14 Best Sandwich Shops in Green Bay

“I don’t get a chance to take a photo as I normally would, because it was a work lunch function in the office.

I saw they had a Cuban on the menu. Outside of FL it’s hard to find even a passably decent one. But have to say their take on this sandwich shocked me, and was utterly delicious.

Can’t wait to try more.“

“Cheese Cake Heaven is literally heaven! The soup is amazing, I recommend the Wisconsin cheddar or lobster bisque! The serving was super duper fast. I definitely recommend Cheese Cake Heaven!!!!!!!!!!😍🥰😘😃🤩😀😁😆😎😊“

“Omg huge shout out 2 Schlotzsky’s deli. As soon as I walk in I get greeted. Everything is always so fresh my staff are awesome I’ve been going here for years ever since they had the one on Oneida Street in greenbay. But after that one closed I started going to the one in Appleton but now I will drive 20 minutes just to come to the one in Green Bay on Mason Street . Very clean and you feel welcome as soon as you walk in the door whoever the owner is he’s got a great staff that work for him in a very clean restaurant. Keep up the great work love your food!😎 Thank you Aaron“

“First time eating here and not disappointed. Absolutely delicious and will definitely eat here again😋“

“Great experience ordering catering online from Erbert and Gerbert's! I called day of to verify delivery time, and they were already on their way! The gentleman I spoke with on the phone was polite and helpful. They even helped me load up my cart to take the food inside. Food tasted amazing, and everything arrived as expected.“

“best sandwich meat! good flavor! fresh bread! just absolutely delicious!! way more ingredients you can put on your sandwich. gotta try them if you havent!“

“Great Bar for a good time. Perfect for the draft. Close enough to get the vibe and walk over to check out the crowds, but great place to park and take a break from the shoulder-to-shoulder standing room only. Especially for those who have issues in BIG crowds. Get ready Green Bay you will never see crowds like this again until we win the next Super Bowl.“

“I’ve always had a good experience at Subway, but one visit really stood out to me. I stopped by during a busy afternoon, expecting a long wait, but the staff moved quickly and stayed friendly the whole time. They greeted me with a smile, listened carefully to my order, and even offered some suggestions to make my sandwich better—which I appreciated.

I went with the Steakhouse and Eggs sub, and it honestly hit the spot. The steak was flavorful and tender, the eggs were fluffy, and the melted cheese brought everything together perfectly. It was warm, hearty, and way more filling than I expected. Plus, everything from the veggies to the bread tasted fresh.

What I really like about Subway is how you can make your sandwich exactly how you want it. Whether I’m in the mood for something light or something more indulgent, they’ve got me covered. That particular visit reminded me why I keep going back.“

“The new owners are very nice people who have a passion to make the quality of food their number one priority. I have yet to have a sandwich made by them that was soggy or incorrectly made and I eat there fairly consistently. The store is clean and well kept and they even care to try and remember who you are and your sub of choice if you are a regular customer. They turn out subs quickly and precisely so you aren’t having to wait to have your sub(s) corrected like it was in the past with previous ownership. Would absolutely recommend trying it out or continuing to be a regular customer as the quality has only up since the ownership change.“

“We have always enjoyed Subway. This morning as we were driving past this Subway we pulled into the parking lot when my wife suddenly became sick. Although it was before opening time the manager, Katie, came out to the car with some napkins and water for her. Her thoughtfulness and kindness were so much appreciated. Thank you, Katie!“

“I would like to share my experience yesterday. There was a huge rush of people and there was only ONE employee. He was younger && he maintained his composure when most wouldn’t have been able to. He was kind even though he was overwhelmed. We were talking to him and making sure we understood the wait and that we’re all very patient (props to those in front of us who were also kind and patient to this young man). We were talking to him and it was only his FOURTH shift. I honestly felt terrible for him that management would put him in that position but I also know that the volume of people that came in may have not been anticipated for a Wednesday night too. There was another employee that came in for food and was able to jump in and help this young man. He was kind, caring polite and professional… well done to both of these young men!!“

“Usually good but not this time. Food not good and all ( yes ALL) tables were dirty!! There were no napkins or catsup packs out… guy had to go find some in back shake wasn’t good n saw him making it the chocolate pump was broke n he gave up and didn’t put hardly any Chocolate in.“

“I frequent this location as it is close-by to me and convenient. Which is great for me because I very much enjoy how well I’m treated here by each and every team member.

Everytime I enter, I’m greeted with a smile and friendliness. I regularly see the owner hop in the line and work alongside her employees which I think is really cool. I love how well they work together and how well they all seem to enjoy their jobs together. Everyone who I’ve interacted with here has been so nice, friendly, and helpful. And my food is always done well and right.

At other similar sub shops nearby, I’ve found myself having to pick off and throw away the produce from my sand-which because it’s wilting or not cleaned well. I never have that problem here. They are generous with meat portions and produce and will gladly add extra mayo for me (which they do anytime they see me now because I’m basically just mayo girl lol).“