19 Best American Restaurants in Eureka

“Super clean, which is a rarity these days! Also, wonderful breakfast, fast and friendly service. Love it here!“

“excellent service excellent food amazing hospitality and atmosphere is awesome“

“So glad they are open for dinner again! They have tasty food, wonderful staff, and an awesome manger/owner!“

“Walked in at 7:05pm and was greeted with a smile. 2 adults and one 5 year old wild child. Our waiter was amazingly kind and attentive. The atmosphere was calm and happy. It was our first time eating there and the food was phenomenal from our burgers to my son's kid pizza....which was giant and flavorful! We had a really good experience and the cost was perfect for the amount of food received. We will be coming back again.“

“The service was excellent! Waitress is very friendly. I would say this was one of my top choices for excellent clam chowder from the places I’ve tried in the past. There’s two sides to this restaurant and I stayed in the nicer upscale side. Excellent presentation portions are small but a great place to come and celebrate an occasion.“

“The service and food were both excellent this evening! I was especially looking forward to a good ribeye steak, unfortunately due to a shipment mixup there were no ribeye. However, they upgraded my dinner to a mouth-watering filet at no charge. Needless to say, I was not disappointed! We also got the rack of lamb and the table-side ceaser salad. Everything was excellent, and I can't wait to come here again!“

“What an amazing experience top notch food and service“

“I appreciate you Hosting Lodestar Birthday Celebration for our Friend in Heaven Linda Faye Carson❤️It was a Truly Amazing Evening-I really Enjoyed Your Tavern🎉 Thank You Michaele Whiteley“

“Love love love the vibes here! I’m a retro soul, and I love coming here. We often get desserts. Sundaes, milkshakes, cones ect. Never fails, always delicious, we use the walk up window and checkout all the model cars. It’s a Eureka MUST!“

“This place is amazing’ I highly recommend it!“

“great experience right from the door. hostess was friendly, server was attentive, and the food was tasty. would recommend.“

“the quality of the locally sourced food is impressive. I am lucky enough to work at Cafe Nooners. I have never experienced a more positive work environment nor felt as welcome as I have here since day one. There's good reason this Cafe has been so successful for so long. The tri-tip sandwich is my favorite, but I find I enjoy their vegan dishes almost as much. Try the chocolate chip cookies made fresh from scratch!“

“Lamb Shanks, Dungeness Crab Benedict.“

“Never leave reviews but boy the food here was amazing. Travelling from Australia and the beers have to be the best I’ve had in the states. Shouts to my boy Marco who was killing it with his service, give my man a raise or something because he works his a** off. Much love“

“Best crab cakes I’ve ever had. Fantastic ambiance and service.“

“The BEST Food and Service I highly recommend!!!!“

“Ashleigh is the best , truly . I love ihop but she made it next level great! She was so friendly and so on top of accommodating our every need. We never had to call her to us or go without , she was on it. Her skills are IMPRESSIVE. She can take a full order from a big family who has all these extra requests , then converse with us and remember every single detail . First time I’ve even gone somewhere in a long time where they don’t have to send the order back because of mistakes . Like she is amazing and I’ll come here again because of her !“

“The new cheesy cheeseburger was awful. As you can tell from the picture there was no gooey cheese to dip the burger into and it was crusted to the plate. It was difficult to pry off. No flavor. The music was so loud you could not hear your partner across the table.

Well went back and tried again. I will say the manager comped us entres for the burger experience. I didn't think it possible however I will not get returning. We ordered the free entree a couple drinks and side salads. There was a rotten lettuce core in my salad and immediately returned it and did not want another. After that my husband couldn't eat his either. Then the food finally showed up. There was some much pepper on my steak my mouth was on fire it was literally coated with salt and pepper. I returned it. My husband's double crunch shrimp was not crunchy it was very soft and flexible and not golden at all. They brought me another steak. I ate it but it was so thin as in less than a 1/4 of an inch thick. To top it all off my husband ended up getting sick in the bathroom. Staff was fantastic however the cook needs to lay off the pepper. It was even all over my husband's fries and floppy shrimp“

“I just can’t get enough Cadillac burrito. Minus cream cheese. Extra jalapeño, coleslaw and spicy Kansas bbq.“