18 Best Pizza Restaurants in Cookeville

“I am from NY originally and honestly I have a high bar for pizza that I will call good. Since living in the South I feel like I am on an endless search for pizza that reminds me of what I can get at home. Big Tony's checks all the boxes. The pizza was exactly what I like for crust, sauce and toppings. The staff was friendly and attentive, and the space was comfortable enough to sit and chat with a friend I haven't seen in years until it was closing time. We will be back, even though it's an hour drive from where I live in Lebanon.“

“Absolutely the most consistent pizza in town and they always taste fantastic“

“You can not go wrong with anything on the menu ! The special pie is not to be missed !“

“The Slice is a wonderful place for family fun!“

“you can't say enough thank you for the best pie“

“Employees have a great attitude, the service is very good as well as the atmosphere when you walk in the door.
I’ve not been disappointed in any pizza I’ve ordered. If in Cookeville, TN it’ll be worth stopping in to take a pizza home to bake and enjoy! You probably will not be disappointed, I know I haven’t as many times I’ve been there.“

“Just left Gene’s Place after having my go to cup of chili and hubby had soft pretzel with a really good cheese dipping sauce. We switched plates and he liked my chili and I had the pretzel with cheese.! It’s all soooo good! If you haven’t stopped in yet you’re missing something!“

“Harper and Savannah were amazing! First time dining here, but had heard wonderful things from friends and they were right. Will definitely be going back!“

“The employees were very nice and appeared to be good employees. We stopped in after being next door and really enjoyed the pizza. We ate in but I suspect most of their business is take out or delivery. The store was clean and pleasant enough. We will head back soon to try the sandwiches.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“they have the best subs and pizza.“

“Five pizzas and 32 count of Parmesan bites ! Took only like 15 min GREAT JOB YOU GUYS ! Thank y’all for your AWESOME SERVICE AND FIXING WHAT NEEDED TO BE FIXED !“

“Once a week I babysit, and no matter what food I prepare I just can't please these two kids. I started ordering 2 medium 1 toppings from Pizza Hut and it feeds me and both of them for under $20 and they love it. Well, me too. Almost every Sunday night, the crew on Neal St. knock it out of the park. I say almost every Sunday because sometimes I don't babysit til Tuesday Or Wednesday. In which case, they still nail it. This has been going on for like...6 months lol I don't know why I never left a review before. They all deserve huge props and bigger raises.“

“Pizza Hut – A Solid Go-To Near Campus

This Pizza Hut, just a few blocks from campus, is a well-run and consistently reliable option for students and locals alike. The location is clean, well-maintained, and clearly managed with care.

Pickup is by far the most popular service here, and it’s easy to see why...it’s fast, efficient, and rarely delayed. The staff handles high-volume times smoothly, especially during lunch and late evenings.

What stands out most is how PH has diversified its offerings over the past few years. Whether you're looking for a budget-friendly meal deal, vegetarian options, or family-style combos, there’s something for everyone. They’ve done a great job expanding their appeal to different market segments without sacrificing quality or price integrity.

Overall, this Pizza Hut hits the mark on convenience, cleanliness, and customer-focused service. It’s a dependable spot for a quick pickup or a casual meal close to campus.“

“Fast and hot.Great wings! ,brownies and drinks. I also like Players billiards,bar and grill great servers,food and a juke box that can play just about any kind of music you can imagine. Its a very,clean,safe and respectable place. 👏“

“The Crazy Puffs are my favorite things ever! I love going to get an order of these every couple of weeks. The employees are normally very nice even when they are crazy busy. Great value for the items you can get here. I definitely recommend!“

“The two boys working are very sweet and delightful and respectful!! This was my second time trying them an by far the best pizza I’ve had in a long time !!!! N there Stromboli was amazing and so is there salad !! No pics we just devoured it lol“

“We stopped for dinner with friends while we were in Cookeville for a funeral visitation. We had such a great time mainly because our server, Brooklyn. She knew the menu, was friendly and had helpful suggestions.“