50 Best American Restaurants near Colgate

“Always a good time at Joe Mama’s. Great service good environment“

“Just wow. came in sat at the far right side of the bar. Not busy but steady. Sat waiting for 8 to 10 minutes for a bartender. Obviously she was too engrossed in a regulars conversation. got up and left. Did we miss something? Certainly not service. The Phoenix across the street definitely wins. Pretty sad that you can't even get acknowledged. She was on the chunky side. Tan shorts and T. There's plenty of local places to go.“

“Everything here is always so good.

Chicken pot pie: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Veal meatballs: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ These are some of the best meatballs I've ever had

Shortrib tacos: ⭐⭐ These were fine I guess, but the meat was flavorless and the sauce was light on flavor or heat. The excess of pickled onions couldn't even overcome the lack of flavor. I just mixed the meat in with the meatballs

Bacon hot honey bread: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Drinks: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“My first experience here was great, the bartenders were friendly and fun, the food was cooked perfect and tasted just as good as it looked (I forgot to take pics and just dug right in) will definitely be back!!“

“Had our team dinner here for 17 people on 8/28/25. Per my request they seated us in the back so we'd have a little privacy.
Everyone said the food, drinks and deserts were fantastic. Special shout out to Shannon M. for the great service.“

“Word can’t describe what amazing place this is, from menu, to food, to employment, to ownership to all should get a 5 star plus. The minute you walk through to door you feel so welcome. I was there with a group of 8 and everyone had nothing but amazing things to say. Keep being amazing!“

“Awsume smoked BBQ on menu !! Huge beer selection plenty of parking room Great music and entertainment outside“

“Went there for my birthday this week. Service was amazing, drinks very good and food was the best! Will definitely be going back! 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟“

“Enjoy your German entree’s. Would also love to see a vegetarian entree option(s). We and others would be dining there much more often.“

“We sat on the deck and had about a dozen of us. Unfortunately I don’t remember our servers name, but she was wonderful! We came to Uncle Larry’s bc a few people in our party had NEVER had FRIED CHEESE CURDS! They were great!! We all just came from a 1950’s Sock Hop, cousins from Denver, California, Minnesota,Arizona and New York! Couldn’t have been better.
We sat out on the deck. Weather was with us and we were out before they closed! Looking to go back next time we are in town.“

“I live on the far south east corner of Milwaukee County, and I am always on the lookout for a great burger. I was fortunate enough to stumble upon Sweet Dreams in Hartford, I have made the drive five times since finding this hamburger stand earlier in the summer, the burgers are that good. And the best news, last time we were there we were told they are planing on being open this winter. If you’re looking for a great burger, amazing fall colors a great staff to take your order. I can’t recommend Sweet Dreams enough.“

“Wonderful atmosphere and delicious food. The wait staff was very friendly and accommodating. We will definitely be coming back and it was great place to take our grown daughter for her birthday.“

“Hot House is truly in a league of its own. From the moment you walk in, it’s clear that this place isn’t just about the food or the ambiance—it’s about an experience that’s truly elevated by their exceptional hospitality. The staff goes above and beyond in every possible way. I was blown away by how accommodating they were, anticipating my needs before I even had to ask. It’s rare to find a team so in sync, and it speaks volumes about the strong culture they’ve cultivated here. Every interaction, no matter how small, was met with genuine warmth and attentiveness. They’re not just serving customers; they’re creating lasting, meaningful connections. It’s refreshing to see a business so tuned in to the needs of its guests. Clearly, Hot House knows the importance of putting people first, and it shows in every detail. The standard they set for hospitality should be the benchmark for the industry. An absolute must-visit!“

“We wanted to find a new place to try while here for a conference and we are so happy that we came here. I got the chicken littles as an appetizer and my husband got soup and immediately we were impressed. Followed up by steak for him and a Parmesan crusted grilled cheese for me kept the amazing food going. Then the desserts brought us over the finish line to an amazing meal. Everyone was so kind and helpful and we will definitely come back.“

“The crispiest golden brown hashbrowns and perfectly browned corned beef hash! Giant servings! Great value for the corned beef hash, scrambled eggs, sourdough toast, and hashbrowns-my all time fav!!!:)“

“We had a great time tonight. The food was excellent and the service was awesome. Ladies night was a huge success.“

“Sawmill is one of my all time favorite places to come after church. The food is always amazing, the holiday decor is wonderful and is always a great experience, until today... Unfortunately, the waitress "T" was absolutely awful, she was rude and should really find a new profession not dealing with people. I would hope it was just a bad day for her, but she ruined our experience. We have never left a $0 tip and that should tell management that she needs a chat. Still great food and atmosphere. We'll be back, but will not ever have her again! God Bless Oh and a different waitress had a packer shirt that says "I love it when he goes deep". I'm not a prude, but seriously so inappropriate for a restaurant to allow that!“

“Tried the BLVD Royale Burger, and it was perfect! Juicy, flavorful patty cooked just right, with a soft yet sturdy bun. The frizzled onions added a great crunch, and everything was well-balanced. Had some Micheladas, and they were spot on. Great service, perfect food temperature—definitely coming back!“

“Jackson Culver’s is simply the best! ❤️ Even though we no longer live in Jackson, we still go to this location whenever we have a Culver’s craving! It’s the cleanest + most friendly location we’ve been to. We are regulars at this location and have gotten to know everyone there over the years and just simply love it!😍“

“Everything was fantastic! The food was excellent, and the service was fast and very friendly. We got our meal remarkably fast considering how busy the restaurant was. The view of the lake made our meal even more enjoyable. I would recommend the Copper Dock to anyone looking for a nice dining experience.“

