10 Best Mexican Restaurants in Payson

Don't miss Payson's top Mexican restaurants, as recommended by Restaurantji. Enjoy the best Ceviche, Shrimp Tacos, Birria, and more in the city.

Snapper Mexican Seafood Mexican • $
3 N Main St, Payson

Customers` Favorites

Quesatacos De Birria Order of 3
Charola Ceviche 4-6 P
Quesadilla De Camaron
Chicharron de Pescado
Guacamole & Chips
Enchiladas Suizas
Chips & Salsa
Mojarra Frita
Shrimp Tacos
Street Tacos

“Love this place! True latin fare, my new favorite.“

5 Superb67 Reviews
El Tapatio Mexican • $
47 S Main St, Payson

Customers` Favorites

Pineapple Chicken and Steak Fajitas
Carne Asada Chile Verde Burrito
Ask for the Pineapple Fajitas
Chile Relleno Y Enchiladas
Pineapple Chicken Fajita
Chicken Enchiladas
Carne Asada Plate
Chips and Salsa
Al Mojo de Ajo
Piña Fajitas

“I went here after a friend told me about it. It was incredible. The Pineapple fajitas was why I went. They position was huge and served in a half pineapple. It feed myself, son and daughter-in-law and we had left overs. Their guacamole was excellent. The service was great also!
If you haven’t gone, I highly recommend it!!“

4.5 Superb127 Reviews
La Alteña Taqueria Mexican • $
190 E 100 N, Payson

Customers` Favorites

Carne Asada
Al Pastor

“(DO NOT ORDER ONLINE)
This place is delicious. The meet is very well seasoned!!!! The tortillas made by hand and omg! Only reason it gets -1 star was because I ordered online, it got canceled and I had to call them and asked what happened. They say they don't take online but the website gave me the option so I was just confused lol. Besides that I wish I would of gotten more cabeza quesadillas!!! So yummy“

4.9 Superb43 Reviews
Maroan’s Mexican Food Mexican • $
898 E 100 S, Payson

Customers` Favorites

Beef Head Cabeza
Chorizo Sausage
Chicharron
Al Pastor
Steak

“there food is so good I would go there everyday and there service is so good they make your food so fast there salsa bar is so clean and you can even get your own toppings there really nice!“

4.7 Superb54 Reviews
MI Rancherito Mexican Restaurant Mexican • $
85 E Utah Ave, Payson

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Enchilada and Beef Taco with Beans and Rice
10 Beef Enchilada Beef Tamale Beef Taco
Chicken Enchiladas with Salad and Beans
Beef & Bean Tostada and Beef Tamale
Carne Asada Plate
Cheese Burrito
Chips and Salsa
Chile Verde
Chimichanga
Taco Salad

“Tucked in the historic downtown Payson this Quant location has yummy food, I enjoy the steak fajitas and making a wish in their indoor fountain. 😋
Expert tip - allow an extra hour or two to visit the awesome stores on Utah Avenue.“

4 Good119 Reviews
Taco Time Mexican • $
212 S 100 W, Payson

Customers` Favorites

Crisp Bean Burrito or Beef Option Too
Chicken Ranchero Burrito
Crisp Pinto Bean Burrito
Crisp Chicken Burrito
Chicken blt Burrito
Crisp Meat Burrito
Stuffed Mexi-Fries
Egg & Tater Burrito
Taco Mexican Fries
Chicken Quesadilla

“Great old taco time! For the age of the building it was super clean and the employees were very polite. Food was good, hot and fresh. Only complaint about taco time is it seems a bit steep in price compared to what you get. It was tasty and fresh. Didn’t give me diarrhea like other taco places do, that is a plus!“

3.7 Good111 Reviews
7

Beto's

Beto's Mexican • $
785 E 100 N, Payson

Customers` Favorites

Bacon and Egg Breakfast Burritos
Grilled Chicken Burrito
Chile Verde Smothered
Chile Verde Burrito
Carnitas Burrito
Carnitas Plate
Two Enchiladas
Chorizo Fries
Rolled Tacos
Pico Salsa

“this place is the best. they never mess my order up, and I stumble in here at odd hours and it's still amazing. 10/10 for those that know.“

3.6 Good96 Reviews
Los 4 Amigos Restaurant Mexican • $
110 N 800 E St, Payson

Customers` Favorites

Ground Beef Soft Taco and Chicken Enchilada
Bean and Cheese Burrito Chile Verde Burrito
It's Supposed to Be a Smothered Burrito
Shredded Beef Chimichanga
Smothered Beef Burritos
Chips and Guacamole
Chips and Salsa
Cheese Enchilada
Rice and Beans
Chile Rellenos

“Food was ok, kinda bland. Service was really good. Our waitress was very nice and courteous. Food just needed more seasoning.“

3.5 Good74 Reviews
Costa Vida Mexican • $
818 Turf Farm Rd, Payson

Customers` Favorites

Queso Smothered Burrito
Chicken Tortilla Soup
Grilled Chicken Salad
Sweet Pork Quesadilla
Shredded Beef Nachos
Sweet Pork Salad
Burrito and Salad
Grilled Chicken
Dulce De Leche
Chips & Queso

“Went through the drive through and our order was wrong. So we took the food back into the store to get our correct order, and Annie helped us. Annie went above and beyond to make sure we were satisfied and everything was correct. To put it simply this girl needs a raise“

3.2 Average119 Reviews
Don Chuy's Taco Shop Mexican • $
1024 W 800 S, Payson

Customers` Favorites

Pork Chile Verde Smothered Burrito
4 Birria Streettacos w Consome
Breakfast Steak Burrito
Breakfast Burrito Tray
Carne Asada Enchiladas
Carne Asada Burrito
California Burrito
Hot Cheeto Burrito
Carne Asada Nachos
Carne Asada Plate

“I recently had my first purchase via drive through at Chuys. I had heard that it was a good spot for food and wanted to give it a shot. We ordered some asada fries and burritos. Overall service was pleasant and they made the order fast. I asked for very well done meat and they definitely listened which I loved because places usually dont do it. I do feel that the food was overpriced for what I got comparatively to other local area taco shops. The food itself was good/ almost basic but the salsa was not it. Its was very watered down which I didn’t like. I“

3.2 Average138 Reviews

You May Also Like