43 Best Pizza Restaurants near Yorktown

“Shout out to Jordan's Pizza for a delicious dinner tonight. I had one of those days where making a home cooked meal was the absolute last thing on my mind. Kids voted for pizza but I've been pretty unhappy with Marcos lately. Googled nearby delivery and their reviews seemed great. They're in Lackey off Old Willamsburg Rd. The pies were fantastic!I Big slices, New York style crust, and the sauce was perfect! Not too sweet and just the right consistency. 🤌🏻🤌🏻 We also got a baked ziti which came with a side salad and garlic knots. It was more than enough for two people to share and came to us nice and hot. We will definitely be ordering from them again!!“

“I was sent to “pick up” the pizza ? & got the surprise that I was paying for it at the counter. Pierre saw that I was totally duped & so very kindly paid for the pizza without saying anything!! ?? The love was everything! I’ve been coming here for years & still eat from other pizza shops, MARCOS has the BEST Customer Service, Period. They’re always finding ways to enjoy their job & make customers smile!“

“This is literally the only Pizza Hut in Newport News that I would go to! The rest of them I have no clue why they're so nasty or the food tastes gross... But this Pizza Hut is literally the only Pizza Hut that cooks the orders right... And they are nice and the food is always fresh and delicious. I don't understand why other Pizza huts can't do the same thing... I'm always willing to make the drive for this Pizza Hut lol“

“First off Gus' got a bit of a face lift since last I had visited, and it looks FANTASTIC. They added a bar, which looks great.Secondly their service was excellent, we actually apologetically came right before they were closing. Yet they were still able to serve us, and di an awesome job serving us.Third, their food was DELICIOUS. It ended up being an awesome restaurant visit.“

“Our ladies group is returning again tomorrow for another delicious, hot fresh excellent choice of varied, authentic Italian food. The service is great. each of the dishes anyone had were excellent!“

“Ordered pizza for dinner for my family. Matthew was amazing, went above and beyond. And had a great attitude, even though it was busy.
He helped us and got our order, even after other employees look and just walked by. One employee even asked if we had a pickup order and asked the name on the order and just walked away and never came back. And the 2 other employees on their phones didn’t help either.

Matthew was amazing and because of him, turned the experience around.“

“We had such a wonderful experience at this Italian restaurant! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt warm and welcoming. The staff was attentive, friendly, and made sure we had everything we needed.

The food was absolutely delicious—fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. The pasta tasted homemade, the sauces were rich and perfectly seasoned, and the portions were generous without being overwhelming. We also loved the appetizers and desserts; everything tasted authentic and prepared with care.“

“We always prefer to order from this location! The service is friendly and the food is always great! They’re relatively quick too once they get our order in. There has only been one time we had a long wait and that was because we ordered on game night at dinner time.“

“Most authentic Italian food for miles. 10/10“

“Best pizza and subs in town!“

“Food will speak for its self. Great authentic pizza. Dough is homemade and you can taste the work and effort they put into their ingredients. If you know and love what genuine pizza should taste like, this place is a must try. Great job guys! Keep up your hard work!“

“Love this place!!! Great food, great people, great vibes“

“Tastiest donuts around!!! 🍩💜“

“A quick online search for pizza as we were heading through Gloucester included this place. What a delightful find! The pizza and garlic knots were delicious and the waitstaff were attentive, friendly, and efficient. Charming little place with a steady flow of people. Nice atmosphere and a wonderful dining experience!“

“Been going here since I was a baby. Simple, reliable, and satisfying 🍕“

“Went to sals for lunch got the pizza salad and spaghetti and it was amazing Maria and her staff are great customer service is amazing also“

“love their pizza family specials. it's our go to every friday night :)“

“This restaurant has a great breakfast but what makes it great is Kim she goes above & beyond with the customers. You can have good food but the people make the place.“

“Very first time ever at one excellent experience“

“Eating at a Vinny’s is like eating with family. Always delicious! Always fast! Always a friendly wait staff! Always so clean! Just like eating with family. We love Vinny’s!“

“Tonight all our food was on point! Pan pizza, pasta, sandwiches, parm bites, lava cakes. Thanks for the hot n fresh food along with fast n friendly service Keith and Dominos Team“

“Best chicken parm I have ever had in my life. I asked for vodka sauce, and it was rich, creamy, and very pretty.

