50 Best Bakeries near Fitchburg

“Rolling Pin did an absolutely amazing job for my daughter’s Golden Birthday. While ordering the cake, I spoke with Faith, who would be making the cake and I gave her very limited wants/needs for the design and basically said “all I want, is for my daughter to see the cake and be shocked”. I was completely blown away when I picked the cake up and when my daughter saw it, she couldn’t believe how absolutely amazingly beautiful it was. A+++ for Rolling Pin and the entire staff that I interacted with, oh and the cake itself, delicious.“

“That was the most luxurious semi-sweet pastry I have had in a very long time. It was very reasonably priced, and I had a wonderful experience:

1. Use the tongs
2. Put it on the tray
3. Walk to the front counter“

“Finally stopped in after watching people rave about them online for almost a year. I ordered a chocolate orange croissant thing and let me tell you when I say that thing blew my mind like wow. I knew it was good from people raving about it but I was so impressed dropped the last bite on the floor and about died I was so sad 😅 the lovely lady also gave me a free shortie I was eyein up 10/10 recommend so good I will be back“

“It was my first time stopping by this Crumbl shop, and everything was so delicious. The display looked incredibly clean and beautiful — I’ve never seen such a stunning presentation anywhere else. Even the cookie cut was just wow! The entire staff was very polite, and everything was spotless. Just wow. I already know I’ll be coming back again and again🤤.“

“I eat keto when possible, and Paleo Mama Bakery has amazing keto-friendly goods. They are as beautiful as baked goods from traditional bakeries, and they taste delicious! A lot of the time, I find keto-friendly frosted goods to be really heavy, but these are not as heavy as others I've tried. I've even gone out of my way to get a birthday cake from here (I live almost 150 miles away) because they are perfect for special occasions when people are eating low-carb/keto. I've attached a photo of a slice of the keto carrot cake, which was delicious!“

“We were looking for Brownies for our wedding dessert and thank goodness we found The Baled Lab. They were wonderful and so easy to work with! The brownies… to die for!!! It was so hard narrowing down which ones to choose for the wedding. We also got a small Salted Carmel cake which was delicious and exactly what we wanted. We can’t wait to find another reason to work with them and get more delicious desserts.“

“Our company brought a variety of cupcakes in for our annual awards ceremony and they were fabulous! Highly recommend these delicious treats 🧁“

“Our Christmas variety cookies just arrived today from Yummee Treats! The dough was so rich and dense, and the fillings, chocolate, smores, oatmeal, and pecan were soooo good! They ship internationally to your doorsteps within a day or two! 😋“

“We were on vacation and we were not leaving Wisconsin without mapping and getting to Stella’s! Seriously the best breads and pastries we have ever had… The cheese bread is the absolute best!!! The customer service was exceptional and very helpful! Now we just need to get one in Indiana!“

“This cafe has many delicious options for food. It however does not have celiac safe options. The cross contamination is too high. They do note this if you call them by stating that they can't guarantee there isn't. But I would not eat here if you have celiacs because I did twice and it made me incredibly sick. Again the food in my opinion is delicious, it just isn't celiacs safe.“

“Great neighborhood spot! The breakfast sandwiches and baked goods are DELICIOUS! The staff is beyond friendly and so pleasant to chat with. Quickly becoming one of my favorite Madison morning spots <3“

“I love El Hornito. I love all flavors of the Mexican tacos they offer. Me encanta el hornito. Me encantan igualmente todos los sabores de tacos mexicanos que ofrecen.“

“We had Greenbush Bakery Doughnuts for dessert at our wedding and they were such a hit! 10/10 recommend. Amazing service, delicious & beautiful doughnuts! Such a fun treat that everyone raved about!“

“Craig's is amazing! From birthdays to weddings they can make it happen! As a father and a weddding planner I cannot reccomend them enough!“

“Fresh, delicious and new to me flavors. Thank you for opening my world to your baked goods!“

