50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cotati

“Just went over to get a pizza. 4pm May 26 2026. Guy behind counter was working on one. Guess he didn’t like chatting or his job. Told him take his time…sat down to wait. Another woman and daughter came in and the pizza guy went right up to them and took care of their order first. Waved at him wondering what’s up and he just shrugged his shoulders. felt like age discrimination… I left.“

“I'm not a small pizza type of guy but I was for this. The flavor the dough the freshness of the ingredients the way it was cooked was perfect I've been to similar places like this elsewhere and they always let me down but not Slow co. Pizza thanks guys I'll be back.“

“We LOVE Sal’s. Excellent pizza and calzones. My daughter and I walk often and always grab two slices for the rest of the way home. Pure deliciousness! The staff and owner are wonderful, courteous, caring people. If you are going to get pizza in Cotati or Rohnert Park this is the place to go! New York style, thin but the crust stays the right amount of crispy and the end crust is a delightful perfect finish!“

“Great spot to hang out, they now have a pool table and pin ball machines. Nice outdoor seating. Service is impeccable and their pies are so good. One of my favs is the Detroit Style pineapple jalapeño offering. I know, pie enthusiasts frown upon pineapple on pizza, well I happen to love it and this combo is bomb. The arugula salad is also a must.“

“Ordered a bbq chx pizza good thing I checked it before I left apparently when it was going to the oven it got some bubbles and there was four pieces that didn't have any toppings on them because the bubbles were so big and all the toppings went off. I figured either they would offer me a discount or offer to make me another Pizza they didn't either and the guy just handed me my change. But I'm not going out like that, I asked to have another pizza made and they did this one looked much better anyway. The taste on the pizza was very bland. We also ordered boneless chicken garlic parmesan and barbecue and all they did was drizzle the sauce over the top and it was minimal at that also tasted very bland. Too many pizza places around to serve bad stuff and have bad service and we will not be going back.“

“Outstanding pizza!! Sonoma county needed this!“

“Great pizza place with an awesome owner.

I ordered a hawaiian pizza and they were out of ham. Had a disagreement with the employee, and left without buying a pizza.

The next day, they called, apologized for the miscommunication and made things right.

I’m happy they made things right, and I’ll definitely order from them in the future!!!“

“I have been going to hectors pizza for about 30 years now recipe workers everybody there are still the same will continue being my favorite pizza“

“Best pizza I’ve had in Sonoma County.“

“had meatballs. garlic knots. salad. wings and pizza. everyone loved each item. wow. its new in petaluma next to whole foods“

“definitely unprofessional not ok to tell a customer that even though the person taking your order over the phone messed up your order then you call then rude employee female at 6:30 pm answer the phone saying they can resend it out but charge me delivery fee again which is not ok or how it works I worked for domino's for a few years now and we don't do bussiness like that at all its unprofessional to lie to a customer then when the customer ask for a manger you don't put them on hold for 15 minutes and you over hear the person on the phone say just great saying not professional things about the customer completely rude and employee needs written up an reprimanded for this type of behavior but the manager is going to make it right but no customer should ever have to wait 45 minutes more to get there correct order completely not ok hopefully the GM and the district manager will look into the store off bear valley in apple valley to train there employees in proper procedures and professional way to handle customer service we order all the time never have these type of issues very disappointed“

“Some of the best thin crust pizza I've ever had. Try the Bada Bing; it's not too spicy and not too sweet, the sausage chunks aren't overcooked at all, and whatever seasoning they throw on is perfect. Bring friends (or a lover, like my sweetie did), buy drinks, and enjoy the vibes. Two hungry adults can finish a twelve inch, so I'd guess a ten inch would be a solid solo meal.“

“Loved the vibe, GSW on the tube, best thin and crunchy slice of sausage pizza I've had in a very long time! Good guys working the joint and a family feel good local old school authentic place you just want to hang at and support. Loved it.“

“5 star review great service Madeline“

“absolutely the best pizza around this area. Great food, nice people, a great combo.“

