cone 7 for half gallon and it's right next to a pool for Hershey members only.

Get the peach flavor or the coconut and all your worries will be cast off as you ascend into ice cream bliss.“

“The sign said something about treating people right. So I asked for a small Pecan Mudslide. The guy said they don’t have small. So I told him what the sign says. He proceeded to make a small Pecan Mudslide for my wife. All I can say is Thank You for treating people right! My wife was impressed that he went out of the way to make her a small. Then he also charged less. Way to go! I wish everyone would put the customer first! This is one of my favorite places now because of what this you man did!

Parking: Lots of room!“

“I am so glad to have a Rita’s back in Chambersburg! We went at a busy time during opening week and the young staff were extremely friendly and professional even during the chaos of an overflowing parking lot. They worked hard to keep the lines moving and our gelatis were absolutely delicious. We look forward to enjoying trips to Rita’s to cool off this summer!“