10 Best American Restaurants in Sister Bay

“Great sandwiches, love the outdoor seating!“

“I've been there a few times, everything has been wonderful. Turkey sandwich was delicious, and the "adult" grilled cheese was amazing. I was a bit skeptical about the fig jam, but wow, it was great. Also, the music playlist that is in the background just happened to hit one favorite after another. Go there. Everyone's super welcoming and the service is efficient but not hovering.“

“Family friendly place! The spicy white fish wrap was honestly the best fish wrap I’ve ever had 💯👏 great customer service. Friendly atmosphere“

“There are several Italian restaurants in Door County. And yet, once again, there I was...in the land of whitefish and walleye. Eating pasta from my very favorite place to eat pasta. I swear these people have an Italian chef being held hostage in a cooler full of perch....Creating absolutely insane pasta dishes. Like the current special which involves Green goddess sauce with pistachio and I'm pretty sure... fairy dust. Oh, and have I mentioned the cocktail creations? My latest was made with gin infused with baobob. (Oh ... and the seafood is awesome too)“

“Wild Tomato never disappoints! We usually visit in the off-season, but even in the busy season this place is amazing. Best. Pizza. Ever. �“

“food, atmosphere, staff are all incredible“

“Love the food, the environment and Alex and Nick made our visit so much fun!! We came back 3 times in our 4 day stay!!“

“They were so nice and turned the back TV to Sunday Night Football for us. We’ve been coming up for many years and always try and hit the Northern Grill. One year we discovered all you can eat spaghetti night. They no longer do that but we still get the spaghetti. Prices have gone up and they have reduced their portion size and nights they are open. But we still recommend it.“

“Sara who answered the phone to take our reservation was so friendly, helpful and so sweet! We ate inside and it was so good. We had the salmon and steak and both were amazing! The bread was so good as well as the side salad. It was our 1st time trying LURE and it was 10/10 and we will be back!! Can’t wait to try everything on the menu as it looked top notch… keep doing an amazing job LURE! Even with it being such a busy weekend- service was quick and top notch!!“

“It was an awesome experience at Sister Bay Bowl ❤️ We really enjoyed the steak toppers, door county cherry pie, and the brandy old fashioned 🥧🥃🍒 A lot of the reviews strongly recommended the fish so a couple of us got Surf & Turf platters—and the fish was great, but everyone agreed the steak was the real highlight! It was fun to end the evening with some more drinks and bowling 🎳 Would definitely recommend to anyone visiting in Door County!“