50 Best Italian Restaurants near Spring Brook

“We went to the High Bridge House tonight for dinner to celebrate our 19th wedding anniversary. The restaurant was highly recommended by a friend of ours, and we were not disappointed. I had the Steak and Cake, and my husband had the Lobster Bacon Mac & Cheese, and both were delicious! We ate in the dining room which was lovely, and the service was top notch. We highly recommend The High Bridge House for any occasion, and we will definitely be back.“

“One of the best dining experiences we’ve had in a long time! The place is absolutely beautiful, the food is phenomenal, and the mocktails were perfect. The staff was incredible — warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. And Gabe, the manager, is truly exceptional and made us feel like VIPs. I had the Goat Cheese & Ricotta Cavatelli for my entrée and the Flourless Chocolate Torte for dessert. Everything was just amazing from start to finish. We can’t wait to go back!“

“We took my son last night for his birthday and as a family what a wonderful experience! Atmosphere was great. The wait staff is very tentative along with the owner. The food was delicious. We all enjoyed our meals, best penne à la vodka around the area! We definitely will be going back! At the end of our service we complimented how great everything was and we were celebrating our son’s 16th birthday and the owner and his staff came and surprised my son on their own with a piece of cake and sang to him! Genuinely good people!“

“Excellent service. Quality menu & food.😊“

“We heard about this place on NEPA Pizza Review and since we happen to be in Scranton today we stopped there to eat lunch. It's such a nice, clean place with friendly staff. We had the large pizza with sausage and it was absolutely delicious!! We'll definitely go back!!!“

“This pizza is great!!! GO ORDER SOME LOL its seriously that good �“

“Great food! Great staff! Love the garlic knots!“

“Our Favorite Restaurant. Delicious & Plenty of food. Deserts are Amazing!!“

“My favorite place to eat. My wife had my 60th birthday there on the 13th. As always food and service were excellent! Thank you for a great birthday!“

“Great local italian restaurant in the downtown area. It's pretty popular so be sure to make a reservation ahead. Randomly, you can find empty seats by the wood fire pizza station. We don't mind and the hosts always ask in case as it isn't a regular table. You can see all the kitchen action and pizza making skills while dining. Terrific service by my server JP. He set us up with a wine bottle and the bikini bottom pizza which is always delicious. There is also a gelato/coffee section near the entrance located by the bar. They do have a room with a big table in case you're looking for a more private dinner. However, you still feel like you are in the restaurant part of the crowd as it is enclosed by glass. There is a section to hang coats. Definitely try the whipped ricotta!“

“By far our favorite Italian restaurant in NEPA! Love the atmosphere, the service and the food! Only drawback is we live 5 hours away but stop for dinner @ the bar every time we are in town.“

“Always wonderful! Today we had the maple toffee cake with cream cheese icing for dessert. Fabulous!“

“Probably my favorite restaurant downtown right now, I could eat this food every single day. Handmade pasta, delicious sauces and of course the meatballs! Our waiter is always a delight. The atmosphere is something you'd find in Manhattan or Philly, a great place for couples or a group dinner.“

“First time trying Club 17 tonight 3/17/23. Absolutely awesome. The red pizza was some of the best I’ve had in Old Forge. Light, crispy and flavorful sauce. The fresh tomato and garlic pizza was equally amazing. Super fresh ingredients and the garlic was the perfect amount. The star of the show for me though was the Rigatoni Abruzzi with hot sausage. It’s done in a light creamy tomato sauce with roasted red peppers, hot Italian sausage and just the right amount of chili flake. Everything was awesome and we got it to go. I’m sure it would be even better sit down in the restaurant which we will certainly be trying in the near future. Highly recommend.“

“We absolutely love Sidel’s! The hospitality at this establishment plus the food & beverages offered are top notch. Thank you to each and every person at Sidel’s who made our dining experience so enjoyable. We made a reservation for 11 guests including two small children to celebrate a special birthday over the weekend and there are no words to describe how truly amazing everything was. Each person went above and beyond the entire time without hesitation. From providing a cake for the birthday girl at the last minute, welcoming all of us like we were family, & bringing toys out for my children who started to get a bit restless, my family and I cannot thank you all enough. We can’t wait to return again very soon! ♥️“

