9 Best Sandwich Shops in Morristown

1 Redbud Deli

4.5 Superb 294 Reviews

345 East Economy Road, Morristown

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Foods fresh and people friendly”

2 Firehouse Subs Merchants Greene

3.9 Good 208 Reviews

140 Hatfield Drive Suite 3, Morristown

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Yesterday at lunchtime, I ordered three subs to go. There was such a large amount of mayonnaise and/or dressing on them that they were soggy. They were almost impossible to eat as they fell apart when you picked them up. A major disappointment!”

3 Jimmy John's

4.4 Superb 30 Reviews

4310 Evan Greene Plaza Suite 101, Morristown

“We got two turkey Tom's with only mayo for a pick up order. It was ready in 2 to 3 minutes tops! The bread was fresh and the turkey is amazing. Me and my husband don't even really like turkey but theirs is great! We also got a potato salad for free using our jimmy johns app. It was great too.. Will definitely be back. Huge shout out to the manager BB 👏 he was awesome!”

4 Subway

3.6 Good 106 Reviews

2427 East Andrew Johnson Highway, Morristown

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I've been a Subway fan for years, and my local spot never disappoints. Stopped in during lunch rush today, and the staff nailed it—super friendly, no wait despite the crowd. I went for the classic Italian B.M.T. on Italian herbs & cheese bread, loaded with all the fixings: extra provolone, banana peppers for that zing, and a drizzle of sweet onion sauce. Crispy veggies, perfectly toasted, and the portions? Generous without feeling stuffed. What I love most is how customizable everything is—gluten-free bread option for my picky friend, and they even subbed in some fresh avocado on the fly. Portions are spot-on, prices fair (under $10 for a footlong meal), and it hit the spot without the post-meal slump. Clean store, contactless payment was a breeze. If you're craving something healthy-ish but delicious, Subway's your go-to. Keep crushing it, team—I'll be back next week!”

5 Jersey Mike's Subs

3.4 Good 38 Reviews

1117 East Morris Boulevard, Morristown

• Delivery

“A great experience worth talking about! I made a pick up order around 8:30PM. Got to the store around 8:45PM and picked up my order. Drove home and realized I had the wrong order. No issue, I’ll run back, expect they close at 9PM I arrive at 9:15PM and the manager (I assume) and two others are cleaning up after a presumingly long day. I called the store while sitting out front and the manager picked up. I explained the situation and he met me at the door. Once he realized what happened, he has no issue getting everything back out, putting the slicer back together and making the sandwiches I ordered. It could’ve been a bad overall experience but seeing the people in the store taking care of the customer made this a great experience. I appreciate the manager and his staff for taking care of me tonight. Happy wife, happy life as one of the sandwiches was hers! Thanks again.”

6 Subway

3.4 Good 116 Reviews

2788 West Andrew Johnson Highway, Morristown

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best Subway in town!”

7 Subway

3.1 Average 50 Reviews

5969 West Andrew Johnson Highway, Morristown

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great staff and good fresh (processed) food.Pros:Prep area was clean and orderlyVeggies looked fresh and unwiltedTea was on point and freshFriendly staffSame'ol Subway pricingCons:Sometimes theres a wait due to factory workers hitting the place up for lunch. (Great choice guys/gals)Parking is horrible as its connected to a busy gas station.”

8 Subway

3.2 Average 99 Reviews

211 East Morris Boulevard, Morristown

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Danielle was wonderful, I’ve been here a couple times this week and both times she was cheerful and upbeat, a sweetheart to talk to, and the service was amazing! She deserves good things her way, and I’ll definitely be dining with subway more often because of the customer service. The entire store was also extremely clean and tidy, and the food- my custom sandwiches- are absolutely amazing. Everything is just right here, cannot recommend this subway enough!”

9 Subway

3.0 Average 131 Reviews

105 Thoroughbred Run Road, Morristown

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“When I came in I didn't expect the man who was working to be as knowledgeable and friendly as he was. John was the only one in the store running it at the time. He had informed me of all the different possibilities that weren't even on the menu in store. He was extremely friendly and helpful. The store was fairly clean. As he handled my order he would offer options and give recommendations. All together it was a good experience, and i had fun while ordering food and you don't get that kind of exchange in the food industry anymore.”