50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Plum

“Noticed today this place popped up on Google and I hadn't seen them before. Saw they had a deep dish and took the plunge with a medium Sausage/Pep deep dish pizza.

The crust is perfect with a great taste; the sauce isn't too spicy or sweet and with plenty of garlic.

This is a tad pricier than other options, but well worth the couple dollars more.

Don't sleep on Calabrese' Pizzeria. They're new to the area and need some business. You won't be disappointed!“

“Now that they moved we don't get delivery any more, but we will drive to get the food. I have been eating here since I was a little child. Mom worked at presby and would bring home her leftover lunch, as kids we would Tear it up!!, that was over 20 years, and as an adult I still love the food. Always will remind me of home and good times. Thanks for keep with the same old traditions and recipes, yall will forever be on my top 5 list.

Parking: The old location the parking was a joke! But now they have a huge parking lot! Lots of open spaces for a lot more business to come.“

“Hands down the best pizza, wings, pasta, garlic knots, and more!“

“The pizza is absolutely delicious! It's very filling. Plus they use some of th best pepperoni I've had in a long time. The staff is super nice and I love the baseball atmosphere. Definitely recommended!

Wheelchair accessibility: Very accessible“

“I live behind this Fox’s pizza & have placed takeout orders 158 times from 3/2020-2024 according to fox’s account info page. Wow!! I can count on one hand the number of times it’s been just satisfactory in all this time. I keep going back because it’s consistently great pizza for the price. They always have great sales!Fox’s is the consistently great pie. Conca D’oro’s across 286 has options for higher quality toppings, but is less accessible/ much more expensive/ doesn’t accept cards. I’ll go with Fox’s most of the time but Conca D’oros if I want a higher quality topping (ie spinach) that Fox’s doesn’t offer. Conca-$18/ large one topping / fox’s- 9.99 but doesn’t offer the same topping assortment. Different strokes for different folks.I don’t dine in, yet I’ve found the atmosphere to be ya know, pizza shop. Employees are busy making pies and the pens game is on in the background. As it should be.“

“So happy to say I work here. Everyone is super nice and just great people to be around. The food is really good too. I would 100% recommend the buffalo chicken pizza (and of course you need our amazing homemade ranch to dip it in).“

“Love everyone and everything about Amilis . We order at least 5/6 a month.“

“first time customer today. one of the best pizzas I've had in a very very long time and I will be back!“

“We’re in the neighborhood every few years and come here semi-regularly. Just ordered the vegetarian plate and was really delighted by the different vegetables. Cooked thoughtfully, great flavor. The kebab are also quite good.“

“Truly one of the best Pizzas in or around Pittsburgh and I try everywhere in Pittsburgh . The owners and family of the shop are amazing and as friendly as they come . Fresh Ingredients and the crust is just to die so plain and simple it’s a must and a favorite pizza shop of mine“

“Stopped by today and tried multiple sandwiches and pizzas. The staff was extremely friendly and the food was outstanding. My personal favorite was the Grandma Pie ❤️. Highly highly recommend!!“

“Amazing experience all the way around! Super food and super staff!! Great spot!!“

“Delicious food by a wonderful local family!“

“The pizza is delicious, the wings are great, never had anything that wasn't delicious, and my wife "Her Highness" LOVES the Wediges. Ok fine, she's not really a queen, she just threatens to throw me in the dungeon if I don't order from Meglio's. My only issue is I need them to add an item to their menu. There are nicotine patches to help those with a nicotine addiction. I need some Meglio's patches so I can slap one on my neck when Meglio's is closed. I'd hate to cause problems in my neighborhood, you know, local flooding due to me slobbering while craving Meglio's.“

“Found this place via Google Maps on my way between clients. The food was exceptionally delicious. The Hot Sausage Hoagie was everything I wanted it to be... absolutely on point. My side garden salad had a variety of very fresh veggies and the home made Italian dressing was great! The gigantic brownie was also phenomenal. I can hardly wait to share this discovery with my coworkers, friends and family!“