Apparently even the bread they make in house. Our waitress was a sister of the chef--it was a real family business. She knew everything. Would recommend“

“great food, fair prices, and quick service“

“it was not good at all. it was hard and cold. It tasted like old food. it is too expensive for the food to be like that.“

“This is the best pizza in the area, which is really saying something considering it’s a chain. They almost always have perfectly made pizzas that taste delicious. They’re also always welcoming and quick when you go to pick up the pizza.“

“One of our favorite things about the Hayes Pizza Hut is our delivery driver, Bobby. He is great! Always gets our order to us piping hot and always has a smile and a great attitude! These days, good customer service is a rarity so we are very thankful when he brings our order. We had another delivery driver once and by the time I got done discussing which order was mine and why the food was cold. Keep up the great job, Bobby! see you again soon!“

“Papa John's is my favorite fast pizza. I no longer live within 1 hrs of one, and definitely not within delivery distance. Thus particular one was cleaner than most, on my way elsewhere, and an apt reproduction of the company product. 100% of what you desire from chain pizza.“

“Felt like I was visiting “the good ole days” where people are friendly and serve great food. Unlike the chain restaurants of today. So refreshing!“

“Excellent Subs and service! 😎👍👍“

“Tonight all our food was on point! Pan pizza, pasta, sandwiches, parm bites, lava cakes. Thanks for the hot n fresh food along with fast n friendly service Keith and Dominos Team“

“I am loving their salads and gluten free pizzas.Unlike many others, their gluten free pizzas are an indulgence, which is exactly why I eat pizza. Delicious.

Dietary restrictions: I cannot say enough positive things about that gluten-free pizza. No gluten, but plenty of spice, cheese, meat, vegetables, mushrooms and a heaping helping of joy. It's what's been missing from my sad, bland, gluten-free life!“

“We do delivery only. The food never disappoints, but the drivers never pay attention to the instructions in the app. We ask them to leave the food at our door, and they always stand there until we answer. That will always be my only complaint. Everything else is good.“

“I would've given 5 stars, but 4 is more reasonable. Came in to get food for pickup. When we pull up, lobby is BARE! 1 folding chair and that's it. We ordered our food, lady was nice about it. Food is reasonably priced. Fiance ordered a pizza with ham, black olive, pepperoni. Instead of black olive, he got mushroom. He called the restaurant to fix it. Since it was a pickup, they wanted us to come back to pick it up. Mind you, we live about 6 miles away. So instead, we got a $15 store credit. We will come back as it is good. Check your food before leaving though“

“Best S'barro slice I've had in a good long while. I've stopped going to S'barro because of the disappointing slices but went back for one and it was great. The ziti was still sad, but you can't have everything.

They use a heating oven, that's good.

Go to this one, you want to.“

“Wonderful staff always friendly. Their services bar none the best!“

“best place in town love the food drinks an the staff“

“awsome place to eat staff is friendly and efficient“

“We were very impressed with the customer service tonight and how friendly Keith (general manager) and the rest of the staff were!! We will be going back! Thanks for the laughs and showing our boys that there are still nice people!“

“I love the pizza. We always order a specialty pizza. At first i would always receive my order as requested, however the last few months they have been ignoring the garlic and romasean crust ON ALL MY ORDERS. When we ask them about it, the attitude and the lack of responsibility in wanting to correct the issue is too much.“

“Needed pizza to feed volunteers for a food drive and John, the manager of this location, was super helpful, even giving us a better deal than what we found online. John had our large order hot, fresh, and ready on time for us. Our hungry volunteers really enjoyed the well made pizza.This is what great customer service feels like and this will make us repeat customers to this location.“

“The employees are very friendly and I see them working hard to get the orders out quickly, I recommend using the app to just pick up the purchase. I would say that the business needs a little maintenance, there are already some things that are deteriorated and for a franchise as big as Litter Caesars.“