39 Best American Restaurants in Sheboygan

“Awesome food and drinks. Prices are very reasonable and the staff is very friendly.“

“Great place! Their grilled chicken sandwich with the French fries is delicious! We go here on ocassions for the Friday fish fry. The staff and management is so nice! Don't forget to try their desserts! Their apple crisp with ice cream is amazing!“

“Great atmosphere, large portions… awesome for family get together!“

“good eats friendly staff“

“Absolutely spectacular golf courses. All of the servers and staff are so nice and professional.

I was admiring the pin of a sheep for the Irish Course worn by our server Ellie.

Such a sweet and smart girl, full of knowledge. Ellie took off her pin and gave it to me. A gesture that touched my heart ❤️ and will not forget.

I highly recommend this hidden treasure in Wisconsin.“

“great atmosphere great servers great company“

“Some friends and I made reservations before a comedy show. Once we got there we quickly realized we didn't give ourselves enough time to thoroughly enjoy the atmosphere and eat at leasure, which is what Bomallies does best,try,eat ,try something new again. We meantioned to our server, the amazing Holly, our time restraints, she then helped us though the menu on what we could get in time, while still enjoying ourselves. Not only did we have an amazing meal and delicious crafted drinks but we checked out and got to our show (in Kohler) with minutes to spare. THIS MY FRIEND, it what sets BoMallies aside. Not only have I never had a bad meal, I have always had the customer service that made me walk away loving my time with them and ALWAYS leaving with a strawberry shortcake to go. No matter how full I am. You won't be disapointed .“

“After a long day of travel including a series of incremental flight delays that kept me from walking away to eat, I finally made it to Sheboygan and walked into Black Pig at about 8:30 when they close at 9. Bartender Michael welcomed me in and even though I offered to order my food to go he encouraged me to stay and enjoy my dinner while it was hot. (Thank goodness since it was a balmy 0 degrees outside). The food was amazing! The salad was beautiful and the pan seared striped trout (if I remember that correctly) was amazing! The place itself was just beautiful inside. Thank you Michael for making sure my first meal of the day was a great one!“

“We absolutely love Schulz's! I grew up going with my dad and now I take my son. We live further away but always make a point to stop. The most amazing food and service! Wonderful family owned small business! I hope they stay around forever! Thank you for the years of amazing food and service!“

“Excellent shrimp dinner. Portions were over the top. Service and waitress were excellent. Highly recommend!“

“fast, friendly service & the food is exceptional“

“On the coldest night in January, we enjoyed the juiciest biggest burger, about 5" tall and the most delectably crafted and flavored flat bread. We'll be back!“

“we made a day trip down to the Milwaukee area and on our way back to green bay we stopped to grab our 1st meal of the day!! it was delicious the burgers were very hot lol the bacon was real bacon also!! very very good food! gentleman wearing black chef jacket asked us how things were along with refilled my husband's water!! kudos to this place! Will have to become a regular stop when we travel that way for sure“

“Best Burger in town. Hands down“

“Always a great atmosphere to enjoy some tasty food, good drinks, and laughter with friends. Forgot how good the tenderloin Mac & cheese was among other menu items.“

“the food is great I eat there all the time“

“Great beer, great drinks, great music, great people“

“😎 great cheese burgers, good service“

“huge fresh burgers 🍔 fast and great service 👍 huge variety of drinks“

“The food is always fresh, always super flavorful. It’s also high quality. The same staff has been there for a while and friendly each of the few times I’ve been in here. I really wanted some of their bottled truffle aioli sauce (I try to get some when I’m in the area) and didn’t see any in the display so asked them if they had any. They were out but the guy in the kitchen bottled some- sealed and everything for us while we were there. We will be back!“

“The best fresh cocktails in town! We've loved going to Urbane for their pear mojitos and food options, so we took our bridal party there for cocktail hour! The staff is always so professional, and make the best cocktails. Additionally, the bartenders always get creative with mocktails and they exceed expectations each time. The bar was decorated so beautifully for Christmas, it was the perfect stop for our bridal party before our reception. Thank you for having us!“

“All the bartender is amazing, super friendly and attentive.“

“Awesome food! Clean. Great atmosphere“

“So good!!! (um, they let you choose the crispness of your bacon and hashbrowns...wow and yum!) We love breakfast, but not bringing a toddler out to enjoy it. Our first meal was an unexpected delight and Bill's Corner has become a staple spot to order from now. Thank you and great job team!“

“Had a great time today. The waitress was great and Mark… I think that was the hosts name was very cool. Such a great guy and was great to us. Appreciate it.“

“it's a wonderful places to hang pit with friends good music 🎶“

“The owners and wait staff are great, very attentive. . Have never had a bad meal, extraordinarily clean and everything from homemade soups to fresh salads, breakfast and sandwiches are all great!“

“The bartender is absolutely fantastic! He has a way with making people smile and laugh. The food was good. Next time… I’ll take a medium rare steak-sandwich without cheese, please! That’s my only complaint about the sandwich, had I not ordered the cheese…“

“Had a great time when we stopped in. Frankie behind the bar was welcoming and fun but not intrusive. Also, she cheffed up some excellent food for us. Steak sammie was a hit! I’ve only been there once and live 1200 miles away, but if I return to Sheboygan, I’ll be returning here. And *fingers crossed* it will be an equally amazing night!“

“Awesome place. Great customer service. Owner always acknowledges everyone and appreciated her customers! Good old fashioned customer service! A lot of regulars, and we come from 45 minutes away. We are always treated as a regular! Great place!“

“Me and my daughters went there for breakfast. The staff were very pleasant. The food was pretty good. I ordered my eggs over easy, but there was still a little runny. My waitress Made me some new ones. My daughter ordered banana pancakes And Wow that was a big plate But all in all it was a good experience

Parking: Wednesdays and Saturdays. Is farmers market right across the street? So in the morning it's a little more difficult to find parking, but they do have a private parking lot. Just for the restaurant

Kid-friendliness: They have a kids menu and There was A high chair available for me“

“Fast and friendly service and the food as always is fantastic!“

“It was much better than the first time I was there a few years ago. Service was OUTSTANDING. I had the grilled spicy shrimp tacos. I liked them. It's not as good as others I've had. I think the ratio of coleslaw is too high. There was just something missing. The best shrimp tacos are Time Out in Manitowoc. I wish somewhere local could create them.“

“Great service and great food“

“good brew selection and open atmosphere. i just dont reccomend sitting by the door to the smoking room“

“Sly's looks a little rough from the outside but don't let that scare you. The food is excellent and the service is very good. It has a great local atmosphere and there are lots of specials! Bonus was they had the brewer game on!

Wheelchair accessibility: Front door is no steps to the street“

“Good food, great service! While I was there with my wife, I witnessed a waiter(not mine) take care of a couple who had difficulty getting to the salad bar due to their immobility. He checked back with them often, and took the time to physically go to the salad bar himself and prepare a salad and extras for the couple. He really didn’t have to do that. It was busy and arguable the couple had an order placed and I suppose could have skipped the salad. In today’s environment it was refreshing to see someone caring for their customer like this! Great job by that waiter, and our service was excellent as well.“

“Had a wonderful lunch. The BLTA with herb salad was delicious. Great food and friendly staff. Definitely recommend Driftwood South Pier!“

“Carissa our server was the great estate“