5 Best American Restaurants in Mechanicsburg

“If you are looking for fresh made to order delicious food, this is your place. It is not your typical restaurant. You place your order at the counter and pay, then it is delivered to your table.“

“I wish that I had the time or energy to write out a full review. It's a 2 hour drive from my home to the restaurant so I'm a little beat at the moment.

But I wanted to make sure I give a shout out to our server, Jennie. It is Saturday, November 8th, 2025, and she was our server and she was amazing. She made sure we had everything we need and even anticipated things before we even asked. She was personable and friendly and cheerful, even in the midst of a busy Saturday night dinner rush.

Whoever is in charge of the wait staff, she needs a raise. I mean, seriously. She exceeded all our expectations and then some. Take care of this lady, she's a treasure“

“Best place ever!! Food was great so was the staff.“

“Juicy medium rare burger was absolutely perfect. Waitress was spot on with my refills as I needed. Her name is Madigan,if you want good service ask for her. Caddyshack is a great restaurant and the food is always delicious. Even if you don't play the course,consider the restaurant for a great lunch or dinner“

“What a great surprise. Have had breakfast, lunch and dinner there. Very good!“