46 Best Italian Restaurants near New Berlin

“Worked at Armelis many many years ago. Had a craving for it tonight and it’s exactly how I remember it from 15+ years ago! My husband had it for the first time and said “WHY HAVENT WE ORDERED FROM HERE BEFORE?!” So we will definitely be ordering again!“

“Most awesome pizza ever they have the best Italian sausage on the pizza. The cheesy bread is also great. Their wings are good. Their pepperoni pizza is awesome. Customer service and staff are really really nice. No complaints at all if you have trouble getting through there a small place for pick up and delivery in carry out so just keep trying they’re worth every second..“

“I love sandwiches and I now have a new favorite sandwich shop. My only wish would be you did soup on GrubHub.“

“Had a great experience here, it was an easy place to get some food after our movie. We were greeted by our host, Craig, he was very friendly and prompt to get us seated. We were served by Ian, he was incredibly friendly and helped us get acquainted with the menu. Would definitely come back again.“

“Fried zucchini and steaks are very good so is the spaghetti very friendly people“

“Our third time and the anniversary couple's first time (55 years!) and we were all thoroughly impressed! The food is so authentic - better than any dish we had when we visited Italy! Made with love and fresh ingredients, served by staff who care, and presentation and waitstaff well worth the price. This is not inexpensive, but for any meal with ambiance, and never disappointing, I recommend it highly. Five star everything. We cannot say enough. Thank you for contributing a wonderful Italian option in Tosa area.“

“Cannot say enough about the food, the staff and the ambiance. Whether it is pregame, post-game, special night out, day drinking and dining or late night cocktails and dinner after a late flight this place never, ever disappoints. Its been that way for years and hope it never changes.“

“I have not been here in years. We just had a large family gathering today and it was amazing! Great food, great service.“

“Staff was very attentive. Food was fantastic. My only complaint is the price, but you certainly get plenty of food for what you pay.“

“everyone there is always very friendly. we love eating there“

“There is nothing that I did not like about tonight's experience. The atmosphere was lovely. The service was fantastic and friendly. The food was delicious. The wine was divine. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Cheesy garlic bread 👍Salad was fresh and tasty. Generous portion. Steak speidini with angel hair pasta was perfect. TIRAMISU was one of the best I can remember. GRAZIE 🇮🇹“

“Went here for the 1st time tonight and is was beyond wonderful. Service was fantastic and the food was soooo good. Can not wait to eat here again ❤️“

“I love the pizza but it seems like the sauce was different. did they change the sauce?“

“Classic Italian done right!“

“Great discovery of a great pizza place!“

“Extremely good pizza! I’ve been eating Mama Mia’s since I was a kid, and even though I no longer live in Milwaukee, it’s still a rare and special treat whenever I get the chance to enjoy what I consider to easily be the best pizza in the Midwest. The garlic bread is exceptional as well. Sadly, the original Antipasto salad is no more. Highly recommended!“

“Our food came out timed with apps and entrees. Fresh and hot. Exavion was a superb server meeting our needs and friendly with smiles. Our apps the lasagna rolls and fried mozzarella were delicious! Entrees of shrimp scampi and eggplant parmigiana were wonderful! I am new to the area and I will be back!“

“Vinu Cappuccino had a great takeout experience. I ordered the chicken parmesan & few more to go, and it was very tasty — the chicken was well cooked, crispy, and flavorful with a rich sauce and melted cheese. Everything was packed nicely and stayed warm until I got home. Quality and portion size were both good. I would definitely order from here again. 👍🍽️“

“Absolutely fantastic. I ordered on a whim , en route home from work. I never heard of the place before , but it slapped harder than nonna with a hot spoon. The food was ready before the pick up time. And it was phenomenal. Would smash again. Definitely. 🤌🏻🤌🏻“

“The absolute BEST gluten free pizza! You brought me to tears! The pizza tasted just like “regular” pizza! Thank You!!“

“Best around baked mostacolli“

“I have been to Brick Pizzeria 5 times and I absolutely loved the braised short ribs. The last time I went i got the lobster mac and cheese. Sadly it wasn’t real lobster. it was fake or as the waitress said a mix of lobster with other seafood. The other people in my party tasted it as well and all said it was fake crab meat. I was very disappointed. I would have appreciated the menu listing what was actually in the dish. Lobster has a distinct texture and flavor. I have really enjoyed Brick so this was very sad Michelle L“

“I was here recently with my 89 year old retired dance teacher and my friend I used to dance with. We had not seen each other in several years. We met at the restaurant that is near Southridge mall in Milwaukee. Shelby was our waitress. She is a gem! No hurry to get out. Came to the table often to see if we needed anything. Had a great time! I had the sampler platter . Awesome and at a good price. No wonder these restaurants are always busy. We went to one last year in Boseman Montana when we were on vacation. This was the first time my son ate at this restaurant. He loved it. The waiter again was awesome! He gave my son the meal for free since it was his first time eating there. Not sure how he could do this but people in Boseman are very nice indeed. My son is now a lifelong patron of this restaurant! Soup and salad for 12.99. A deal!“

“Food was phenomenal!! The atmosphere is lacking. A day of touching up paint, stain, chair nicks and deep cleaning would go a long way for minimal cost and effort. You would have thought it would have been done during the COVID-19 shutdown.“

