Sandwich Shops in Sulphur Springs

“If you're looking for a charming, no-fuss spot to enjoy a fresh, flavorful meal in Sulphur Springs, Texas, Plain and Fancy Sandwich Shoppe should be at the top of your list. Located at 120 Main Street in the heart of downtown, this beloved eatery has been a local staple for over 20 years. The atmosphere at Plain and Fancy is warm, welcoming, and full of small-town charm. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, you'll be greeted like family. Customers often praise the friendly staff and upbeat vibe, it's the kind of place where everyone knows your name and goes the extra mile to make sure you leave happy. The menu is just as inviting, offering a wide variety of options to suit any palate. From tried-and-true classics like the Reuben and BLT to lighter, vegetarian-friendly selections, there's truly something for everyone. The “fancy chicken salad” is a standout favorite, consistently recommended by regulars. And don’t skip the soups, salads, or desserts, each one is as satisfying as the next, with many customers calling them “over-the-moon yummy.” Special shoutout to Sandi and Heather, who are absolute rockstars, along with the rest of the hardworking team who keep this local gem running smoothly every day. If we could give it 10 stars, we would!“

“I want to say thank you to the gentleman that suggested avocado on the chicken, bacon, ranch calzone, that was the best thing ever!!! it was so good I appreciate your recommendation and service!! 🥳“

“I love this subway...the owner is awesome to her staff and it comes across in how they treat their customers. The staff is always ready and willing to satisfy the customer and make sure they have a good experience. The food is good and they make sure you get your monies worth. Ingredients are always fresh. The facility is always clean and looks great. Thanks for a great experience! Tell Dani I said hi!“

“This is by far the best subway I have ever eaten at. I don’t know what it is about the manager, but I prefer her to make my sandwich. It always seems to be made with love. She is generally kind to every customer that comes in super welcoming and is by far the best thing that has happened to Subway. I live in Yantis and used to go to the subway over there because it’s closer to my house but one trip to the subway and this is now my favorite shop I drive all the way to Sulphur Springs just to eat here and it’s mainly because of Amanda. She is a great person. Don’t listen to the bad reviews because they are 100% wrong.“