21 Best American Restaurants near New Holstein

“Home made soups, fresh, crispy salads, amazing burgers, wraps and fish fries. And on top of that...great, friendly service. This place ia s favorite for sure“

“This is a great dive bar with great people and great staff. I had the privilege to meet the owners, and they were extremely friendly and inviting they even taught me a new bar game called Tower. I highly recommend this place. If you're looking for a fun night out at a dive bar.“

“Excellent food and service.“

“food was very good and service was great!“

“Any and every thing tastes excellent here! Love this place and the staff especially! Jim and Ann“

“I can't express how grateful my husband and I are to have chosen Millhome Supper Club as our catering service. From start to finish, they exceeded all my expectations and truly made our special day unforgettable. First and foremost, the food was absolutely incredible! The highlight was definitely when Aaron (Managing Owner) personally congratulated us, and stayed to ensure everything ran smoothly. Aaron is amazing, his communication impeccable and he is so personable. I did not have to worry one bit as a bride. Thank you Aaron for taking what is typically a huge stress, off my shoulders. The team at Millhome was not only professional but also incredibly attentive. On the day of the wedding, their execution was flawless. The service was seamless, and the staff were friendly and accommodating. My husband and I wholeheartedly recommend Millhome Supper Club to anyone looking for catering that goes above and beyond!!! Thank you, for being such an integral part of our special day!“

“Great food . Wonderful people.“

“Our bartender, Anna was so nice and helpful. Our server didn’t seem to want to be bothered with our order. Mixed up a lot between the 3 parties that ordered at the bar. Anna redid the corrected bills, while the server couldn’t be bothered. The food was great as usual, but never he a rude server before. But Anna made up for it, with a smile on her face.“

“Food & service was great will be back there again“

“Quite the interesting interior. Definitely takes you back in time. Was able to go up to the tower. Friend caught orbs on her pictures. Definitely spirits here. Dinner was great. Had chicken Marsala and German Potato salad. Both hot and delicious“

“Best Sunday funday lunch and packer game! Food was DELICIOUS! I had a burger and fries and he had a bowl of chili and Deluxe grilled cheese!! Both to die for!! We will be back:)“

“Great Food/Service Vy Server Elsi L! The Best In Elkhart Lake ! Johnny V (Madison Visitor)“

“The new owner is awesome! Very accommodating and nice to our local homeschool group! Great food too, highly recommend!“

“The burgers are amazing! Definitely will be back when we come back to Wisconsin!!💚💛“

“My wife and I moved to the Fond du Lac area about 5 years ago and have been trying different places around the area for their fish fry’s. Although some have been pretty good none have been OMG we have to go back until we found Neighborhood Pub and grill. I had the hand breaded perch and my wife had the baked haddock and they were both delicious. We will definitely be going back!!“

“I have been a regular for years and have always ordered to go. Tonight I called to place an order and you're not doing to go's. by no means am I saying people shouldn't go there they absolutely should your food is great. I've just never had this happen before in years of ordering and I definitely think it's a flaw to the business. yall missed out on a good $100 order. lol the reason for no to go's was on busy weekends you dont do togos. totally fine. but could you maybe include that in a post in the future? I'm honestly so bummed I'm missing your dinner. I'm just super autistic when it comes to eating. lbvs so I'm struggling now to figure out how to feed myself and my dad who I care for 😭😭😭 food is always awesome, workers are always great. a heads up of no to go orders would make you perfect 💜 also love your non alcoholic options for people who don't drink.“

“I have been enjoying coming here shortly after they opened. Live music, good food and good people keep me coming back. I highly recommend stopping in with an appetite and desire for a good time.“

“Once again amazing food & service. My inlaws from Texas loved the place & Ethan was fantastic!!“

“Nice clean place , bar tenders where very nice!“

“👍👍First time fish fry, certainly won't be the last! Excellent job!!!“

“What a great place for me to walk into for the first time not knowing what it would be. Atmosphere was great, plenty of TVs playing sports, and some of the best wings I've ever eaten. Service was spot on all around and the locals were very friendly with me knowing that I was out of state. And.... the spotted cow beer draft was amazing as advertised!“