“It was a new find for us newcomers to the NNK. We followed the signs and were thrilled to find such a wonderful place on the water. The owner shared his story with us and the wait staff was so helpful and kind. My fried oysters were delicious. The appetizer of Philly steak egg rolls was tasty and unique. I had fun checking out the gift store. We will return since they're open in the winter. And we can't wait to join friends there and arrive on our boat. What an unexpectedly wonderful evening. Oh and their cranberry margaritas were pretty good too!!!!“
“This place has changed hands/leadership and thus has had waves of good and bad. Worst was some okesh pizza, but we always came back. The managment and staff are in full stride now and have worked out the kinks.Great service, friendly staff, really good food at good prices and with very large portions. Plus, Icecream is an option! Its a NNK staple.“
“Tasty food, a lovely place to eat (I enjoyed my lunch outside, and there is indoor seating as well), and the sweetest folks providing it all. Loved the key lime pie! Bonus: shopping in the tavern art guild shop, where every item is unique and handmade by local artisans, and prices were so reasonable!“
“This is my favorite restaurant in town. Actually I can't think of many places that are better even when we go to the big city I love Casey's. Their food is great. The atmosphere is fun clean and I love everything about it. Hope you guys stay there for a long time.“
“The food was excellent and my server did a good job. However there were several people sitting at the bar that were drunk, loud and out of control. Some of them were employees. Their language was horrible and I ate my dinner as they loudly discussed women’s nipples. So inappropriate in a restaurant! If I ever return, it definitely won’t be for dinner if this is how the restaurant is allowed to operate. I ate my entire meal listening to ongoing cursing in every sentence and other vulgarities. If the food wasn’t so good I would have walked out. The owners need to take a long look at their staff before the full season starts or you’ll be loosing a lot of business.“
“Honestly wondering how this restaurant is still in business.Fresh food, prepared incredibly fast, served up by a staff that always seems happy, and at a very reasonable price while inflation for ingredients is through the roof.Something ain't lining up ?So thankful for this family and their restaurant. Becoming a regular. ♥“