50 Best Italian Restaurants near Brookfield

“Stopped for a visit at this Carrabba’s location and was pleasantly surprised. Our server was phenomenal, quick, attentive and very friendly (she gets 5 stars). Food was good, not the best Italian I’ve ever had but very good and fresh. Decor at this location is modern and nice.
Would recommend!“

“Very good service from relatively young wait staff. This is encouraging. Atmosphere would have been better except the family next to us was louder than we usually prefer. But that is not the restaurants fault. Note to other patrons: if you're gonna talk loud enough for the entire dining room to hear, please be interesting.“

“Had a great dinner with friends. I’ve visited this restaurant multiple times and anything I’ve ordered from the menu from appetizers to drinks has exceeded my expectations. The red pepper soup is a must try! Service was a little slow, but we were there to enjoy our time and company so I was glad for it. They were very busy and the staff were fantastic. If you are looking for an enjoyable evening with fantastic food give this place a try!“

“Service is amazing, pizza outstanding and I have been searching for a place that actually knows how to make not a decent meatball but an AWESOME meatball ♥️♥️♥️“

“Marty's pizza is such a local gem. I have been eating and loving this pizza since I was a kid, an unmentionable amount of years ago. Last night they helped me throw a 50th birthday party for my boyfriend. Provided a great space (in the restaurant, not a banquet room as they do not have one). However it was perfect. The staff was so helpful and sweet to us. The bill for about 25 people that included plenty of pizza, salad, garlic bread, soda, and beer was alot cheaper then I expected. Also, their food is amazing. Please check out this local legend.“

“my husband and I went there tonight for his birthday. the food was really good but I want to brag about Robert our server. He is the best server I have experienced in a long time. we never once had to flag him down to refill our soda. If we blinked we would miss him putting a fresh basket of bread out for us. Our empty plates never sat on our table for long before Robert walked by and swooped them up. kudos to Bravo! for hiring Robert. I would definitely come back if I was guaranteed him as my server. Robert thanks you so much for the excellent service you provided, and I hope we left you a great tip, you truly deserve it“

“Ordered catering dishes and pizzas. I worked with the owner to order and everything was so phenomenal. The penne pasta delicious. Breadsticks are outstanding. Baked chicken was some of the best. Perfectly seasoned. And of course pizzas are always awesome. My gusts couldn’t stop telling me how good everything was.
Thank you!!“

“Fried zucchini and steaks are very good so is the spaghetti very friendly people“

“I forgot to tell you, they change their menu once a month - but if you like something you might still find it later on - but this is a great idea since it's a local favorite foodie place so customers nearby that frequent don't have all the same food choices!!!! Loved everything about this cute, quaint, delicious spot.“

“everyone there is always very friendly. we love eating there“

“Cannot say enough about the food, the staff and the ambiance. Whether it is pregame, post-game, special night out, day drinking and dining or late night cocktails and dinner after a late flight this place never, ever disappoints. Its been that way for years and hope it never changes.“

“Wonderful bartender, drinks were on point. Great waitress, attentive and helpful. Food was excellent! Highly recommend.“

“Staff was very attentive. Food was fantastic. My only complaint is the price, but you certainly get plenty of food for what you pay.“

“Mama Mia's is Back! I was a loyal and frequent diner for decades. I just had to have the signature garlic bread and delicious delicate crisp crust pizza, but the original Mama Mia family sold the business several years ago, and the food and service went into steady decline. It seems like the recipes were the same, but the execution was lacking. The bread was oftern served re-heated or stale tasting and the pizza was seldom done right. I don't know who is running the business now, but we gave it a try and ordered carry-out. The meal was fabulous! I hope they keep it going.“

“Worked at Armelis many many years ago. Had a craving for it tonight and it’s exactly how I remember it from 15+ years ago! My husband had it for the first time and said “WHY HAVENT WE ORDERED FROM HERE BEFORE?!” So we will definitely be ordering again!“

“Classic Italian done right!“

“Food was phenomenal!! The atmosphere is lacking. A day of touching up paint, stain, chair nicks and deep cleaning would go a long way for minimal cost and effort. You would have thought it would have been done during the COVID-19 shutdown.“

“Fantastic food and great service. Brenda is the best!“

“Went here for the 1st time tonight and is was beyond wonderful. Service was fantastic and the food was soooo good. Can not wait to eat here again ❤️“

“I love the pizza but it seems like the sauce was different. did they change the sauce?“

“Amazing food! The portions are huge and we always leave with leftovers.“

“This is our favorite Fish Fry in the area! (And we've tried a lot of fish fry's :) The Pizza is also really good! We love their thin, crispy, crust! The wait staff has always been friendly and hard working. It's hard to beat Pepino's.“

“Nadi plates is incredible!! Nadia, Zachary and their team did a fantastic job with our wedding at Mercantile Hall. We had 116 guests and everything was cooked perfectly! Our guests were raving about how good the food was. We had filets and steak for our entree. They are a family run business and are so passionate about what they do. We could not have picked a more perfect caterer to do our wedding. I highly recommend them!! Thank you so much for everything!!

