49 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Salem Borough

“Bought a California burger with fries the burger was hot and juicy vegetables were fresh and crisp even the fries where hot and crisp would highly recommend“

“all I can say is I love doing what I did I love doing what I do and I am just so happy that Matt shover shover is doing such a wonderful job and keeping our family tradition extending more than five generations he's doing a wonderful job and I appreciate everyone who ever walked through them my door just like myself I know Matt and his family welcome you through his doors thank you.“

“My friend and I had the vegan Punk Rock Girl pizza for the first time last night. Amazing.“

“Always great food and great service!“

“Big variety and big flavors served up with big hearts with great family friendly service. IT was our first time. Margherita was thin crust, but possessed both crunch and softness. The flavor of the sauce and two cheeses was perfectly balanced. I hade the Marco Favorite Steak. Tender chopped philly steak with mushrooms, peppers, onions, provolone, and a touch of sauce. It was delivered on an fresh & soft roll from Philly. We could not have asked for a better first experience. Vito came out and gave us two slices for free...one with bourbon chicken and the other with hot pepperoni. They also gave out 1.00 off on an ice cream! Lol I had to take their side salad home. That was packed with romaine, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, two types of olives, red onions, and croutons. We had two drinks as well only $38.00.
Molte grazie!“

“French fries are best in york county bar none pizza is really good as well as cheese steak as well haven't tried everything yet but everything I did I loked“

“Sons of Sicily catered the most amazing rehearsal dinner tonight! Julie set up the space so beautifully and was so kind and thoughtful! She even catered the decorations to the bride and groom’s wedding colors!
The tri-colored tortellini and the meatballs with pasta were superb! Also the chocolate cannoli’s set my heart ablaze! Food was amazing, and Julie was the difference maker for this event! Thank you for making tonight so special!!! As seen in the photo, the cannoli’s were obliterated, and I certainly will be eating the rest minutes after this review posts!“

“Highly Recommend! owners are so kind & friendly! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS food! Best pizza/sub shop in Hanover Area.“

“Best Pizza in York County...just WAY too salty...wont shop there again...sadly“

“Stopped in for lunch. Amanda served us. Pizza was soo good. Will definitely be back“

“Good variety and great tasting pizza“

“I was in PA to visit family and wound up here fairly randomly looking for sicilian pizza and I was not disappointed. I'm from NY but live in WI and they just don't make sicilian out here. Domenic was behind the counter singing joking and laughing and it really did remind me of home

edited to add: and I left with a t-shirt“

“Joe has good food and great service. Place is always clean.“

“Good Pizza and friendly service“

“Just ordered a sub (take out). When I got home and opened it up, it was burnt. Charred black burnt. NOT EDIBLE! Unless the worker was blind, there’s know way they couldn’t see it was burnt. They just wrapped it up and sent it out. Customer beware, they don’t care! I recommend going somewhere else.“

“they have the best food in Pennsylvania!“

“Mod gets a 5 from me for the fresh toppings, great taste, excellent service and the outdoor seating that is perfect for cool evenings! A quick, enjoyable and fun pizza experience.

Kid-friendliness: We had 2 kiddos with us, abs they each got mini-mods the way they wanted them! Milk is a drink option- I do prefer that for the kids over the sodas and teas.“

“I've gotten lunch and dinner from here several times now. The food is always excellent. I highly recommend the steak and fried onion pizza, it is outstanding and unique. Service is always friendly.

The prices are more or less in line with other local shops, but $30 for a large pizza with toppings will always seem expensive to me (currently 49 years old). The online ordering is easy, that's how I order and pay.

The only thing keeping me from a full 5 star review is there have been little errors in nearly every order. Last night I think I got a "garbage" pizza instead of the supreme I ordered. Technically a mistake, but that "garbage" pizza was excellent, so heavy with toppings you need a knife and fork to eat it. But that wasn't what I ordered. This place is so close to 5 stars. Wish I could give 4 1/2.

They offer other diner type options and have breakfast too. I've only ever gotten subs, strombolis, pizza, and fries here, but I have hear good things about the breakfast choices from other people.

Caesar's is for sure worthy of your eating out dollars. They also have a nice little eat-in area if you want to do that.“

“Had Paesano’s for the first time yesterday. Cheeseburger sub and Stromboli was absolutely delicious and fulfilling. Highly recommend & will definitely be back.“

“We frequent this place weekly...good food, good prices and good people! This is the "Killer Stromboli" #boliheaven“

“Very nice people delicious pizza!“

“You can't beat the outdoor seating, either under the covered deck or at the tables with umbrellas. Views of the hills of the golf course make it feel calming and luxurious. All the wait staff were on top of their gane. There's a huge menu with typical pub options but also a ton of creative pizzas with white or red sauces. I got one with a white crab sauce that was amazing!My wife had one heavy with spinach and also a mix of cheeses. The beer selection was ok. The cocktails are ok. But they all taste better on the patio! It was cozy looking inside, too.

Vegetarian options: Many pizza options that are veggie or where you can then to skip the meat topping. Also impossible burger and salads, maybe other options, too“

“Favorite place to grab a personal pizza. I love that you can individualize what you want to your taste buds. The pizzas taste amazing coming out of that wood fired oven.

