50 Best American Restaurants near New Eagle

“We were looking for a place to host a surprise birthday party. Hills was very affordable and the whole process was pretty stress free. The food was good and the staff was very friendly and accommodating. We would definitely use Hills again for any event. Thank you to Hills and the staff for everything.“

“Delicious, fresh homemade food. The food a service was out of this world! Highly recommend.“

“Stopped here on our way through Monongehela. My husband had the cheese burger and d fries and really enjoyed it. I cannot eat gluten and very rarely find a place that can accommodate me. I had kolbassi with no bun, coleslaw, and they cooked my fries in a separate fryer. Everything was very good!“

“absolutely phenomenal food! the staff is amazing very nice and attentive! Victor took care of us and our expierence was definitely a 10/10 couldn't recommend more!“

“This place is such a gem! My fiance and I drive 35 minutes here for the food, best breaded zucchini in Pittsburgh hands down, best nachos, and the flatbreads are amazing. The staff are always so kind and the atmosphere is great for a date night or a family night! 10/10 recommend this one for sure.“

“Just wanted to extend our sincere thanks to Rus, Kim, and the entire staff for continuing to be a blessing to our family and the community. Thank you for helping to make a memorial dinner into a celebration of life. The food and hospitality you provided are second to none. We appreciate everything that you did to make things easier for us.“

“I enjoy going to Bills for breakfast, dinner, and lunch. The food is always good and I love the everyday specials it takes the work out of picking from the several other daily items they offer. The staff is always helpful and food comes out quick.“

“Food was good. Waiter was friendly! Would definitely go back!“

“If you want better fresh cut fries than Kennywood, Bar 48 is it. Their wings and ranch are top notch; it’s the only place I order wings from. Their owner Katelyn does an amazing job of planning many fun events and her personality brings people together!“

“Portion sizes were very generous. The food was very good. Our waitress was very attentive, even when she had an entire section that was packed. The temperature inside was a little cold, so I'd suggest a light sweater or jacket if you get cold easily. Very good first visit. We look forward to visiting again and trying more of the menu.“

“My wife and I had dinner this evening at the Whitehall location. Tia was our server. She was very nice and provided excellent service !“

“The food was great, the owner was really nice, and the employees were amazing. If you're in the area you have to go here. Great little mom and pop restaurant. Just don't turn left when leaving the parking lot. You'll see what I mean.“

“I will not be back, left a $20.00 tip for the waiter and was charged $14.99 as a sweeneys special convenience fee for a party of 3. And the drink prices are out of the park.“

“The atmosphere is Queint and relaxing. The hostess was very friendly and Liza our waitress had a warm demeanor and was personable very attentive.
Delicious doesn't even begin to describe the food. We had the bruschetta, French onion soup, side salad, French dip and stuffed hot pepper pasta.
All portions we exactly right (not to big not to small). Each dish tastes home cook and they space our the dishes so you don't feel rushed. I couldn't tell you the last time I enjoyed eating at a restaurant. We will definitely be back again.“

“This restaurant seems to change hands, but my experience this last visit was great! Bigger menu options, healthier, and the atmosphere is always nice. The staff was friendly and the food was very good. Not a long wait time either. Will visit again, especially in the summer! Highly recommend!“

“Food is amazing . Staff is friendly .“

“Outstanding food and the ambiance takes you back to a wonderful point in time! Owners, staff and patrons are very friendly! The hotel has an excellent cook and the entire place is run in a professional manner! It takes me back to when Sunday dinners were a key part of the blessed sabbath! Rating 100!“

“We stopped in for lunch today for our first visit and were really impressed! The restaurant is beautifully decorated, and our server Natalie was incredibly welcoming and attentive. The prices were very reasonable too.

My husband enjoyed the pizza buffet, which included a drink, salad, and breadsticks. The pizza was hot and fresh with the perfect crispy crust. I chose the Pick 2 lunch special with a club sandwich and side salad, and the sandwich was loaded with meat. Everything was delicious! We’re already looking forward to coming back and trying more items on the menu.“

“Had a wonderful weekend at the John Butler B&B. Cozy house in a safe area. Quite and peaceful. All the staff we met at the restaurants were friendly. Everything was clean and as described. We definitely are adding this to our list of places to return to.“

“The Angus Steak and Crispy Taters were cooked to perfection❤️“

“Hot food and good food. Coffee good too!“

“Shout outs to Jeters, Angel and Kim, excellent servers in Monongahela, PA. We always enjoy Lou Gneely seating us!“