“The pinnacle of Sourdough baking that I have found in the Midwest. Amazing! Great Job!“

“Best Bread 🍞 🥖 in Midwest imo. Check website for latest updates on pastry options and menu changes. Seasonal Galettes are my usual go-to’s. Big fan of the local hot sauce options (Fatalii Attraction 🔥) to dose my eggs. So many layers of cake temptations in front case..Good luck saying no.“

“What a wonderful Dane County organization.“

“So good!! we got two things from them at the farmers market. my girls loved the treats!!“

“They really outdid themselves, cake looks way better than the inspiration picture I sent them! Gorgeous work! Will always be back for any sweet needs from now on.“

“I came back to town and visited two days in a row. I’d forgotten how much I love this place!“

“Melissa made all of the desserts for my wedding on 5/21/22 and they were all AMAZING. I was actually a bit disappointed that there were no leftovers! I have Celiacs disease, and Melissa was even able to make everything gluten free - cake, cake pops, Oreo balls, and pie bars...wow! The dessert displays and the cake decorations were also beautiful. We got so many compliments on the desserts, and Melissa was so easy to work with. Thank you, Melissa!“

“Quick and fast service definitely recommended“

“Friendly staff and beautiful atmosphere“

“All of the mochi donuts always test very good. However sometimes they aren’t fresh and can go stale fast. But if you go during the day there is no problems !! Definitely recommend“

“When I was a four year old wee little sprout I learned if I didn’t like something I just didn’t go back. Instead of childishly trying to ruin their business online. Miggy’s is a hard working and professional business that makes delightful desserts! It pleases me to see a business willing to stand up to bullying :)“

“We came across your bread at a local thrift shop they had fresh bread they brought in from your bakery it it's absolutely fantastic. We frequent Wisconsin often and will be in to see the bakery itself. 10 out of 10“

“Decided to try today with the kiddo. We walked in and were immediately greeted. We placed our order...16 oz. Oreo Cold Brew & 16 Oz. Chocolate Covered Strawberry. While the drinks were being made we walked around and checked out the decor inside. It was decorated cozy and the atmosphere was cozy and very welcoming. We got our drinks and they tasted exactly like flavors ordered and not watered down like other coffee shops. Definitely will be back. 10/10“

“Great coffee shop with a lot of character.“

“Hi Bill. I was just talking about a million years ago on our blind date. I never was on a blind date before. U have to admit it was a super innocent funny story. Hope your life is great. I remember at the beginning of our date thinking we were meant to be siblings who would fight all the time lol. Never had a brother. That's a compliment. Lol?“

“We stopped in before a concert and was greeted by a friendly staff member. Went in for a water came out with donuts and a fritter. The donuts and fritter were fresh and delicious. We stopped after the concert to take some home. The staff were amazing, friendly and selection was great even though it was late. Best donuts we’ve.had in a long time. Thanks for the great service🍩“

“One of my favorite foods is pastys, I was excited to learn about this place, otherwise you would find them normal in the u.p area of Wisconsin. All of the varieties are great! Had the chicken tikka masala one today, was awesome! I do like they wrap it in foil, because my 40min drive home it's still warm!“

“I want to give a shout-out to Monona Bakery & Eatery 😄 I've ordered their food a lot via delivery apps, but never went inside. My friend Robin & I stopped in on Saturday! I've been on crutches 6 weeks, and they were VERY accommodating 😊 All the staff were amazing, and their food is SO good 🤤 I highly recommended checking them out! As someone who bakes quite a bit, I must say their bakery is 🤌😍👌“

“Good Auntie Annes
Friendly employees
Good pretzels
I also noticed that this auntie Anne’s sells pretzels about $1 cheaper then Auntie Anne locations inside malls
The seating area here is small but it’s clean.
Conveniently located on state street,near UW
Madison and near downtown Madison.
Heads up no Public restroom available here.“

