Throwback Supper Club
CLOSED$$ •
91 S, 91 Lincoln St, Elkhart Lake
Throwback Supper Club Reviews
Cozy little Supper Club! The muddled old fashioneds were really well done. We had a party of 4 and all of our entrees were delicious. Service was great. This place is intimate, quaint and a little quirky. We ate here before going to a show at the Ostoff. Would definitely go back!
Wow! Excellent food and drinks. The chicken Marsala was absolutely delicious. They make all the noodles fresh to order, excellent noodles. Husband had chicken piccata, also delicious. It is a bit pricey, but it’s so worth it. I cannot wait to go back to try other meals.
Phenomenal food! Everything was great but the pork schnitzel was to die for, and I don't even like pork! I wish I would've ordered it instead of stealing bites off my mom's plate ? Homemade cake for dessert and it tasted better than my favorite bakery.