“We needed a place that had power during the wind storm to feed our kids and actually called asking if they had a kids menu they said yes and even told us what was on it over the phone. We ended up going the kids got chicken, fries and applesauce. Husband and I got salmon and swordfish both vary good, the bread was good,my salad was good husband said the house dressing was a little strong but still good. The waitresses were all great and super friendly. Even the customers were all friendly. The place is a little pricey though so be prepared but worth it for the price, the amount of food and the service. We'll be back!“

“Great food, friendly workers nice atmosphere anytime“

“Loved this place! I have been wanting to stay at the property for quite sometime due to my commute. I decided to check out the Restaurant & Bar and was greeted with such lovely staff. Connie could not have been more hospitable with her knowledge of drinks, conversation and amazing service. Scott, Food & Bev.Manager was highly impressive as well. His professionalism on top of personality and knowledge of the f&b world was an enjoyable experience. I will be back weekly if not monthly thanks to Connie & Scott. This is a truly a hidden gem with amazing food & service! Beautiful property! Thanks Connie & Scott!!“

“This was our first time here and the breakfast/lunch bar was open. it was phenominal. great quality of food, tons of choices in buffet style containers to keep it hot. Everything from made to order omlettes, waffles, sausage, salad, pot roast, mashed potatoes, tender breakfast potatoes. my husband said it was the best omlette he has ever had. he had the Irish Omlette. Great staff. This was a huge win. very comfortable seating. The chef was also amazing“

“The flavor of the food is well season right with a unique great taste😋The egg rolls that they created is different with some flavor to choose from like seafood and steak that is out of this world when it come to the flavor also the sauce that came with it just added another level of awesome flavor that satisfy your taste bud. 😋They have a wide variety of delicious food that they have there. Great atmosphere nice people who prepared serve and deliver quality that put a huge smile on your face and enjoyable food that they prepare with love. I highly recommended 3 Good Brothers this establishment is worth going there to order some awesome variety of food.😋“

“So delicious. The restaurant itself is absolutely beautiful. The food is amazing. I have lived in the valley for over 12 years and this was my first time eating here for Valentine’s Day with my husband. I cannot believe I waited this long. I will definitely be back !“

“My kid and I enjoy dining at this location. We've never had any major issues, so I can't really complain very much at all. Our most recent meal there.. the check did seem higher than usual, but that's about it; it wasn't too bad! Everything is too expensive!“

“My Husband and I eat here often for breakfast Friday mornings date time for us. We usually ask for the back near a window mainly because Sharon King serves this area she is always so happy and even when we we sometimes bring the granddaughter goes out of her way to make sure we have everything we need!“

“My parents were visiting from Tampa, Florida and chose Eat’n Park in Belle Vernon to celebrate their 36th wedding anniversary. While the meal itself was fairly unremarkable, the level of service we received from our server, Mia, was truly exceptional and deserves recognition.

From the moment she greeted our table, Mia demonstrated a remarkable level of professionalism, attentiveness, and hospitality. One member of our party has food allergies, and Mia handled the situation with impressive knowledge, diligence, and care. She took every concern seriously, answered questions confidently, and ensured that we felt completely comfortable and reassured throughout the dining experience.

What distinguished Mia most was her extraordinary attention to detail. Drinks were consistently refreshed, dishes were cleared promptly, and every request was met with efficiency and genuine enthusiasm. She anticipated our needs before we even had to ask and maintained a warm, welcoming presence throughout the evening.

As a newer server, Mia’s performance was especially impressive. She carried herself with the poise, competence, and confidence of someone with years of experience. More importantly, she brought a level of sincerity and kindness that cannot be taught. She made my parents feel celebrated on their anniversary and elevated what would have otherwise been an ordinary dinner into a genuinely memorable occasion.

In an industry where exceptional service can be difficult to find, Mia exemplifies what outstanding hospitality should look like. She is an invaluable asset to Eat’n Park, and I sincerely hope her dedication, professionalism, and commitment to customer care are recognized by management. Employees of her caliber are rare, and she left a lasting impression on our entire family.

Thank you, Mia, for making my parents’ 36th anniversary celebration so special.“

“My wife and I came to the chef's table event last night, it was our first time there. and we had a fantastic time, the service was impeccable, the food was delicious. It was a wonderful experience and we will be back again.“

“Fast service, I was sat ASAP (as soon as possible). My burger was cooked to perfection not still mooing, and not too dark. The highlight was the bazookie. It looked liked poop at first they loaded it with so much chocolate (which made me really hungry.) I then wolfed it down tom pearl style, gave my waiter my fat tip and went on with my day!“

“I was at Best Buy in Bethel Park this morning and googled restaurants nearby for lunch . I prefer local (non- chain) places, so when I saw Ma & Pop's Country Kitchen on South Park Road, I decided to try it.

