7 Best Ice Cream Shops near Williams Bay

Dip In The Bay Ice Cream Shop • $
105 N Walworth Ave, Williams Bay

“Absolutely love the butter pecan ice cream. First time ever going there and I'm going to go back before they close for the summer and get a big thing of the butter pecan ice cream. Everybody else is ice cream was really good too but mine was better of course cuz it was the butter pecan ice cream lol“

3.9 Good21 Reviews
Medusa Gelato Ice Cream Shop • $
272 Broad St unit A, Lake Geneva - 5.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Hazelnut Gelato
Cream Puffs
Baklava

“The best!!! Get all of it because the gelato is delicious and a welcome alternative to ice cream and the house made cream puffs are, in my husband’s opinion, a dream come true. The baklava is perfect and we’re going to try some of the grab and go specialties this weekend. Such a great addition to LG.“

5 Superb60 Reviews
Kilwins Lake Geneva Ice Cream Shop • $$
772 W Main St, Lake Geneva - 5.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Caramel Apple
Banana Fudge

“It's rare to get great service anywhere these days though all 3 people who helped us, 2 young men & 1 older woman, were friendly and helpful! We were given free small chocolate bar samples with our purchase of fudge, which was really good. Also got cappuccino chocolate chip ice cream that was very good. Wasn't sure where to eat it as it was very cold outside & they didn't have tables. Must have had that look on my face as I was kindly told there were tables in the building's common area, which served perfectly. Will definitely go back when in LG!“

4.6 Superb67 Reviews
Something Sweet Ice Cream • $$
105 E Townline Rd, Lake Geneva - 5.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Apple Pie Ice Cream

“While my mom and I were in town, we decided to stop by this family owned candy shop. The owner was super friendly and not overbearing while we browsed. The store itself is decent sized and has a variety of sweets like chocolates, gummies, taffy, fudge, caramel apples, prepacked candy, etc. A vast majority of their selections were picked over and I'm assuming that was due to the recent holiday. Overall, this is a cute sweet shop that has a variety of sweets to offer to surely satisfy your sweet tooth!“

4.6 Superb30 Reviews
La Michoacana Ice Cream Shop • $
229 E Walworth Ave, Delavan - 6.56 miles

“So glad our family stumbled upon this gem in Delavan—TONS of options, and it was hard to choose just one or two flavors because they were all so delicious! Highly recommend if you’re in the area or nearby in Lake Geneva and passing through to sightsee.“

4.6 Superb27 Reviews
Patty's Deli Deli • $
E Walworth Ave, Delavan - 6.62 miles

“Patti and her daughters catered our lunch for our work. It was the best Italian beef sandwiches and ham I have ever had. They also brought us homemade mashed potatos, green beans, corn and rolls. They also have 2 restaurants you can visit and have sandwiches made for you right there fresh. I highly recommend either visiting them or having them cater to you.“

4.9 Superb8 Reviews
Backyard @ Friends Beer Gardens • $
41 N Wisconsin St, Elkhorn - 6.58 miles

“I walked over here while waiting for the Christmas parade to see if they had any good food options for a small lunch. I noticed some cute women's clothing off to the right.Due to the parade the line snaked all the way around the side of the ordering station and I didn't get a chance to see the menu to check for food, but decided to get in line because there were a dozen people ahead of me already!There was a small dining room in the back near the kitchen with table seating and I could see that they had baked goods.Once I made my way around to the front counter I was glad to see that they did have three soups, which seemed like a perfect option for keeping us warm while we watched the parade. They also offered paninis and other food items.The soup options were chili, pumpkin, and chicken noodle. While I love a good pumpkin bisque, I wan't sure if this one would be a cream based version here or not, and something like chili with beef sounded great so I ordered two of those and a hot apple cider.Due to how busy they were, there was a bit of a scramble for the staff to determine the best way to communicate with the kitchen and get soup up to the counter, but they were on it. My apple cider came out quickly, and it was good although I wished it had been just a little hotter. Several minutes later my chilis were ready, piping hot and complete with crackers, spoons and napkins. The chili was homemade with lots of tomato chunks, celery, some beans and beef and it definitely hit the spot.The shop is family-owned and had lots of gift items, decor and clothing available as well as Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream. Their coffee brand was JBC Coffee Roasters. Available in the shop they had drinkware, Jewelry, teas, soaps, and pet supplies to name a few.When I got back to my parade post, I found out they were running a hot cocoa counter out of the back parking lot with a long line as well. If in the area I'd definitely stop back in.“

4.7 Superb14 Reviews
Loading...
map Map