“first time here tonight based on my dates recommendation..very happy with our dinners and the service..I got the gnocchi with meat sauce and she got a chicken caesar salad I believe..both large portions . Will definitely be back“

“Our new favorite pizza place! The sweet sauce is delicious. Their wings and hoagies are really good, too. Inexpensive and a great value for your money. And their customer service is top notch!! 🍕“

“Great food and pleasant wait staff!“

“Absolutely Fantastic! Angelo was wonderful!“

“If I had to have my last meal on earth it would be RIGHT HERE! The greatest food ever!“

“I got 2 trays of red pizza with anchovies & the pizza was Absolutely Scrumptious. Pizza was phenomenal. Loved it! Everything was perfect even though I ordered out. Order was ready when I got there & just the smell, I couldn't wait to get home to have a piece. Sheer Perfection.“

“A nice little place that has been in the downtown for close to 20 years. You enter through the bar that is roomy while also having hightop tables. When entering main dining, the first thing we noticed was the piano player, which is a super-cool touch! He played some fun songs, including some of his own, cracked jokes, and also interacted with the crowd while not being intrusive at all. My wife and I each got a martini (Dirty Gin for her and Honey Nut Cheerio for me) and both were delicious. As an appetizer, we got Eggplant Melanzane, which was light, had great flavor, and a delicious vodka sauce. My better half had a Caesar salad with probably the best Caesar dressing we have ever had. I went with the gorgonzola salad that had a nice, tart raspberry vinaigrette. For our entrees, she had the chicken special, which featured thin chicken breast and portobello mushrooms in a port wine sauce, topped with gorgonzola. It was very earthy and deep, a worthy special. I had the Pollo Sambuca, which is the same thin chicken breast with shrimp and mushrooms in a creamy sambuca sauce. It was very flavorful and slightly sweet. The anise is there, but not distracting. This was a solid meal! Our server, Thellenza, was attentive and informative. She made sure we understood all of the specials and took care of anything we asked. The rest of the staff is also helpful, too, and we were never in need of anything for long at all. The adult beverages that we enjoyed were definitely tasty, we just wish they had more of a wine and beer selection. Food: 9 Service: 10 Atmosphere: 10 Adult Drink Selection: 8 Overall: 9.25“

“I never leave reviews, but I was so impressed by my experience here on Saturday that I just feel like I really have to. My girlfriends and I met here for a girls night over the weekend and every single one of the four of us had nothing but great things to say about the whole evening. The service vibes were IMMACULATE; from the hostess, to the server, to the bartender, everyone added a positive energy to the restaurant. The food and drinks.. MY GAWD. We ordered quite a bit of food for the four of us to share, and there was not one single thing that we didn’t love; seriously, we talked about how good the food was for hours to everyone any anyone who would listen. Its two days later and I’m still talking about it and telling my husband that we need to make a reservation for our next date night. Seriously, one of the best restaurant experiences I have ever had.“

“Outstanding Italian Family Service. Great food and prices.“

“Tried Sibio’s for first time today for lunch- definitely worth the drive. Food was very good and prices appropriate. I definitely enjoyed this wonderful Italian restaurant. Decor falls between original 1970s and a little updated - but that was charming and likely kept prices so reasonable. The place was quite busy for an afternoon lunch and service prompt and attentive enough! Highly recommend - we will be back to try more. Everything coming out of the kitchen looked great!“

“Have always had a great meal and pleasant experience. Anything I’ve tried has been great and desserts are a must (I usually pass on desserts anywhere else…)“

“Ordered for the first time yesterday for lunch. The food I ordered was delicious and fresh with good quality ingredients. The guy that took my order was kind and patient which is appreciated and delivery was fast. Prices are reasonable as well. Great job D’Amore thanks again for the great food, service and delivery!“

“the food is good, nice variety of menu options and the staff is very friendly.“

“The thai chicken soup might be one of the best things I’ve ever tasted in my life.“

“Been here many times,, had so many different meals. I haven’t been disappointed YET. Mike comes out and Greets his customers. The the atmosphere..“

“We got several items from their Easter catering menu & everything was absolutely delicious! Quiche, macaroni and cheese, pierogis, chicken francese. It was such a big help to be able to grab some locally prepared dishes for the weekend. We will look forward to doing it again!“

