Custom Cakes in Seattle, WA

“The team at Deep Sea Sugar & Salt went above and beyond for our wedding cakes, and they truly ended up being one of the highlights of our night. Not only did our guests rave about them, but even our vendors couldn’t stop talking about how delicious they were.

Kim, Kelly, Kinsley (and the rest of the incredible team) were so kind, thoughtful, and accommodating. Since we had to bring our cakes to the San Juan Islands, they partially froze them to ensure they traveled well and even arranged for an early pickup so we could make our ferry — that kind of attention to detail and care was so appreciated.

And the cakes themselves? Absolutely stunning and unbelievably good. The carrot pineapple cake was my personal favorite and ended up being a huge hit with our guests. Every flavor we chose was beautiful to look at and even better to eat.

We can’t thank Deep Sea Sugar & Salt enough for being such a special part of our wedding day. Their cakes made our night even more memorable. Don’t hesitate to book with them — and definitely put down that deposit early, you won’t regret it!“

“This store is a gem. I’ve been coming here for decades. The previous owner walked me through figuring out everything I needed to know to make a spectacular three tiered wedding cake (something I had never done before) and the new owner has kept up the excellent customer service with knowledgeable and friendly advice, and of course their superb collection of anything a home baker could possibly want.“

“Absolutely amazing cake pops and the sweetness girls make them! Highly recommend!“

“Zylberschtein's catered my son's bar mitzvah luncheon and did an amazing job! The food was delicious, there was PLENTY of it and the Zylberschtein's team did all of the set-up & clean up, making it effortless for me. Working with their team before & during the event was also very easy. Highly recommend them for your catering needs! 🙌✡️🥯🔯🫶“

“Baked designed the coolest cake for Schools for Salone (Sierra Leone). The cake was just like the Sierra Leonian flag! 🇸🇱 Thank you! You’ll have my business any time I need a special cake.“

“Best guava cake around, highly recommend. Can’t wait to have it for my birthday soon“

“Got a custom cake for a work party and it was a hit! Fluffy, light, delicious. Everyone raved about it. Great price, too.“

“Their food is great, and the workers are really friendly!“

“I ordered a heart shaped cake with vintage piping and it was perfect for my thirtieth birthday party! It was so pretty and everything I envisioned, and was delicious! Everyone loved it and it was the star of the show! I got funfetti with chocolate ganache.
When I ordered the cake I requested to pick up in Totem Lake, but there was a mixup and I had to go pickup in Seattle. No big deal, and I got a free slice of their eggnog cake for the inconvenience and it was also delicious! The girls working there were so nice and apologetic for the mixup. I will be ordering again for my next event!“

“I had a wedding cake made for my daughter and she had 3 flavors it was the best cake ever“

“It's small and pretty busy. There are a few tables and not much space to even get past other customers. The staff was helpful and friendly. Lots of menu choices including milkshakes and other drinks. The ice cream was delicious, we had lemonade dairy free ice cream, chocolate and mint chocolate chunk.“