“Machine Shed is a nice place to go with friends. The noise level is just right. The staff is friendly, and doesn't hurry us. My chicken salad was too creamy and very hard to eat. Our waitress never came back to refill our water pitcher or beverages.“

“A warm ,relaxing atmosphere with outstanding service! I had the prime rib and my wife had the chicken Madeira, both excellent 5 stars !“

“I bought a gift card and didn't get the value basket coupon. I reached out to Culver's and received a phone call from the manager. I went to Culver's and Jakob, at the register was very nice and helpful. The customer service was awesome!!!“

“The Gyro, steak Gyro , spinach pie, pork as well. The food here is beyond amazing. There is no Gyro place I know that compares. Our son told us that the fish fry is fantastic as well. The owner handles this business in a way that you can see clearly they care. Great quality. We took some food to the hospital for my mom as well.“

“I would like to give appreciation to the staff working at the Sussex location at 1pm today. I come to this location pretty often, maybe a bit too much lol and they always get everything 100% correct and have fantastic service. Today they went above and beyond. I usually order my drink with no ice and today I forgot to ask and they did it. I’m not sure if this was even intentional or not, but love them for that. If there’s any type of reward or something that even I can do to show my appreciation I would love to know! Thanks so much as always!!!!!“

“love Sluggo's always our go to spot when we can go out!“

“The best service you could ask for., delicious food and great drinks.“

“Malita is a fantastic server! She’s so friendly, quick, and efficient! She didn’t ever allow our coffee to run low or get cold. It’s amazing to see people stay employed at the same place for a longer time, it speaks volumes to the quality of the restaurant and staff.“

“Our very favorite place for breakfast. Food is always fast, good, hot, a quantity that’s filling, and at a more than fair price. The owner is the cook, the help he hires is attentive & friendly. The place holds 40 people max and still (as a rule) provides the same excellence. You won’t be disappointed.“

“Drove miles to get to this location. Get it right everytime!!!! I have been to other George Webb,but the burgers,buns are horrible...Even after the bar they suck...I can't explain why but this web's gets it!!!!! Staff is a 15 on a 1 to 10 scale....I will continue to drive 45 minutes to get THE PERFECT GEORGE WEBB experience and burger Absolutely great sevice“

“Food and custard are ALWAYS ALWAYS GREAT! And they employ my favorite guy! 😃“

“Such a cozy restaurant, so inviting! Food was to die for and the coffee couldn't have been fresher. The menu is creative and thoughtful, there's definitely something for everyone. And the service was just stellar--staff was kind and attentive and the owner makes everyone feel like old friends.“

“Unexpectedly great.
Picked the plane randomly when deciding where we wanted to go for a Friday fish fry that we hadn't tried before and ended up here in the basement of an American legion.
The drinks were strong, the food was ready very fast and very good, like surprisingly good! The server was on point. It is in a bar so keep that in mind.“

“Broasted Chicken is 11/10. Fish fry is 10/10. Atmosphere is a throwback. Remember to bring cash, and you won’t be disappointed.“

“The food is fantastic, excellent service, and a super bartender. What more could you want....“

“A bowling alley with a sizable bar area and decent bar food. Service can be slow at times however the bar tenders are friendly. Karaoke on Friday nights pulls in a crowd, and is entertaining most times. There is a enclosed outdoor smoking lounge area that has heat and seating which is a nice feature if you are a smoker. Overall a comfortable place to relax and have a few drinks.“

“The food was awesome great atmosphere!! Was happy we found it after turning down 3 others places to eat!! Would visit again if we come threw that town again!!“

“Would like to see breakfast served all day! The food was good.“

“Food was fantastic!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“Great food and excellent service. Nice atmosphere too. Highly recommend and will definitely be back!“

“I have a love of trying new small mom and pop style restaurants. O'Sullivan's was today Lunch Date choice with my mommio.
I highly recommend O'Sullivan's especially on a Friday lunch. The atmosphere is quiet and spacious without the feel of hustle and bustle.
Although I was incredibly tempted by their larger selection of Friday Fish Fry, I decided to go with the Reuben. It is an Irish establishment, so it felt just right.
Not only was the sandwich great, but it's sheer size was impressive.
Also, do not pass a chance to have a bowl of The Chicken Enchalada Soup (trust me, a cup will not be big enough. It was that good.)“

“Food is always plentiful and tasty. Service is fast and friendly.“

“Amazing lunch & it’s my sons favorite place in pewaukee - he lives 5 minutes away ❤️“

“The chicken dinner was definitely a winner. Waitress was on point. It was our first visit, will definitely return!“

“Stopped in for lunch and was glad I did. Friendly service from the jump—felt like a place where everyone knows each other, but newcomers are still welcome. Locals at the bar, couple of regulars playing games in the corner, and the staff chatting like it’s just another day in paradise.

It’s not quite a dive bar, but has that same laid-back, no-BS charm. Heard good things about the steak sandwich—can confirm it lives up to the hype. Solid lunch spot with a comfortable vibe, decent menu, and just enough grit to keep it real.“

“I went there with my boyfriend for a date night on Friday and everything was amazing from the service to the food.. we will definitely be coming back!“

“Great and friendly staff. We enjoyed our time there very much“

“I love buzdums they have the best food and bartenders anywhere.......“

“Food is very good. Great fish fry’s and pizza. Amazing wings. Fun bartenders too“

“Great atmosphere, great food (ALL THE PASTAS, Yes Please!!), and great people (especially the staff!!)!! Only go here if you want to have great time!! And by the way the short bartender is amazing!! 🤩“