“Edited to add this was in Honesdale place 🥰. We accidentally ordered a different style than we usually get, so I thought they "burned" our NY style. NOPE! It was the American Pie 🎶! After sending a Pic, they explained it in the nicest way. Polite, great communication! Also nice to note, that there's a lot of complexity to their pies-sometimes restaurants use the same pies just "add" a slight change. Now we're inerested in trying some other styles! Thank you for bringing on the excellent customer service!!“

“We recently moved to the area a year ago and was looking for a perfect place to have our daughters 1st birthday party when we came across St. Anthony Center. On June 3 2023 we had our daughters party and it was absolutely fabulous I couldn’t have asked for a better place and better staff to have our daughters party at. They helped with everything and anything we needed and our family enjoyed Linda and everything she did for us. We are now looking forward to having future events at St. Anthony Center! Thank you again for a perfect event!“

“Enjoying a pleasant meal out is always a treat, and Stirna's never fails to impress. My husband and I chose it for our anniversary dinner, and from the moment we stepped inside, the wait staff provided top-notch service, making us feel genuinely welcome. The food was delicious, and those legendary Stirna's brownies are always a must for a sweet treat. Much thanks to Cathy and her team.“

“The thai chicken soup might be one of the best things I’ve ever tasted in my life.“

“I've lived around the corner for a year, but never tried their place 'til last night. Got a pizza for my upstairs neighbor and myself to split. It's unique, and for 5$, you can't beat it. She and I (mostly me) almost ate the whole 12 cuts too!“

“I was just here last Friday. I was here about 15 years ago. I liked it then and it might even be a little better now. GREAT N.Y. Style Pizza! Try some Wings too. Good stuff. Next time I go in I will try Tacos. Give them a shot. Very reasonable Prices too. ❤️“

“Great pizza! Get it at work occasionally and never disappointed.“

“Just love the people and the food! You can't go wrong no matter what you order.“

“Great place, friendly staff and food is delicious.“

“Frequented this establishment often…I LOVE LOVE LOVE the FRESHNESS of the rolls n deli meat…I ALWAYS get the Turkey n Cheese w/that YUMMY SPICEY MAYO….& follow up with the Carrot Cupcake…I HIGHLY recommend this place….the OWNER is very SOCIABLE w/his customers which is nice…1 greeting could really make a difference in some1’s life….the staff are very Courteous and Friendly as well….Overall: I LOVE LOVE LOVE this establishment🙂Go check them out!!!!👍🏾“

“This was a very nice place me and my family came to ALL the food was fresh flavorful and so reasonable with the pricing and best part was they give you big portions and I don’t even think I saw anything over $25 on menu I highly recommend going I am looking forward to eating on the terrace this summer“

“Best place to go for all your pizza needs“

“Had never been here before. Found them on the upside app & decided to give it a try. Food & service was good. Would go back again.“

“We recently had breakfast at Carmen’s for the first time. It is a “hidden gem”, IMHO.

The food and beverage quality was very good.

The service was very good as well.

It is the Carmen’s and Lobby atmosphere that creates an “elevated experience”, we love the train station conversion. Very quaint.

So overall, an excellent experience and value.“

“Had to travel to Wilkes Barre, well worth the extra time to go to Old Forge. The classic red pizza tray was delicious, whole family loved it. Crust was perfect slightly crispy on bottom and great bread texture. The tomato and onion flavors are well balanced. The white pizza is also good, tons of cheese. Goes great with tomato soup the next day. Only slight issue was woody rosemary leaves on the white pizza, other seasonings are tasty. The kids enjoyed a quick game of bocce ball while the adults picked up the pizzas. Staff were friendly. Didn't get dessert this time but they're always delicious too“

“I am so glad I found this gem! The staff are so welcoming, the food is delicious, the prices are extremely affordable and the atmosphere is delightful ?

I love coming here!

(Seriously, try the cheesecake with raspberry drizzle! ?)“

“My husband and I were in Friday night. We had Joes seafood combo, mine with scampi sauce my hubby's was fra - diablo,both were magnificent! The seafood was so fresh cooked to perfection! As always, Joe, is so welcoming you feel like family! Our waitress was Angela so friendly..We love this place !“

“Simply the BEST.“

“Excellent Italian food. Family friendly.“