8 Best Pizza Restaurants in Cookeville

“I've been a big fan of Big Tony's ever since they opened their doors. It's the only place in Cookeville to get Authentic New York Style Pizza. The prices are reasonable, service fantastic and the food spectacular! There's a reason why they were rated #1 in 2023!“

“Best pizza in town!! People will tell you another local place is the best, they are wrong- this is it! I haven’t ever gotten anything other than pizza in the YEARS I have eaten here other than the pasta salad and some desserts. A lot of the negative reviews talk about the other food items which I don’t have experience with. Staff is always friendly & kind when I have been in and most recently been in with my 1yr old- they are so kind. The atmosphere is so cute and feels very hole-in-the-wall but is extremely limited seating. 10/10 recommend!Kid-friendliness: Extremely small place BUT they are great to help me in with my stroller and we usually eat at the table outside and they bring my food to me. They are so kind & helpful!“

“I recommend the pepperoni pizza cause that's what I ordered, my gf got the garlic knots as well and they were both perfect. I'm going to attach photos of them both but it won't do them justice. I could tell there is real pieces of garlic in the knots, didn't taste minced at all.The service was friendly, very laid back group of people. Today is the first time I've had it but it won't be the last. I recommend if you like local tastes to follow this place. Can tell a lot of work was put in over the years into their crust recipe. Everyone in COOKEVILLE loves the pizza machine and now I see why. Love the mural on the side of the bus , from the name to the mural to the way to pay, everything about this biz is original and creative.“

“We love our visits to Slice! The kids love the variety of games and claw machines. The card system for tickets is excellent too. The little prizes are always neat too. The food is tasty and comes out in a timely manner. We're very grateful to have such a fun place to bring the kids for birthdays or just because.“

“Me and my wife ate there last night 03/13/24. We got the crab cakes as an appetizer and they were so good. My wife had the New York style pizza and I had a Chicago style. Both pizzas were amazing. Are server Anthony was very friendly and spot on with the service. Place is clean and has a great atmosphere will definitely be my new go to place for pizza and future date nights“

“In a previous incarnation, we walked into this place and right back out, as the previous owners allowed smoking inside. Nope.This new incarnation is quickly becoming a favorite, with good food and service, a decent beer and wine selection, and a calm and friendly atmosphere.We'll keep coming back.“

“Ordered a large veggie pizza, carry out. Cooked well done. Deborah, who was working the counter was cheerful and welcoming. She made sure everything was correct and I was happy before I left with my pizza. She made the experience pleasant. The pizza was fantastic and perfectly prepared. We will definitely order from this Pizza Hut again. The inside was clean and payment was fast and easy.“

“I've eaten here before but it's been so long I couldn't remember. My vegan mother has said it will be her new favorite restaurant. She got an amazing looking veggie sandwich LOADED with veggies and the baked fries. My sister and I got the chicken Alfredo pizza and garlic cheese bread. They were both were good, full of flavor. All their bread is made in house and it shows. My only very small complaint because I didn't even need it but I wasn't a fan of their ranch. The service was excellent everyone was very friendly . The food came out promptly and accurately. We will definitely be back!“