“Not enough words to describe the food. Had the best Stromboli I’ve ever had. Stayed crispy until the last bite. Staff was super friendly. I will definitely return and highly recommend.“

“This is God's pizza! Pizza by which all others are judged. Pizza all pizzas aspire to yet never achieve. To eat this pizza is to ruin all other pizza on the planet. You will forever hang your head at the thought of another's pizza.“

“I’ve been eating here FOREVER! The steak hoagie is seriously the best I’ve ever had, Lou is the greatest! I wish they would bottle the Italian dressing, because I would def buy it! Best pizza shop around hands down!“

“The guy was so nice and friendly! Great service and awesome pizza and breadsticks!“

“Found our go-to pizza place! Jumbo wings were awesome. Salad was packed with a variety of toppings and made with spring mix not cheap iceberg lettuce! High quality and fresh ingredients. A lot of bang for your buck. Super friendly staff and owner. I will definitely be telling everyone this is the best!“

“Delicious food, a wide variety of options, a great local place!“

“We ordered several Charlie’s Super Square for a party. 24 slices for $23! Great deal.They came hot and fresh. Absolutely delicious! Everyone at the party raves about the pizza. We will definitely order again!“

“Great service, great food, the Britannia do a fantastic job“

“One of thee best pizza shops in the area.(this is my opinion so don't get all bent out of shape if you don't agree). Great service, very clean establishment, and the food well if I'm writing this that means something cause I'll ghost you if it's bad lol. Keep it up sir, you gained another loyal customer. See you soon“

“Food is amazing and they are always friendly, and their delivery is always fast and efficient.“

“awesome staff and great tasty food love their penne with meat sauce and their pizza too“

“great pizza. good delivery. nice people. good menu“

“My wife and I come here every last Wednesday of the month with our Aunt. We always request Brandon as our waiter, and the entire staff makes sure that our dining experience is exquisite every time. The food is always excellent. Strumboli is the best in the world. Best draft beer you'll ever have. So cold, so clean. We even tip one of the cooks regularly. We are treated like family, and fed like family. Best branch out there is in Monroeville! Big ups to the manager, he's so personable and works extremely hard. This is our favorite restaurant out there!“

“This is by far, the best pizza and the best calzone I’ve ever tasted. The cheese to sauce ratio was impeccable. The crust was a perfect bit of crunchy around the crust. There was NOT a single bite of pizza that was soggy - and given the moisture of the cheese and sauce the pizza had, I was floored by how perfectly cooked it was.This place is CASH ONLY and although there is sorting available, it doesn’t seem like the type of place you want to sit down and eat. Not that it’s unwelcoming, it’s just very quaint.

Vegetarian options: There are plenty of vegetarian pizza toppings available for personalization

Parking: Plenty of parking with a bit of a walk from the lot“

“Our server Elaine was nothing short of excellent! She was so pleasant, was very quick and always made sure we had everything we needed. She made our trip very memorable (we are staying at a hotel close by for a business trip). My daughter (she is four) saw they had a claw machine for a bouncy ball but we didn’t have cash on us play, Elaine overhead my daughter’s disappointment and came over and gave her a dollar to play! My daughter was so excited to win a ball for herself and her sister. I can’t thank her enough for making my daughter so happy and you can see she genuinely care for her customers, you don’t see that often nowadays. We want to thank you again Elaine for such an amazing experience and a delicious dinner. Would totally recommend this location to anyone!“

“Great food! Had a small bit of our wedgies and took them home so we could get ice cream! Hot fudge brownie and nutty buddy sundaes were great! So were the wedgies. Stuffed with meat !“

“Really Great Chicken Salad! I've never had one that included a meat and cheese roll up but that made it even more fantastic! we also ordered wings and a thick crust pizza which were also great! well be back!“

