11 Best American Restaurants in Arcata

“I have been to alot of restaurants and this is one of the best ive ever eaten at. My old fashioned was perfectly crafted and my filet was perfect and melted in my mouth. I'll be back for more.“

“Excellent fresh and local ingredients. Food was delicious and plenty of it. Everything homemade and from local sources. Highly recommended!“

“Good food that comes in large portions though takes a little bit to get to the table. Great service, I have been multiple times and have gotten a variety of waitresses and all have been very kind and patient. Nice atmosphere, and is very clean, bathrooms look nice. Typically a bit crowded especially at dinner times.“

“Visiting from Sacramento valley. This place is good & decently priced! Better fish & chips than more expensive places. Baked goods are yummy!!“

“We were in town visiting from NJ. Stopped here for breakfast and it was amazing! Huge portions and delicious food. had a sweet treat from the bakery too. Staff was very friendly. Would highly recommend!“

“I don’t know why there isn’t a line up the street for this place. Absolutely delicious sandwiches. And for a reasonable price too. Very filling as well. 10/10 will be coming back“

“Great food and great place to people watch..“

“Best Mexican food in humboldt, and one of the best restaurants all around. Gotta try the Pollo a la Crema, so very good! Their Chipotle burger is delicious also. Give them a try!“

“Every time I go into the Big Blue I’m greeted with a smile and quickly seated. The staff is amazing and you can tell all the dishes are made with love. ❤️“

“Good vibes, great music and food smelled great, but we had already had a meal. Fun venue!

Parking: I'd recommend getting there early for tje more popular shows......parking is competing with residents, mivie theater and shopa and events on the Plaza....“

“Love us some Pub at the Creamery. It’s a regular spot for our weekly date night. We each get a pizza, share the house salad and get a couple of their creative cocktails. My favorite vegetarian pizza is the Greek. The husband likes the classic pizza. My favorite thing about the house salad are the roasted garbanzo beans. Their cocktails are delicious and their ice is huge and clear just like we like em! You can also get the food to go which we did last night. The hostess called when the food was ready so I could pick it up hot and fresh. So great customer service too. 👌🏻“