Potbelly

$ • Sandwich Shops, Fast Food, Salad

Hours:
9330 76th St Ste C Ste C, Pleasant Prairie
(262) 842-0246

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites

Potbelly Sandwich Shop Reviews

2.1 (40)

Food was good and cooked the way it was ordered. However, if you’re going to cover the sink lids with stickers, at least use stickers I can take off and use a straw with. Spent 10 min trying to pick it off and ended up having to cut through it with a knife. Only seems to happen when you order ahead though, so drive through and dine-in are all good!

This Potbelly used to be good but service and food quality has fallen drastically post-pandemic. They seem to be understaffed, and the sandwiches are hastily made, and a mess when you receive them. The onions are stringy and slimy and they put hardly any mushrooms on the veggie. Prices are also too high for the quality of the food. I cannot recommend this place.

Wow!! Just left Potbelly (mind you, I've never been in the restaurant before, 1st time ever....) but 4 woman and a man was working, the girls acted if I was an inconvenience, had an small attitude about the cheese and bacon in my potato soup. Like .. okay...The man and the cashier were really friendly the drive thru woman was helpful but the other 2 seemed annoyed and didn't want to be there. I did not feel welcome ordering my smoked ham and potato soup or even in the restaurant...read full review

More Reviews(148)

Ratings

View all photos

Hours

Monday 10AM - 9PM
Tuesday 10AM - 9PM
Wednesday 10AM - 9PM
Thursday 10AM - 9PM
Friday 10AM - 9PM
Saturday 10AM - 10PM
Sunday 10AM - 9PM
Updated on: