23 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sumner

“Great milkshakes and flavor options! Fish and chips were very good, and the chicken strips were tasty (best part is they didn’t taste like the fish aka not same oil). Had better fries but honestly didn’t eat here for the fries lol, great summer experience for the kiddos.“

“I wanted a thank you gift and I stopped in and picked up a variety of mini cookies. They are regular cookie sizes and just the perfect thank you gift. I stopped by early morning so I had great service and was in and out. If you haven't tried the cookies maybe it's time!“

“This is a great place for sweets. You place your order through the kiosk and pay with a card.

There are usually a couple of employee who works there and they’re so busy - no one greets you.

Some of the cookies are pretty good and some are so-so. Lots of cream and sugar.“

“Lots of unique options of cookies. They have refrigerated options served cold as well as some served warm which makes the flavors so yummy. My favorite is the cornbread cookie that is served with syrup. So delicious.

Our location has curbside pick up that we love. Makes ordering so convenient. We order on the app and pick up at our pre selected time slot.

The parking lot is small but I have never struggled to find a spot. Most of the traffic is in and out.

The price point is correct for gourmet baked goods. They have a lot of size options for boxes so you can get just one or a larger box to serve more people. They are huge so we always share whatever we get. They have really cute cookie cutters now to cut into triangles and make them more shareable. Also available now is mini size cookies.

If you have not tried them out I would recommend them.

Dietary restrictions: They do not have gluten free options“

“Wonderful location, a lot of toppings and different syrups and stuff to add, service was okay, not overly friendly but okay according to WA state standards, not even one single flavor was sold out, which is rare, I appreciate how clean and organized this location is, highly recommend to stop by if you are craving something sweet.“

“It’s the real deal, old-school drive-in burgers that you’re craving. Everything is good here… EVERYTHING.“

“Just want to say a huge thank you to the evening team.

My son just got out of the emergency room on 02/11/25. He wanted to get Menchies so bad. I told him we might not make it because we had to wait for nurse to sign us out. We left at 8:55PM and came at 9:03PM to Menchies. The team was so accommodating, that they let us come in even after 9PM. My kids were able to get some ice cream and were so happy. Not only that, but my son was able to be so happy even though he had a broken arm and sling. Thank you for your gift as well team. Thank you so much for serving us and the Bonney Lake community. You really made our evening. We are thankful! God bless!“

“Menchie's Frozen yogurt is a great treat. I like that it has no preservatives and no additives. It has a great variety of flavors. I'm so glad I found a good frozen yogurt place. I also love the friendly staff.“

“Great coffee and the best service!“

“Tasty ice cream and good service. Beautiful ice creams and a very wide selection. There's something for everyone but it may be hard to choose just one! We had the Pistachio and it was delicious and best we've had in a long time. We will definitely be going back. ?“

“Yummy, awesome toppings 🤤“

“Awesome service and good blizzards“

“bubble tea was excellent, service was great and inside was a great photo opp!“

“best 🍔 burger I've had. my 1st time there. great friendly staff“

“All the of the ice cream flavors is really good also the employees are very friendly“

“I went there tonight with a friend and had a Reeses Blizzard. The manager was very friendly and respectful to me and he has a great team working for him. They are all are very hard workers and very friendly and Helpful . They all knew there job was and fast .You don’t have to wait very long for what ever you are waiting for. I would give them all five stars. Keep up the great work you all.“

“I love this Coldstone. It may not have the frills or modern flavor mashups of the modern ice cream shops (like salt & straw) but the classics are on point. Their mint sundae thing is the best. All served up with great customer service- the perfect stop after a dinner out or on your way to a fun evening somewhere.“

“I’ve been coming here for a few years now and recently I’ve been coming here almost everyday before work. I love their smoothies, build your own parfaits, and grabbing their immunity boosters for a quick pick me up :) definitely recommend 😋😋“

“Stopped by Baskin Robbins inside the Commons Mall in Federal Way. You don’t see many of these around anymore, so it was a nice little surprise. It’s located right in the mall, with ample parking and food court seating nearby. Restrooms are also accessible inside the mall. Service was good. It was nothing extraordinary, but smooth and without issues. I knew what I wanted, got it quickly, paid, and left. A simple, satisfying visit.

Efficient: Yes
First-Time Friendliness: Yes
Would I Return: Yes

JY review“

“everything is good. get yourself s bionico“

“Great burgers. Best burger I've ever had from a Dairy Queen. I typically don't like them from DQ but this one was very good. I think some things may have been changed besides it being very fresh.One of the only DQ's that still serve chocolate ice cream. (Be sure to keep cleaning the machines every night) The last couple of times I've questioned it.Overall, I must stop by every time I drive north from Puyallup. Thank you.. service is usually great too, more recently in the last 6 months.“

“My wife and I enjoyed a wonderfully prepared Dbl cheese burger, cheese burger and fries. For desert we enjoyed a large serving of mint chocolate chip ice cream. The staff were very engaging and the facility was spotless. I highly recommend you check out this drive in for yourself!“

“Top 3 Coldstone experiences of all time.

Went in for a Strawberry Blonde and got in line. Even though it was slammed the line was moving quickly. Jackson helped me with my order and with a fantastic attitude at that. Employees like him are the reason I will be back.

Not to mention his no look, behind the back receipt shot to top off the visit. Legendary.“