10 Best Ice Cream Shops in Mechanicsburg

1 Urban Churn - Desserts and Craft Ice Cream.

4.7 Superb 175 Reviews

Silver Creek Plaza, 6391 Carlisle Pike, Mechanicsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The ice cream is good, I like the different flavors and the staff is always welcoming and friendly. However being an ice cream cone lover I seldom visit because I would like the option of a plain old ice cream cone rather than a waffle cone😊”

2 The Sugar Shack Creamery

4.7 Superb 41 Reviews

675 Williams Grove Road, Mechanicsburg

“Their chocolate ice is exceptional. I know it's one of the most basic flavors but it still tasted damn good. My partner enjoyed their chocolate ice cream sandwich. It was hard as a brick and had a bit of freezer burn, but he still ate it so whatever lol”

3 Crumbl

4.6 Superb 414 Reviews

6416 Carlisle Pike Suite 1400, Mechanicsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I love Crumbl! The business is absolutely pristine inside with the wonderful smell of cookies baking. I’ve always had positive interactions with the employees and they are more than willing to be helpful. I will be a Crumbl fan for life! 🍪”

4 Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

4.2 Good 59 Reviews

Hampden Centre, 4900 Carlisle Pike, Mechanicsburg

• Delivery

“I don’t like to leave bad reviews. Especially because my customer server from Nate was amazing however, while I was waiting the other shift lead I think Cailie? Was training a young kid on how to make cookie sandwiches. He was clearly brand new and she couldn’t have been more annoyed by his lack of knowledge. I heard her say things like “haven’t you make this before” or “well you have 2 cookies so what do you think” Laugh and roll her eyes and at one moment look at me like I was gonna chime in with her public humiliation of this kid. He was so embarrassed. With my background in restaurants and training this is an individual who shouldn’t be training at all. I hope this young man doesn’t quit because of her poor leadership. Hats off to Nate tho for his professionalism. As I was leaving, after cailie ran off in the back, the trainee asked for Nate’s help and he politely went to help him. Nate needs a raise!! What a great kid!!”

5 Dairy Queen (Treat)

4.1 Good 240 Reviews

607 East Simpson Street, Mechanicsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Can I sign up on the app?”

6 Cold Stone Creamery

3.9 Good 67 Reviews

6044 Carlisle Pike Suite 300, Mechanicsburg

“I love the creations and the way they mix the ice cream right in front of you. Today I took four young teens to the cake decorating workshop. They had so much fun! The staff were very attentive and so friendly. They offered all the toppings the girls wanted. They followed up to see what more we wanted.I hope they do this again because I have other kids who want to do this now.”

7 Urban Churn Creamery + Bakery & Cafe

4.6 Superb 34 Reviews

4902 Louise Drive, Mechanicsburg

“I have been going most Saturday mornings for the past year. Always greeted with a smile. Great breakfast sandwich and chocolate raspberry shake. I have purchased just about every item on the menu, even the holiday specials, over this year, too. Always excellent quality and service.”

8 Eckels Ice Cream Fountain

4.4 Superb 83 Reviews

36 East Main Street, Mechanicsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“great ice cream and old time atmosphere”

9 Macris Chocolates

4.5 Superb 11 Reviews

6395 Carlisle Pike, Mechanicsburg

• Delivery

“Abso-freakin-lutely AMAZING 🤩!”

10 Sweet Frog

3.5 Good 178 Reviews

6416 Carlisle Pike Suite 1100, Mechanicsburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The delicious flavor selection!!”