16 Best Ice Cream Shops near Lake Geneva

“I absolutely love this place and the family friendly environment!!“

“CUTEST candy shop right in downtown Lake Geneva! Ice cream, candy, baked goods, nuts, they have it all! Did I mention the Taffy bathtub? Something sweet is a one stop shop! Mike and Kristen put a ton of love and hard work into this place and you can tell!“

“There were a fair variety of flavors, we had never been there before and no one was present when we walked in, there was an arrow on the wall that signified where to start though. I helped my youngest with her selection then the gal came and weighed hers and I didn’t feel rushed at all while I selected my toppings. I appreciated that there were lids available as I was bringing one home to my husband. We will definitely stop in again sometime.“

“Danny was an excellent help and went above and beyond to ensure all of my questions were answered. His phenomenal customer service, professionalism, and attention to detail made the entire experience smooth and enjoyable. He was respectful, courteous, and truly made me feel valued as a customer. This Cold Stone store is incredibly lucky to have Danny and how he runs the store on his back when it all matters most.“

“Holy…. This is really good ice cream. It comes with a slightly tall price but 100% worth it. I got the brownie cascade, one scoop on a dipped waffle cone. I was stuffed. Really good chocolate flavor! My wife really liked her strawberry in a regular waffle cone. I will definitely go back, and probably tomorrow lol.“

“Thursday, May 12th, 2022Today is Day 01 of the Dole Whip machine being fired up and my mom and i are the first dole whip customers of the season. KC Senior and her daughter KC junior are amazing and so nice. They need to.open up some locations in Illinois. To open the Dole whip season, they have cherry, pineapple, or cherry pineapple swirl to.choose from.“

“Food was excellent, but double the price I remember.“

“Fabulous ice cream wonderful service“

“Sue is so nice and friendly. Really delish ice cream!“

“Delicious ice cream and such friendly staff! Order the Rainbow cone with 5 flavors, it’s the same as the Original Rainbow Cone in Chicago’s Beverly neighborhood. So delish, definitely stop in when you’re in the Bay. I love the cherry and pistachio!“

“Today my son went to the dari alone for the very first time on his bike! I called in advanced to ask them for help considering he is still learning about money (change jar and some tooth fairy dollars) the young man on the phone was so sweet. My son came back with some DELICIOUS cheese curds (the plan was for ice cream but that’s okay😂) “MOM THE SERVICE WAS SO POLITE AND I EVEN GAVE THEM A TIP” he was so giddy and hasn’t stopped talking about how much he loves it there and how amazing the food is. Thank you for making his whole day 💕“

“Such a nice and classy little place to meet with family and friends for a fun cocktail before or after dinner! Ice cream inside for the kiddos = win/win!“

“We held a bridal shower for 50 people in the Cobalt Lounge a few weeks ago. I can't say enough good things about our experience. I originally booked the venue site unseen when they were closed for the winter season but Frank was great and easy to communicate with and gave a tour to the bride and her mom when they opened for the season in May. Closer to the shower Gabbi coordinated everything with me (menu, setup, etc) and was great and very fast to respond to all my questions. The day of the event, Nate was our bartender and helped everything run smoothly. He was super friendly and easy to work with. I requested a last minute table out on the patio and he set it up quickly while I was decorating the room. All the food was ready at the scheduled time and was delicious. A very reasonable rate for the amount of food served. Everyone that attended the shower had wonderful things to say about the venue, the food and the VIEW! A wall of windows overlooking the lake was absolutely amazing. I would absolutely recommend Gordy's and the Cobalt Lounge and they would be my first choice for any future events/showers that I'm a part of“

“I love Friends on the Square- I almost feel like family when I walk in- the owner even knows my order by heart. Their drinks are always well made and I love their seasonal offerings (there’s always something new to try!).“

“Ice cream cakes! Ice cream treats! We get the treats and then deliver them to our grandsons. Then we come home and video chat while enjoying ice cream together. #socialdistancingwithgrandchildren“

“Culver's owners set their own prices. So their prices have a range. This one sets them high compared to others. It's the most expensive of those I frequent so I go out of my way to avoid getting the fish dinner there (which is my normal order).“