13 Best Sandwich Shops in Appleton

“We were in the area and decided to pick up a couple of subs to take home. The service was very friendly and professional. Our sandwiches came out promptly and were very good! We will definitely return.“

“Sorry I keep forgetting to take a picture of the sandwich but this place has absolutely taking over the first place in my heart for a delicious sandwiches. I order the #16 Pick 2 option which includes half a sandwich and soup. So far I've tried the Mac & Cheese, the Chili and also the Broccoli and cheese. All 3 were good.“

“Great sandwich! Excellent service!“

“I always like eating at a Jersey Mike’s when I donate a sub. They have good options and have great ingredients. I was particular struck by the amazing customer service and kindness in this staff at the Appleton location. I rarely take the time to leave reviews, but 5 stars all around d for this crew.“

“Just had my best experience at Jimmy John’s (and I’ve eaten at a bunch of them). At this one on Wisconsin in Appleton, I was having a hard time ordering properly through the app. The young man at the counter was extremely helpful, was professional and polite, and then made me the best LOADED sandwich of my experiences at one of my favorite places for a sandwich. Thank you!“

“Keons and Collin are top-tier workers, they were happy to make orders, patient, and great conversationalists during the downtime of toasting and getting everything rung up and wrapped

Other times I have stopped by it was purely transactional

Update: 8/16 Brian killed a wasp 🐝!“

“Jimmy John’s has become my go-to spot for a quick, satisfying meal. Their sandwiches are consistently fresh, with high-quality meats, crisp veggies, and that perfectly soft-yet-crusty bread that makes every bite worth it. I especially love the #12 Beach Club – the avocado spread is a game-changer!

What really sets Jimmy John’s apart is their speed. Whether I’m ordering in-store, online, or through delivery, my food is always ready fast and made just the way I like it. The staff is friendly and efficient, and the locations are always clean and well-kept.

If you’re looking for a reliable, no-fuss sandwich place with great taste and unbeatable speed, Jimmy John’s delivers—literally and figuratively.“

“To the owner who replied, where in my review did I say I was not a fan of your food? how rude of a reply. Your lucky I did not review after my sandwich 2 days ago. That one had all the toppings in the box UNDER the sandwich. That pickup order I sent a picture to your store and no reply.“

“Do the subway rewards and have yet to offer reception of my rewards at this location...other locations kindly give me my $2.00 rewards toward purchase???
Remember only till 8 pm Saturday and Sunday the young worker had to kick someone out that tried to get service at 7:59:59pm...“

“The team at the Ballard Rd. location in Appleton are some of the kindest people I have ever seen in food service. Every single visit I've encountered wonderful people. I have driven across town just to go to this location over others due to their friendly employees.“

“Got 12 " to share w/ the wife. When I asked her how it was, She asked what I ordered. I aid "all Meats." She looked and there were NO MEATS!!! Complained to the staff, the manager and no results . TERRIBLE EXPERIENCE! DO Not Patronize them~~~~

Parking: Iy sucks!“

“glenn fresh bread and heaping meats and cheese are delicious“

“Decided to try this subway on our way home and met the super nice and personable owner. He said he just took over four months ago, which explains why the hours haven’t been updated yet. If you’re in the area I would choose this subway over the others. Great service and a very clean restaurant!!“