“Great ambiance, and delicious pastries! If you aren’t a coffee person, like me, Alice has a variety of teas for us tea lovers. The staff is very kind. I also love to support local businesses! Give Alice Good Coffee a try! You won’t want to leave ☺️“

“beautiful location, great service and wonderfully cozy atmosphere!“

“Miss Cafe Domestique so much 😭“

“Probably the best beer I’ve ever tasted!, the puff pastry sour was so good and the mango ipa aswell. This spot alone makes me want to come back to wisco every time. Food is great, atmosphere off the charts, I want to take this place home with me🫡“

“Pan & Pan Bakery is an amazing Mexican bakery! Their cakes and desserts are always fresh, delicious, and beautifully made. The staff are super friendly, and the place has such a warm vibe. Highly recommend for anyone who loves great pastries or needs a cake for a celebration“

“We love getting food here. We have never had a disappointing dish. Every item is thoughtfully made and delicious. My kids are big fans of the seasonal pancakes.“

“We LOVE this restaurant. We make sure we stop every time we are in the area. We especially love the cinnamon roll pancakes, the homemade toast, and the hashbrowns--delicious! The portions are huge, too. You will not leave here hungry. I also love diners with old-school atmosphere and this place hits the mark. Today we tried three of their baked goods, and the cream cheese danish was phenomenal. It's always packed (others think it's delicious, too), but we've never waited long for a seat. It's just all-around fantastic.“

“Excellent soup and salad bar“

“One of my favorite cafes and hidden gems in the middle of town. The vibes are good, drink selection is spectacular and there's a lot of cool aspects like rentable meeting rooms, record selection on sale, and Paul's Pelmeni. Give it try“

“I've loved this peak of mall food location for my whole life, and lemme tell ya pal, these guys are great. Multiple times I would go there in my usual comfy attire. Third eye, goth dress, cat ears and tail, just my everyday. And I was treated with up most respect and kindness like every other customer. No weird glances or comments at all! Those are the things I'd get in a Walmart, but not Auntie Anne's.

They got my back with their fantastic pretzel dogs. They're always hot and ready, almost like it was just for me. But oh ho ho, get ready for this, if you haven't had a strawberry smoothie from here? Gaw I can't tell you in perfect words just how wondrous my first one was. I just had a food-gasm about it frankly. You should get one if you love a tasty cold fruity drink.

The photo is from just last week when I was enjoying a lovely picnic with a pal of mine. However, side story, the mall security seemed to not like the idea. Allow me to vent/explain;

Mall security walked up to us within ten minutes or so and said that we had to keep shoes on and could only eat in the food court. We weren't being loud or messy, we were on the carpeted resting area on top of my blanket, we kept the food close to us so it wouldn't get on the floor. Tbh the only thing they should've reasonably held us for was the fact that I was sort of in the way of one of the benches. But that's it. Plus, I have sensory issues as an autistic customer so eating where all the noise and heat was wouldn't have worked for me.

Needless to say, we chose to eat our yummy food outside the mall after that. Didn't wanna cause trouble with the rules as I really like this Auntie Anne's location.
☕️Here's to getting more Auntie Anne's and hoping that the mall itself does better for the people.“

“Wow Taste so Good! We will back again next time :)“

“Jane's is a funky little cafe & bakery. Surrounded by art from local artists. Open only till 3 in the after noon it's mostly breakfast and lunch. Counter served multi-cuisine fare that's fresh and family friendly. Their signature scones and pasteries are to die for with flavors you won't see anywhere else. Also great for Vegans and Vegetarians.“

“Delicious gluten free scones and breakfast sandwiches.“

“Whenever we're in Madison area, we go there and LOVE EVERYTHING-THE FOOD AND SERVICE IS WONDERFUL!“

“Driftless is one of my favorite coffees. So much so that I ordered some to be delivered to me in North Carolina. If you want a really good tasting coffee, look no further. Wish I was closer to a location, but will be in heavy rotation for delivery.“