Italian Restaurants near New Freedom

“Went there last week. Prices were cheap for what you get and will get you full. Our food came in around 10 minutes and was hot. I recommend the Pizza Hoagie for anybody coming here. There is biking parking in the front, for anybody wondering.“

“This was our first time here since the new owner took over. The reviews were mixed, so we took a chance. I am so glad we did. The subs we ordered were over the top, full of meat, and very flavorful, especially with the smoked bacon added.We also ordered the fried mushrooms, originally thinking they were expensive, but once we received the order, the order was more family sized, and the marana sauce served with it was very flavorful.I highly recommend thus place“

“I stumbled into this place because I had some time to kill. So cute inside. Warm and cozy. Everyone was friendly. Really liked the atmosphere. It’s a pizza place you want to hang out in. Food good too!! Everything well stocked and it was clean!!“

“This was our 1st time here. We drove 40 min from PA. The service was perfect. Our waitress was very personable and funny. The food was out of this world. My friend and I had the crab cake which went to the top of our list as a favorite. My husband had lasagna, which was a huge portion, and he had to take some home. And my friends husband had the chicken that was topped with crab imperial and was also delicious. We can not wait to go back and sad we didn't go here sooner. “

“First time ordering from here. Food was delivered within 30 minutes. Fair prices. I can tell you the crab pretzel was awesome!! Nacho cheese fries were great too and have a little spice to them. We liked everything we received and will definitely order from here again ?“

“I've eaten at Genova's way more than I can count and have tried virtually everything on the menu, aside from the Italian dishes.Firstly, Genova's has the best bread for subs in Carroll County. Their meats are on par with everyone else but nothing special, but the bread makes it. Portion sizes for the cost are hit or miss. If you get a parm sub, fillings are generous. Cold cuts filling is about what I expect and are decent (although their Italian Cold Cut is only ham and salami, which is not an ICC which should have at least 3 meats IMO, but that's a different rant.) Steak subs are a little light but relatively fair. I always add extra meat onto a half which is reasonably priced add on and that works for me. I've gotten their BLT and Veggie subs from time to time and they are absolute rip offs. It seems like they just give you the normal amount of filling as a topping on a regular sub with for these.Their pizza is one of the better ones around. Haven't really had a bad one there, although on a personal level, their pizza can sometimes be rough for my stomach. Try their garlic sauce even though its more butter than garlic but I'm not complaining.I used to like their salads too but the past few times I've been disappointed. I usually get the small Greek with chicken which is around $12, which is a bit high and twice out of the last 3 times, the container was about 3/4 full and/or has wilted or big chunks of white lettuce. The wings are another one that is a poor value. They are big and tasty, although sometimes light on sauce, but $10 for 6 wings is high. They bumped up the price when there was a wing shortage and never reduced it.So overall, Genova's has some great items and virtually everything tastes good but the value on some items is poor. Fortunately I've eaten there enough I know what is a good and poor value and I stick to those.“

“Came in first thing on a weekday. Ordered a reasonably priced medium pepperoni pizza. The toppings were generous and the crust on the ends of the pizza has a crispy texture to it. Mozzarella and sauce were tasty. Would definitely be back. Best pizza in Stewartstown.“