“If ya think thin crust, sweet sauce & generous toppings is GOOD pizza then MARY JO's IS DA GOODEST ON GOD's GREEN EARF!!Amy Peddler Lil Peaches. A one star cuz u loved it now 30 years ago... Did something change? Should post a reason for a 1 star. U seem mad cuz it took ya 30 years to get back to ur 1st Tru love & u taking it out on others. Mary Jo's was named from Luv of daughter now thrives on Luv of mother. PRODUCY SAME NOW AS IT WAS 40 YEARS AGO WHEN I FIRST TRIED.“

“The thin and the thick square (sicilian) were excellent! I'm a total pizza snob and tried both and am so glad that I did! This was my 1st time trying as I don't live in this area and I'm totally impressed. Can't wait to order again! The owners were very nice and everything was ready on time and hot!“

“Latina Pizza needs no introduction. They are one of the places always mentioned when people talk about the best pizza places in southwestern Pennsylvania. They maintain a compact menu of pizzeria staples that are done extremely well. The pizza is a square, Sicilian style and is absolutely delicious.“

“This is one of the few small family gems left on this side of Penn Hills, the food is on par or above dine in restaurant quality, and the prices reflect how cheap eating out was pre C-19 shut downs, the people are friendly and easy to talk with, try their deluxe steak hoagies, or chicken nuggets/tenders for the kids, you spend less than fast food easily!“

“First time going there last night 10/27/24. We ordered a large pepperoni xtra pepperoni and cheese pizza . And we drove from Apollo to Leechburg and pic it up and took it home and it was still hot. The employee’s were super nice. The dining room was very clean & nice looking. We will be ordering again . Friendly employees that names it nicer to pick up or eat in. Or to even come back. Thank you girls for the awesome pizzas and hospitality when I came to pic my pizza up. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Italian hogie was pretty big and delicious. breaded whole wings were the best I had in a long time. Definitely my new go to for wings.“

“Awesome food and great customer service“

“Excellent food and service at Fox Chapel location . My first time here busy Saturday crowd Gabby was a wonderful bar server actually excellent. I had Bruschetta salad which I highly recommend Over any other“

“great people and excellent food ! couldn't ask for nicer people and the ranch is the BEST. so is the Italian hoagies ! and the garlic knots , everything is delicious!“

“We just had this last evening it was brought by our kids. Taste was great, size was huge.. meat lovers pizza was the best!! New place for our pizzas from now on!“

“Called in a small lunch order for the office and picked up a medium pepperoni pizza and some fried zucchini.
The order was ready when I got there and lunch was enthusiastically enjoyed by all.
Bishop’s does great food and we always appreciate supporting local!“

“Phillipis never disappoints! I’ve tried a few things off of the menu so far, birdville pie with pepperoni, steak quesadillas, chicken salad, meatball sub, and the buffalo chicken dip! All are very good! Can’t wait to try more from the menu! Been going here for about 3 years now! Me and my fiance love this place!“

“Their Philly Steak Hoagies are the best. They use REAL BEEF STEAK. Not that cheap "Steak Ums" or poor quality questionable meat.
Plus, their fries are fresh, not frozen, cut potatoes.
Their pizza is above "average." I'd give 4 1/2 ⭐.
But, I'm not really a pizza connoisseur. To me, a pizza is a glorified cheese sandwich.
I do like their crusts and options given for their crusts. Thin or "Sicilian style," a thick crust.
I prefer thin. I'm not a dough/bread/pasta lover.“

“Wonderful Service, AWESOME FOOD and Great prices. Definitely Recommend“

“My favorite pizza in the area! Also the Italian calzone is my absolute favorite ever! My son (also named Dominic) really enjoys it as well which tells you something because he is very picky lol“

“I ordered through Doordash and took a chance, not knowing the area well. but I got the Cheese Lovers Pizza and oreo cheesecake. and it was seriously amazing! enjoyed every bite!“

“best pizza and food around! cool little place with lots of music and sports memorabilia inside.. get the Samzilla Pizza with hot honey drizzle. omg! don't drive by and not order it. its the best!“

“Not the cheapest but definitely get what you pay for! Been going for years, very nice owners. Great pizza!“