Jersey Mike's Subs in York

“Consistently in store pickup orders are incorrect. I would recommend opening your sub prior to leaving to verify the correct order. Multiple times wrong subs were given completely as well as incorrect bread/add ons. Always delicious sandwiches regardless !!“

“These are good and fresh Subs. They give you plenty of meat and toppings and if you join their email Club you get a dollar off the regular size pretty often. We found the employees to be very personable, beyond the just have a nice day.
Edit, July 2026 - Still an awesome place with pleasant workers and exceptionally made subs. Thanks for 8 years of consistently great food and service!“

“The staff is very polite and quick. They make sure you are good with everything they put on the subs and they turn out delicious every time. You may have to wait a little bit if there’s a line,but you’re definitely getting a better sub here than other chains.“