50 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Lake Hills

“I ordered 2 large pizzas and 1 large garden salad to go. The pizza and salad were perfect, and the Sal was top-notch!! Will definitely go back to Baldinucci the next time I am in Austin.“

“This was the very first MOD Pizza location I ever visited a few years ago, and it immediately made me a fan. The restaurant was very clean, had a welcoming atmosphere, and the staff was incredibly patient and helpful, especially since I had no idea how the ordering process worked or what to choose.

The food was fresh, made exactly how I wanted it, and very reasonably priced, which made the experience even better. The ability to customize everything and still get a quality meal quickly really stood out to me.

Because of that first visit, I’ve become a loyal customer and make it a point to stop at any MOD Pizza location I come across.“

“Great place! If you don’t order the cannoli, you are missing out!“

“Luis R. was incredibly helpful today. I had made a mistake with my takeout order, and he immediately stepped in and took care of it without any hassle. He got everything corrected and my food out to me very quickly. I really appreciated how kind and proactive he was. It made what could have been a frustrating situation very easy. Thank you, Luis!“

“My favorite Italian sub in Town. Took it to go today, so I coyest it during the Texas Kansas game.“

“Had a solid night at Pinthouse Pizza and it did not miss.

We ordered the Oh La La and The Works plus a Caesar salad. First of all, that salad was massive. Not one of those sad side salads, this thing could’ve been a meal on its own. Fresh, crunchy, plenty of dressing, no skimping.

The pizzas came out quick which I always respect, especially when it’s busy. Both were so good but in totally different ways. The Oh La La had that sweet and savory combo that just works, and The Works was stacked with toppings without being overwhelming. Crust was on point, not too thick, not floppy, just right.

We didn’t grab any beers, but everything coming out around us looked legit. You can tell they take their brewing seriously.

There’s plenty of seating so it doesn’t feel cramped, and the whole vibe is easy and relaxed. Good for a casual dinner, group hang, whatever.

Fast service, big portions, great pizza. I’d definitely go back.“

“After a delivery issue where things went sideways, the man himself (no, not Conan) cooked and delivered a replacement. Conan’s South for life! Savage for life!“

“Great food and wonderful customer service. I will definitely come back in the future. Gabriel Culiat. Great pizza“

“I came for the "grandma" pizza, and it's terrific. But I'm coming back for the NYC slices, which are crispy perfection. Is it as good as NYC? No - it's better. Check out my full review at "Pizza Quixote" (google it). Five stars!“

“Delicious food! I had a Roma Supreme Pizza and a Calzone (well, there were 2 of us!). Both were so good, the recipe was on point. Definitely add me as a repeat customer.“

“Had an incredible experience at DeSano Pizzeria in downtown Austin. The Margherita pizza was absolute perfection — beautifully balanced seasoning, rich melted cheese, and that classic, authentic flavor that hits every note just right. The atmosphere was warm, lively, and inviting, making it the perfect spot to relax and enjoy great food. And the service? Stellar from start to finish — friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. If you’re in Austin and craving top-tier pizza with an unforgettable vibe, DeSano is a must-visit. 👏🔥“

“The Detroiter Extra Crispy is the best!“

“Absolutely delicious! We had garlic knots, salad, calzone and pizza. Best pizza in Austin!“

“Amazing pizza. New York style thin crust. I love the fact you can get a giant pie divided into 6 individual slices. We started with the Caesar salad, which was large and fresh. Our pizza had slices of the stracciatella, sweet sausage, cacio e pepe, pepperoni, spicy margh, and pickle pizzas (may have been limited time). Great date night experience, when you factor in Flo’s Wine Bar. Beware, the line can get long. It took us 30-40 minutes waiting in line on a Friday night to order and find a table. So would recommend you plan ahead as to not get hangry. Otherwise, Allday also has clean merch. I have a shirt and hat, always happy to support a local business, especially one with fire pizza.“

“This establishment is wonderful. The food is delicious. Gabriel Culiat believes the customer service is top notch. I'll definitely be back in the future“

“My favorite Italian sub in Town. Took it to go today, so I coyest it during the Texas Kansas game.“

“Hands down the best pizza spot in Austin fresh ingredients, amazing flavor, and great vibes every time!“

“The Detroiter Extra Crispy is the best!“

“I highly recommend it all! Pizza, cheesesteak and meatballs were to die for!!! Best we have had in a long time!! Great service and atmosphere!!“

“I absolutely love this place. Some of the best pizza in Texas, hands down. Plus the staff and owners are really solid, good people.“

“I am pizza snob and this spot never fails! I get extra sauce and the cook it a lil bit longer so it’s not soggy. Not many places do that without asking ! Their sandwiches can feed a small family 😂 the chicken pesto is the best! The hidden gem on the menu is the Greek salad ! It’s super fresh, the feta is firm and delicious by itself !“

“Great Food and Service! Thank you all for a great experience!“

“I’m someone who loves pizza and a salad. Unfortunately, I cant just pop in by myself to get that little combo bc they only have pricey gigantic salads. Would be great if there was a half size for like $8-10. Then I might come back to grab that and a slice.

Also, last visit I went with my partner and had weird service. Idk if I was gaslit lol. I ordered a salad and sub for myself. My partner ordered two slices of pizza.

