15 Best American Restaurants near Sister Bay

“I've been there a few times, everything has been wonderful. Turkey sandwich was delicious, and the "adult" grilled cheese was amazing. I was a bit skeptical about the fig jam, but wow, it was great. Also, the music playlist that is in the background just happened to hit one favorite after another. Go there. Everyone's super welcoming and the service is efficient but not hovering.“

“We tried to eat WT in Fish Creek but the wait was long, ended up taking a carry out and beer to the park, we weren't sure what to expect, place looked lovely, bar outside was great especially the bartender from St. Charles ( hey girl! we made it back to Chicago and possibly see You this Fall! ) ... pizza was TO DIE FOR!!! We got the FUN-GUY and wow wow wow, great job guys😍 we'll be back!“

“Love the food, the environment and Alex and Nick made our visit so much fun!! We came back 3 times in our 4 day stay!!“

“It was an awesome experience at Sister Bay Bowl ❤️ We really enjoyed the steak toppers, door county cherry pie, and the brandy old fashioned 🥧🥃🍒 A lot of the reviews strongly recommended the fish so a couple of us got Surf & Turf platters—and the fish was great, but everyone agreed the steak was the real highlight! It was fun to end the evening with some more drinks and bowling 🎳 Would definitely recommend to anyone visiting in Door County!“

“The bar is pretty cool. I got the pizza one night and it was pretty tasty. It was the thin crust pizza the other time I went and got a Ruben sandwich.“

“After a long hike my friends and I stopped at Hill Street for dinner. I had the Kurgan Burger and it was one of the best burgers I’ve ever had. The ingredients blended perfectly with each other and the seasoned fries were excellent as well. I wanted to take some time to write what an excellent experience I had at Hill Street and how much I enjoyed their food.“

“We tried the bone marrow and tuna appetizers. We moved on to crab cakes with lemon aioli and ribeye for our dinners. Thank you to the staff, chef and bartender (I wish we had asked his name). We had a wonderful, peaceful meal here to celebrate our anniversary. The bartender introduced my husband to a new Bourbon and even gave us spot on advice on where to purchase a bottle. Top shelf liquor options galore! The food was amazing! 5 stars and we will visit again!“

“What a great little break on our drive up and TK was an amazing host 😀“

“We love the White Gull Inn! The restaurant has been one of our favorite places for 50+ years! We’ve also enjoyed staying there.“

“This golf course is a gem, and not just for golfers! Their pub serves some of the best food in the area, and the cod fish fry is hands-down the BEST in Door County. The service is always friendly and attentive, and Kevin, the owner, truly cares about providing a great experience to his guests - it’s evident by the constant upgrades he’s making to the pub and grounds. It’s the kind of place you want to tell everyone about… but also secretly keep to yourself. A true best-kept secret in the area!“

“We were on the trolley and stop here for lunch. Service was outstanding and food was excellent! I even got a bandage for my thumb! Thx again!“

“My friend and I were up there for a weekend 6/25-6/29 and the first time we stopped at this bar, we came back every day! The bartenders (who were the owners) were great and so welcoming, made our visit so much fun! Bloody Mary’s were our favorite to order once they opened! The arcade is a must hit for sure! The atmosphere was just so relaxing, it made us happy for sure! Can’t wait to visit Mink River Basin again! 100/10 for sure 😉“

“Excellent food. We loved the French Onion Soup, Ribeye, Fries and the incredible desserts. Most of all, we loved Carlton. He took great care of us and made it fun. Megan was super helpful as well. Great experience.“

“Great atmosphere and good food! Would definitely recommend!!“

“Great food. Great service. Amazing host and bartender. New favorite place.“