I've only ever had positive experiences at Mod. I've dined alone, with my family and even on a date with my husband late at night.
The pizza is made to order and is ready in just a few minutes.
I'm so glad that we can have great pizza like this in York, PA!“

“I’ve had better experience at other locations.

Vegetarian options: Vegan and vegetarian options available. Cauliflower crust is great.

Dietary restrictions: Very inclusive, They have large variety of options to meet just about everyone’s needs allowing them to follow restrictive dietary guidelines if need be.“

“Close location to our hotel. We walked over and ordered a calzone. Very good flavor and the sauce was so delicious! One of the top sauces I've had. Lady that took our order was stoic, not really personable or friendly. Young man that gave us our order was more friendly.“

“Great food and service! Drinks were good too!“

“This place is my absolute favorite! For everything! I luckily work right across the street! Their Reuben, their BLT’s, their burgers, their pizza, their bread pudding, legit ALL of it is the best around. And the restaurant is so cute inside! Love the owners. They know what they’re doing and that is coming from someone that has been in fine dining most of their life. Well done, Copper Crust!“

“We have been coming to Mamma's for the past 36+ years as their authentic Italian dinners, subs, stromboli, bread & salads are next to impossible to beat. They are all about great Italian food at reasonable prices and there are coupons on their App for even greater savings. If you have not added Mamma's to your dining out and take out lists, you are really missing out!! Support this Family-Owned business as they are First Class and they hire and train their staff to be excellent treating their customers as family!!“

“I picked up just a cheese pizza. My garden is in full bloom and figured everyone could top their own pizza. The crust was very good, it had that crunch factor, was cooked perfectly a very good pie! The people working were friendly! Lots of yummy pics included.“

“Food & service was great!!“

“Thank you for feeding my goalie weekly! Your smoothies are SO good and your menu keeps things fresh. We appreciate you!“

“Best pizza ever…crust is amazing!“

“We just got pizza delivered today. Super quick delivery and the pizza tasted as if we were dining in! Super fresh and yummy! 100% recommend!“

“What nice people! Pizza was terrific! This was our first visit @ lunch time.. we had a large veggie, thin & crispy! It was fabulous! Just perfect! We will definitely go back again!
Finally found pizza we absolutely love!!“

“We just got pizza delivered today. Super quick delivery and the pizza tasted as if we were dining in! Super fresh and yummy! 100% recommend!“

“Just have a small pizza which was very good. Also got a cold sub it was good but had to take lettuce off, it very brown you could tell it was old“

“Great food. Great service. Very friendly staff. Lots of young staff the evening we dined in. They were hopping and kept on their toes. Didn’t miss a beat. Stayed focused, attentive and courteous. Worked efficiently and together. Hunter was filling in for a sick employee and was absolutely an amazing waiter. Outstanding work ethic. Wait wasn’t bad at all considering how busy they were. Food was hot.“

“We moved to York from Philly just over a year ago and we have been so disappointed in the pizza around here...it's generally just so bad no matter where you go. Then we found Nino's! This place is the best pizza we've had around here in over a year and we are not going anywhere else from now on.“

“today I ordered 5 big daddy pizzas for a party.. everything was great and on time“

“Good variety and great tasting pizza“

“I have been buying their frozen pizza at our local food store, redners, for years. It has always been good. Perhaps, their school lunches are different. The retail, pizzas that I have bought I have bought. Have always been excellent. Plus plus, comma I'm supporting a local PA company.“

“Pizza was great, especially the gluten free dough but was disappointed with my lava cakes...couldn't even tell if there was 3 of them as advertised since they were (seemingly) all smushed together. Still tasted good though, presentation just wasn't the best.

Vegetarian options: Meat free options including build your own menu“

“Ordered online for delivery. Food was still super hot when it arrived and it was great. My one son is super picky about pizza shop pizza and ended up eating two pieces of it. The buffalo chicken sub was so good also. We also got a stromboli and it has garlic butter on top. It was all soooo good!“

“Ww went today for the first time as we were visiting York College. Everything was hot and delicious. Can't wait to go back and try something different as there were many options.“

“Our family loves Shakey Jakes! The pizza is delicious and the subs are made with fresh homemade bread. We often get pick up orders and the staff is always courteous. Recently I had a large order and the owner Ethan even carried out the food to the car for me. I highly recommend Shakey Jakes!“

“fantastic menu / price. good value and quantity for everyone that got variety of dishes items. Definitely going to get there in oct/2024. doing a take out since health issues can't get together to eat there. so carry out Definitely works.“

“Omg AMAZING!!!! 1st time ordering, the girl who answered the phone was so nice and helpful, food was amazing! I'm very picky with my wings and always have to tell places how to make them. Since it was my 1st time ordering from here, I didn't suggest anything, I just ordered how they come. PERFECTION!!!! As for the pizza,( same thing I always have a special request, didn't this time.) Perfect!!! The delivery guy was nice and i got my food fast! Plus their prices are good! This is my new favorite pizza place!!!“

“My only issue is I want a larger pizza. The one in Manchester is great. They actually cook the pepperoni ,the pizza isn't a sloppy mess like most other pizza shops in the area. Sorry but all I ever order from here is their pizza because I think it's the best. Hope this helped you.“

“Call center sucks,First thing I told them was I have a coupon & read all the details, NO mention of the coupon on the order & order wasn't what I wanted.Manager took care of the order and made sure it was what I wanted, pizza was perfect and everyone was happy with what we got!“