“Visiting family in Milwaukee and they recommended coming here for the fish fry. Fish was delicious. Pieces were smaller than I expected but they were really good. They give you a bread basket as well which they refill when empty. Only hiccup was the service seemed a little slow considering they were very busy but the waiter was very polite and courteous. Overall I enjoyed the food and service“

“This is such a cute hole in the wall!! The workers here are all awesome and nice. We got the whole place to ourselves and the kids enjoyed every second. This is all of these picky eaters new favorite pizza…… that says all ya need to know! THANK YOU GROTTOOO!!!“

“We were in Wauwatosa to avoid the craziness of Milwaukee and stopped by this little bar - Club Tap. Our neighbors at the bar counter ordered the CHEESIEST pizza that I’ve ever seen in my entire life (I’ve seen a lot of pizza) from you guys and we HAD to go next door and get some of our own. The small town vibes of this pizza place are wonderful. It’s so cute, authentic, DELICIOUS, and worth every penny. Thank you Lalli’s for your service. I don’t know who Lalli is but I’m sure he/she is/was great.“

“my children took y wife Lori and me for our 40th anniversary, The food was excellent. WE THOROJGHLY ENJOYED OURSELVES AND THE FOOD AND SERVICE WERE EXCELLENT. THANKS MIAS!!!“

“My family and I have been enjoying leah’s for decades. I love the garlic bread. It’s thick and dense bread loaded with butter! The pizza is great too. I was there on sunday august 4th and our server was attentive and pleasant. I’m shocked about all the bad reviews because I have never had a bad experience there. I can’t think of pizza in the suburbs that I like more than this.“

“I absolutely love Ann’s! Pizza, fettuccine, lasagna are all delicious. Last night I had Ann’s penne with chicken and it’s my new favorite! Our waiter, Logan, was amazing also! Definitely a must check out!“

“January 16, 2026. Just had a wonderful experience at Balistreri’s. There were 4 of us having the BEST PIZZA EVER! This is our go to pizza joint…all the way from North Carolina🤣🤣 (a joke). But my review is mainly regarding our awesome waiter, Ricardo! He was so pleasant and fun and played along with our joke! He showed that he truly enjoyed his job….what a joy!“

“We got our 1st pizza from Cataro’s Pizza last night at 11:15pm after seeing the band Without Annette at Da Bar nearby. We were hungry so we searched pizza open late near me. That’s how we found this amazing pizza. The owner had closed the dining room early because business has been so slow but he offered to make us one to go. It was so good! I highly recommend this place. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Nice little spot with good service and great food!“

“This is our favorite pizza in Milwaukee. The crust is great and they don't skimp on toppings. Lots of cheese too!“

“Hands down the best pizza 🍕 I just love that packer pizza“

“my husband and I went there tonight for his birthday. the food was really good but I want to brag about Robert our server. He is the best server I have experienced in a long time. we never once had to flag him down to refill our soda. If we blinked we would miss him putting a fresh basket of bread out for us. Our empty plates never sat on our table for long before Robert walked by and swooped them up. kudos to Bravo! for hiring Robert. I would definitely come back if I was guaranteed him as my server. Robert thanks you so much for the excellent service you provided, and I hope we left you a great tip, you truly deserve it“

“Juan our server did a great job. Excellent service and the food was delicious“

“Excellent products, excellent service and great atmosphere!!!“

“Fantastic pizza - always - hot, delicious, done the way you like it - near the 'hood' and on-time - small place - but thin crust is on FIRE!!!!!! Awesome - recommended highly by those that tried it - many times.“

“Usually order for delivery, but finally came to see the inside. It is so cute! I love this place and their pizza!“

“Ordered catering dishes and pizzas. I worked with the owner to order and everything was so phenomenal. The penne pasta delicious. Breadsticks are outstanding. Baked chicken was some of the best. Perfectly seasoned. And of course pizzas are always awesome. My gusts couldn’t stop telling me how good everything was.
Thank you!!“

“Always great service and pizza!! Dough nuggets I had last time were amazing too! We tried the pasta tonight and it was delicious but a little disappointed with only half an Italian sausage link being an order size for $2. The noodle to meat ratio is definitely off so make sure you order double meat if ordering create your own pasta. Very tasty though!! My boyfriend had the lasagna and said he would definitely order again. Hands down best pizza in the area that we’ve found. 😊“

“Last opening day today. Sad to see it close.“

“Chicago Native, so believe me when I say these guys are the best. I moved up to the Waukesha area in Summer 2022. I was craving a Large Sausage pizza late close to their closing time, ended up going with a Supreme type pizza. They were quick, and even stayed slightly past closing so I could pick up my order. Tipped generously simply for that courtesy and professionalism. Will be my STAPLE pizza place in the area from now on. A Go-To spot.“

“A friend and I ate here a couple afternoons ago and wow was it to die for. Ever since new management took this place it has been spot on. One of the best Stromboli’s I have ever tried. The staff was also super friendly. I would for sure recommend this place to anyone.“

“I went in person to order my pizza because i was near by. Pizza only took like 15min to be ready. But their entrance, floor and carpet and ordering area is dirty. Filled with grease and flour. Young boys at the front are very nice and polite.“