“Great service. Great food. We will be back. Please put braised short ribs back on the menu.“

“Hubby and I love the Pizza. The Pizza was huge, yummy, and it's not greasy. We will come back again soon.“

“I come here every so often on lunch and I must say it has been a pleasant visit when eating here!! I want to give a special thanks to Roshil he is truly amazing and helpful!! I love this place and I highly recommend you come and eat here :)“

“Such a cute local pizza place to eat at. The food and beers are delicious and reasonable, the atmosphere vibe is amazing. I would recommend visiting Sandy’s whether your dining in or taking it home. Such a great upbeat delicious pizza eating place. Support local and check them out. The owners are a wonderful family too. ❤️“

“excellent quality food, ingredients & affordable prices! best lasagna i ate since my mom made it when i was a kid 😋 2nd try was a tri-tip sandwich & it was excellent!!! our new favorite place!“

“Great creative pizza types!! Order and then get it delivered so you can enjoy the best pizza around. Check out that menu!!“

“I've been to The New Yorker pizza a few times now, they are always friendly and the food is great. I actually forgot my wallet there my first visit and they went above and beyond to get it returned to me, super awesome people. If you're looking for quality pizza and a pleasant experience, you won't be disappointed here.“

“Delicious sauce, amazing dough and fresh quality ingredients. Having been raised in Chicago, I am kind of a pizza snob. So when I say this is the best pizza I've had in my 30 yrs in Sonoma County, you should take notice. Brava!!“

“Mary’s Pizza Shack is an absolute gem! The happy hour here is unbeatable — great deals and a super welcoming atmosphere. The bar manager really stands out — friendly, knowledgeable, and always goes the extra mile to make you feel at home. The bourbon selection is seriously impressive, especially for a pizza spot. Perfect place to unwind, grab a great drink, and enjoy some solid food. Highly recommend!“

“This is a great place for lunch or dinner. Fresh ingredients in salads and pizza toppings. Friendly service. Lots of options which are inexpensive. The Petaluma Extreme Pizza is the best! 🍕“

“So fun watching the game with friends Service was good too 🏈😊“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Stefano’s is our go-to pizza spot in Petaluma. The food is always delicious & the staff is friendly. We’ve taken family here when they visit from out of town, and it’s always a hit—especially the slices.

It’s casual, quick, and consistent..which is exactly what you want in a neighborhood pizza place. Whether we’re picking up dinner or grabbing a table with the kids, Stefano’s never disappoints.

Support your local spots—this one’s a keeper. 🍕“

“We came here for lunch to try some vegan pies, and they definitely exceeded our expectations! I ordered the fungi pizza and the potato pie, and both were amazing. We almost finished them completely! The crust was wonderfully baked and definitely worth eating. They also made for great leftovers during the rest of our road trip. I'm sure their non-vegan pizzas are excellent too!“

“Food is incredible! Bacon Alfredo break sticks are insanely amazing.“

“Hubby and I love the Pizza. The Pizza was huge, yummy, and it's not greasy. We will come back again soon.“

“Fun for the kids! 🤩 Always clean and well maintained.“

“I love this Sebastopol location. Very quick and excellent pizzas. I usually order online so everything is ready when I pick up. My new favorite is the keto pizza, all the goodness of the pizza without the filling crust. That's right, carb free, gluten free deliciousness!“

“Ralph (the owner) is an absolutely wonderful human being. We grew up on Fergene’s and it’s my first meal in California every time we’re in town to see family. Specifically the Chipotle Chicken pizza,“

“The fig and prosciutto pizza was great. So was the lemoncello cocktail. The service was great too, except they forgot to honor my special occasion request to celebrate my sister's birthday. I didn't say anything because I wanted it to be a surprise, but the request was noted in my reservation. They apologized, said it was a computer glitch. We still had fun! Raphael, our server was a delight To top off the evening, we saw Thunder from Down Under show! That made our night!“