-Cayla & Brian

*photos from Corrina Nicole Photography“

“This is such a cute hole in the wall!! The workers here are all awesome and nice. We got the whole place to ourselves and the kids enjoyed every second. This is all of these picky eaters new favorite pizza…… that says all ya need to know! THANK YOU GROTTOOO!!!“

“We eat there a lot as a family. Sometimes service is great, sometimes it can be really bad. During the week it tends to provide a better experience, especially on regard to waiting. Great place, amazing food, but wait time of at least 30-60 minutes on weekends. The food though, is so delicious that you overcome the waiting and sometimes the not so great service as well.“

“Best around baked mostacolli“

“I love OG. I eat at all the locations. I enjoy each of them but my last visit to Menomonee Fall location left me with my very own waiter story like the one told in the book QBQ!.
Charles seved my family and I on last thursday for a birthday lunch. He was charismatic, kind, and most of all attentive. Charles is also an active listener who took information from each person at the table and used it to exceed our individual expectations. Even solutions I didnt know he could solve. I am still pleased thinking about this experience a week later, so it is my duty to say once again Thank you Charles, you made us feel like family. Cheers.

Dietary restrictions: Has a delicious salmon and broccoli dish if you are low carb or on a ketogenic diet. I had my reservations before going because you know restaurant full of pasta dishes right! They have something for everyone.“

“Stoped here on a Sunday night after golfing at Currie. We ordered a drink or two at the Cub Tap. Even though Lalli's was closing.. they happily took our order and cooked us two delicious pizzas to go. HIghly recommended they were very good.“

“My family and I have been enjoying leah’s for decades. I love the garlic bread. It’s thick and dense bread loaded with butter! The pizza is great too. I was there on sunday august 4th and our server was attentive and pleasant. I’m shocked about all the bad reviews because I have never had a bad experience there. I can’t think of pizza in the suburbs that I like more than this.“

“I've been dining here for over 30 years. I recommend 🤔everything 🥰 every single time has been pure epicurean bliss.. Bon Appetite to 🫵and thanks again 🥰“

“my children took y wife Lori and me for our 40th anniversary, The food was excellent. WE THOROJGHLY ENJOYED OURSELVES AND THE FOOD AND SERVICE WERE EXCELLENT. THANKS MIAS!!!“

“Parking: We were here for a funeral repass. The staff was so helpful, kind, caring & attentive that it made the whole day a "celebration of life!" The one who wasbeing remembered would have loved it! The drinks were strong, food was delicious & the service amazing! We are so glad you are a
still in business!

Kid-friendliness: Decorations were entertaining!“

“I absolutely love Ann’s! Pizza, fettuccine, lasagna are all delicious. Last night I had Ann’s penne with chicken and it’s my new favorite! Our waiter, Logan, was amazing also! Definitely a must check out!“

“This is our favorite pizza in Milwaukee. The crust is great and they don't skimp on toppings. Lots of cheese too!“

“Even though the Pewaukee location is closer to my house, I order from the Menomonee Falls restaurant because the food and service I much much beter.“

“Nice little spot with good service and great food!“

“First time here. There will definitely be a second, third, fourth and so on!“

“great customer service and the food was amazing“

“Most awesome pizza ever they have the best Italian sausage on the pizza. The cheesy bread is also great. Their wings are good. Their pepperoni pizza is awesome. Customer service and staff are really really nice. No complaints at all if you have trouble getting through there a small place for pick up and delivery in carry out so just keep trying they’re worth every second..“

“We have never had a disappointment at ZA. Everything we have tried is delicious. Today we enjoyed a brussel sprouts appetizer topped with hot honey glaze and goat cheese, beet salad, lemony chicken picatta and tiramisu. Delizioso!

Dietary restrictions: ZA offers gluten free pasta.“

“We got our 1st pizza from Cataro’s Pizza last night at 11:15pm after seeing the band Without Annette at Da Bar nearby. We were hungry so we searched pizza open late near me. That’s how we found this amazing pizza. The owner had closed the dining room early because business has been so slow but he offered to make us one to go. It was so good! I highly recommend this place. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Fantastic pizza - always - hot, delicious, done the way you like it - near the 'hood' and on-time - small place - but thin crust is on FIRE!!!!!! Awesome - recommended highly by those that tried it - many times.“

“Excellent products, excellent service and great atmosphere!!!“

“Chris the bartender is awesome and food was great!“

“Always great service and pizza!! Dough nuggets I had last time were amazing too! We tried the pasta tonight and it was delicious but a little disappointed with only half an Italian sausage link being an order size for $2. The noodle to meat ratio is definitely off so make sure you order double meat if ordering create your own pasta. Very tasty though!! My boyfriend had the lasagna and said he would definitely order again. Hands down best pizza in the area that we’ve found. 😊“

“We had a large order for a wedding rehearsal dinner. The staff were a pleasure to work with. I did a pre order for 18 pizzas and 3 lbs of boneless wings a week in advance. I had to change pick up time and there was no problem. The staff was happy to accommodate. The order was just being finished at our pick up time. Everything was hot and delicious! I highly recommend!“

“A friend and I ate here a couple afternoons ago and wow was it to die for. Ever since new management took this place it has been spot on. One of the best Stromboli’s I have ever tried. The staff was also super friendly. I would for sure recommend this place to anyone.“

“Usually order for delivery, but finally came to see the inside. It is so cute! I love this place and their pizza!“

“Chicago Native, so believe me when I say these guys are the best. I moved up to the Waukesha area in Summer 2022. I was craving a Large Sausage pizza late close to their closing time, ended up going with a Supreme type pizza. They were quick, and even stayed slightly past closing so I could pick up my order. Tipped generously simply for that courtesy and professionalism. Will be my STAPLE pizza place in the area from now on. A Go-To spot.“