This is a very popular diner with delicious food, reasonable prices and friendly service. I got the Reuben and fries, which was one of the best I've had in a long time.

If you're in the area, check this place out.“

“Good service. Very good food for the price. Staff was Awesome interacting with my 7 year old too!“

“On Sunday we had an In house catered party for dinner and it was excellent! The food was topnotch and the service was great! Special shout out to our server, Bram (Brahm). He was efficient, kind, and organized. From the drinks served before, to the food, then the cake,and packing us up to go, he did it all with a little help by Samantha. There was not one complaint from our party of 20. Thanks so much to all! All I can add is yum!!“

“My husband got the Chimichurri steak and egg hash. He will not stop talking about it. He gives it a 5/5. Service was good too.“

“We had a great time last night! Axe throwing was with our group was competitive, yet fun! It is nice to have an option of a fun activity after dinner. Staff were friendly and service was excellent.“

“Made a last minute decision to go out for News years after our original plans changed. Wait time was reasonable and the staff went above and beyond. Food was delicious and thankful we got to celebrate at such a great local restaurant.“

“Great food! Great Menu! Great Wait Staff! Great atmosphere! 5 Stars!“

“This place has really good wings! And the pork chop is really good too! Especially with barn sauce.“

“So, Red Lobster in Pleasant Hills was clean and had a menu with many options. I chose the shrimp skewers and added a scallop one. They were tasty. I added a side of Brussel sprouts. They were delicious. The biscuits were good. The baked potato was done well. All of the staff were friendly . It’s worth a return visit to try the Salmon Bowl or maybe the flounder.“

“My husband and my mom threw me a 40th birthday party at The Monkey Bar. We had the huge porch to ourselves, wonderful wait staff, and the management was great to work with! Highly recommend looking into this place for events - truly perfect evening!!“

“Super clean and friendly, great family atmosphere. Simple menu with delicious results. Staff was very attentive and helpful with information on the area, and a good parking lot. Would happily come back.“

“I absolutely LOVE going to Wagner's! The food is delicious, the coffee is hot & tastes great and the staff is so welcoming and pleasant. If going, make sure you get the Home fries with Peppers & Onions. You'll thank me for it! I don't understand why they are not open for dinner too. I would certainly go there for dinner a lot!!!! This restaurant is a must try!!!!“

“To Randy Kovac, All I have to say is BS, to your review, and how could you see the bartender ignoring your call?? Lmao. If you was there and needed cigarettes, no matter what time or whoever was there, employees or customers. And needed cigarettes, you would have received cigarettes even if you didn't have any money. So why don't you say anything about you abusing dogs? Or what about someone saying something about you that's not true on the internet?? Wouldn't like that would you.. and the animal abuse is true. Ask WTAE, CHANNEL 4, WITH THE ONLY HELICOPTER IN PITTSBURGH“

“Absolutely delicious. Good sized portion. The batter on the fish sandwich was perfectly crispy. Great seasoning on the fries. Will definitely be back.“

“Amy deserves a huge shoutout! DoorDash really dropped the ball on our order, but when we called the store, Amy immediately stepped in and took care of everything. She even offered to call me when the Dasher arrived (which unfortunately never happened), and when I ended up going to pick up the order myself, she had already remade our fries so they were hot and fresh. She was incredibly kind, helpful, and went above and beyond to make a frustrating situation so much better. Truly can’t thank you enough, Amy!“

“Always a blast!!! Feels like hanging out at a friend’s place.“

“I WOULD RATE 10 STARS IF I COULD!!! I LOVE A GOOD WING AND SAUCE AND WHEN MY BARBER SUGGESTED TIM'S PLACE FOR THE BUFFALO WINGS, I WAS HOOKED!!!! THESE WINGS ARE NOT SPICY, MORESO MILD, BUT SOOOOOOO DAG ON GOOD!!!! YOU WANT MORE AND MORE OF HIS SIGNATURE BUFFALO SAUCE ON THEM!!!! ITS A BUTTERY BUFFALO SAUCE THAT CANNOT BE DUPLICATED!!! I CAN EAT THESE WINGS EVERY DAY!!!!!! AWESOME AWESOME!!!!!“