My salad and sub came out. Waited literally 30m for the two slices of pizza. So my partner pretty much watched me eat for half an hour. When I inquired about the pizza slices for my partner, the server said “yeah the chefs do that intentionally so you can enjoy the salad and sandwich first”. Who splits a sandwich before sharing a slice of pizza? Clearly they were running way behind and just acknowledgement (maybe an apology) would have been enough. Instead I was annoyed and felt crazy.

Regarding the meatball sub - the bread was super hard like cut the top of your mouth hard. Meatball was super tender but lacked ?herbs.“

“Hands down best Pizza I’ve found in Austin since Conan’s South. I have been loyal and have to say that the manager Art was super helpful and went above and beyond for us! Thank you!! 😊 -Mizzy Rivera“

“We heard about this place from Dave Portnoy and had to go try it out ourselves. As soon as we opened the box we knew it would be amazing. The presentations was beautiful. We orders the classic and the vodka. Oh my gosh the vodka pizza was one of the best pizzas I have ever had in my life. It is now our top fav pizza in Austin. If you haven’t tried it the you must. Such a cute place and the staff is amazing and so in. They truly put their love into what they do! A forever customer now.“

“Lots of great pizza and salad choices. They also have a huge beer selection along with wine. The pizza was tasty, fresh and they piled on the toppings, no skimping there!“

“We stopped by to have cocktail. We had the creamsicle and it was so tasty. I accidentally drank it way too fast. I’m hoping it doesn’t hit me too hard.

The texture was so soft it went down like butter. You could taste all the flavors equally.

I’d go back. I need to try the food next time.“

“Absolutely amazing food in an equally fantastic establishment. Tony makes some stellar food that I couldn't even compare to others. If you have a choice between food trucks at Meanwhile Brewing, make this your #1 choice.“

“They have the worst calzones. The dough is horrible, the ricotta is horrible and the pizza sauce is horrible. Paid $30 for two calzones to not even be able to eat much of it because it made me nauseous and tore up my stomach. This will be my last time to eat there and if I could have given it zero stars I would have. Me and my husband both threw most of it in the trash. Complete waste of money“

“Awesome pizza. Awesome meatballs. Love this place. (Would love it even more if you opened one in Belterra Village on 290.)“

“Visiting from Auburn, Alabama and decided to check out Love Supreme. The manager gave us a run down of the menu. They have an experienced chef who makes everything in-house. We ordered a pepperoni pizza and it came with a side of homemade ranch that was amazing. The food came out hot and in a timely. The manager checked on us to make sure we had a great experience. There is only ONE Love Supreme, so if you are in Austin, Texas, we highly recommend checking it out. You will not be disappointed.“

“Best pizza in Austin, amazing flavor pizza, extra crispy if you desire, large portions, extra clean dining with comfortable seating! Happy Hour!“

“Absolutely excellent pizza. This is our favorite pizza. We come here at least one time a week or we order it in at our house and my husband is obsessed with the sandwiches!“

“By far the BEST PIZZA ROLLS I’ve ever had! They are not doughy on the inside, instead they are FILLED with ingredients, and I mean filled! The outer roll is the perfect amount of crunch and they are simply delicious. You get a few options for dipping sauces and you can get a single order, a shareable order or a family order. I will never eat pizza rolls from anywhere else ever again...FACT!“

“All you can play video games and pinball!?!? Yes please. The pizza and cider are pretty good as well!“

“Best crust in Austin! no... actually the best crust in America!“

“Great Birthday 🎂 experience“

“by far best pizza in town!“

“Wonderful establishment. Food is great . Gabriel Culiat will definitely recommend them to family and friends“

“Just yum!!! The crust is great, and you get to pick your own toppings with choice of sauce drizzle. Wish I were in Austin to go right now!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Newk’s is always one of my favorite places to eat! The food is consistently fresh, flavorful, and comes out fast without ever feeling like “fast food.” Their menu has something for everyone, and the quality never disappoints. The staff is friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere is casual but inviting—perfect for a quick lunch or an easy dinner. Always a reliable go-to spot!“

“Soo delicious!! Definitely one of THE BEST calzones we’ve ever had!!! Gotta try this place!“

“Absolutely excellent pizza. This is our favorite pizza. We come here at least one time a week or we order it in at our house and my husband is obsessed with the sandwiches!“

“Amazing pizza and great customer service! I would absolutely recommend Slice of Austin to anyone in the Austin area.“

“I always get great service at Papa Murphy's.

I call my order ahead, and I get through checkout quickly, and with friendly service.

I love the freshness of baking my own pizza.

There are never enough pineapples on the Hawaiian, so I buy a can at the grocery store, or fresh pineapple at the farmers market, to add to my pizza.

Yum!“

“The wait was long, but Alli was the absolute best wait staff. She hustled between our large group and several other tables and never lost her shine. The food was okay.“

“Great pizza and friendly staff!“

“The pizza was fire. I had the shallots and Serranos and it had a solid level of heat but not too overpowering. Crust could have been slightly crispier but no significant flop so I was still very pleased with it. Highly recommend trying this pie but also adding sausage to it next time. I also hear their Caesar salad wrap available for lunch on weekdays is excellent as well“

“best pie in texas!! Everything they make is delicious, owner is a super nice guy.If I've ever had a better piece I can't remember right where that was!! Stony's is as good as it gets. I would give it 20 stars if I could“

“Authentic delicious Italian food, friendly staff and great service. We loved AJ, we thought she was the owner but she told us she is an employee, she made us feel so welcome and showed genuine passion for her craft. Great little restaurant reminiscent of an Italian trattoria in Italy.“