Browse menus, reviews and photos of Custom Cakes near Issaquah.
Ice Cream Shop · $$
1011 Northeast High Street Suite 103, Issaquah
Customers’ favorites
“Very overpriced, but also great staff and product. Support these guys instead of getting Hagan Diaz from Safeway across the street! Manager told me prices will come down now that inflation has come down. Love the Milskyshakes!”
Ice Cream Shop · $$
6100 East Lake Sammamish Parkway Southeast Ste C, Issaquah
Customers’ favorites
“Ah, Cold Stone Creamery! I don’t know what kind of wizardry they’re doing back there, but Cold Stone ice cream is so creamy. Like, suspiciously creamy. I don’t know how they do it. I assume there’s a guy in the back with a PhD in dairy science just whispering affirmations to the cream. Whatever it is, they’ve earned the “Creamery” in their name. That’s not just branding. That’s a diploma. Now, the mix-ins get all the press. People love the mix-ins. But I’m here for the base. The foundation. The creamy core. It’s like building a house on a cloud. This Issaquah location? It’s run entirely by Skyline High School students. I don’t think any of them need to work. They’re just doing it for the love of the game. Like, “Hey, I could be at home playing Fortnite, but I’d rather be here, folding gummy bears into mint chip for a guy who looks like he just woke up from a nap in 1997.” That’s me. I’m that guy. It’s a teen hangout, but they serve old people like me too. We walked in at 9:50 on a Friday night, ten minutes before closing, and they didn’t even flinch. Just smiled, scooped, and let us loiter like we were paying rent. That’s hospitality. That’s Cold Stone. There’s a fine line between laziness and genius, and these teens are skating it like pros. Instead of lugging heavy trash bags to the dumpster, one of them just casually rolled over to Fred Meyer, commandeered a shopping cart, and turned it into a mobile waste unit. Is it creative? Absolutely. Is it lazy? Maybe. But it’s also efficient, ergonomic, and kind of brilliant. That’s teenage ingenuity: solving problems with the least amount of effort and the maximum amount of swagger. I always order something off the menu and then change it so much it becomes a new invention. Like, “I’ll have the Chocolate Devotion, but can you take out the brownies, add marshmallows, swap half the chocolate ice cream for mint, and also make it taste like regret and childhood?” And they just nod. No judgment. No questions. Just vibes. My wife noticed I had more ice cream than she did, even though we ordered the same size. The server, Ayush, overheard and immediately offered to top hers off. That’s five-star service. That’s Cold Stone diplomacy. They’ve got the classics like chocolate, vanilla, and mint, but then they hit you with flavors like “Honey Cornbread with Blackberry Jam.” It tasted like a scone that got tenure. And churro flavor? Sure. Why not. It’s November, so of course there’s pumpkin spice. It’s the law. Anyway, five stars. I’ll be back. Probably tonight. Probably at 9:50.”
Bakery · $$$$
23330 Maple Valley Black Diamond Rd SE B, Maple Valley · 9.59 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Best “Cake in a Jar” options ever!! Her buttercream frosting is to die for, highly recommend!”
Cupcakes · $$
4467 146th Avenue Southeast, Bellevue · 5.82 miles
“Most amazing artistry and delicious product. Michael was a joy to work with, and really made my daughters birthday.”
Patisserie/Cake Shop · $$$$
440 Olympia Avenue Northeast Suite B, Renton · 7.08 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Ordered a cake for my medical school graduation. The company was lovely to work with. They executed our vision exactly how we asked them and the cake is the best tasting cake we ever had!! All of our guests were blown away by the design and the taste of the cake! I would highly recommend them for any event!”
Ice Cream Shop · $
2255 140th Avenue Northeast, Bellevue · 8.96 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great store. Friend ordered custom cake online from other location (Issaquah) but the store unable to fulfill the order with less than 48 hours notice. I told her to try this location where I ordered custom cake before, and indeed, this store is able to make the custom cake for her.”
Ice Cream Shop · $$
15600 Northeast 8th Street Ste J2, Bellevue · 7.67 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Amazing service! There was such a long time and only one employee. There gentleman working was super fast but also had conversations with everyone so no one felt rushed. He deserves to be employee of the year with how he managed to be the only employee serving so many people and still managed to smile and make every customer smile!”
Bakery · $
16418 Northeast 74th Street, Redmond · 10.56 miles
“The server Justin was the best. He was extremely polite and made sure the food was given on time.”
Ice Cream Shop · $$
7345 164th Avenue Northeast Ste I123, Redmond · 10.55 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I noticed there are a lot of bad reviews about the customer service, so I think it may depend on the day you visit. I went on a Saturday, and there was a man and a young girl working. The customer service was great—I was immediately greeted and asked if I needed help when I was looking into the cake fridge. The ice cream cake is always so good. I got the 6” Oreo ice cream and it was delish!! Thank you again for the two working early Saturday! My boyfriend was really happy!”