“I love Round Table pizza! The staff was so welcoming and helpful. I had placed an order for pick up; was told a reasonable amount of time for pick up. I ended up being late for pick up and the gal at the counter asked if I would like them to remake it fresh; which I did!! So nice of them to offer that. I will be back.“

“Love the bar tenders and appreciate them having this second job. I love the two rock pizza when it's open and appreciate the staff. Enjoy Wednesday's Trivia night and Thursday's kariokie night. Military cards or guest of one is required for entry. ?“

“THE BEST PIZZA!!!! LO🍕E!!!“

“If you want delicious pizza, friendly customer service & a chill environment: come here! I was greeted immediately and asked if I had any questions. I ordered what I wanted & said it was my first time and I was given a free huge cookie! It was home made chocolate chip with salt. So, so good. The rice crispy treats are good and if you’re a ranch person, their ranch is the best! I’m normally not a pizza fan but this place had me come back and order more for lunch tomorrow!“

“Fantastic pizza! Good value for the money. The service has always been friendly and accommodating. I love their pepperoni pizza! Its generously loaded with their own pepperoni. This is the kind that curves-up (cups up). Every time I come to Santa Rosa, CA I always make sure and visit this pizzeria for their pepperoni pizza. I highly recommend this restaurant.“

“The restaurant was a delight from the moment we walked through the door, it felt like we were in a pizzeria in Italy. The charming owner Ray was part of the amazing experience. We were only sat for a few minutes when he brought my daughter and some wine. The pizzas were out of this world. We had one with sausage and pepperoni and the other was devine was vegetarian with truffle oil, it was phenomenal. Everything about this restaurant was superb. The staff were great even though we had a grouchy 11 year old with us. The pizza even turned her frown upside down. If you happen to be in Santa Rosa and you want a slice of heaven I mean pizza, this is the place for you.“

“Yummy 🍕 and they let my pup sit with us“

“Pizza is so good. Best of both worlds. Chicken tikka masala on a pizza. 🍕 🔥🤤“

“Always good food and hot!“

“MODD Pizza is like the Picasso of pizzas—every slice is a masterpiece waiting to be devoured! With more toppings than you can shake a spatula at, it's a DIY dream come true. Warning: may induce extreme happiness and cravings for seconds.“

“Wish we could visit you more often but we live in Dixon (1 1/2 hrs. away) and we went to the fair today and chose your restaurant for lunch/dinner. Very nice interior, seated right away, and taken care of quickly. We want to give 5 star award to our server Eddiann. Hope I spelled that correctly. She was attentive, courteous, helpful, and went out of her way to make sure we had a great dining experience. She makes Mary's a great place. Definitely a keeper. Next time we're in Santa Rosa we'll know where to dine. Thank you!!“

“My GAH! The meatball sandwich. Add Pepperoni. I am ridiculously full. And it was amazing. 11/10 would recommend. The wait staff is top notch as well.“

“This was the best service and most delicious pizza we have enjoyed in a long time!! So good!!“

“Kyle at Farmer's: Thank you for going Above and Beyond for this weary Gramma and her 2 disappointment little grandsons. You know what you did, and what you did brightened the day for us all! Excellent and wonderfully empathetic employee- Highly Recommend!!!♡♡♡“

“This is the best Mountain Mikes location!Been coming here since I was about 8 years old, and the staff has changed but the food is still amazing. They even have kept the gaming room section.The last time I came in, I ordered a half Snowy Alps and half cheese and extra pineapple.It was a busy night, but I got my pizza promptly. After getting in my car I opened to sneak a slice, and it didn’t have extra pineapple, it had pineapple and pepperoni. I called immediately and the staff was AMAZING! I can’t stress that enough. Not only did she remake the entire pizza, while I waited she told me to just keep the second one, then the owner came out and apologized, handed me a free soda and 2 more large ranches. I was really taken back by the level of amazing customer service they provided. And the pizza was delicious! So perfect, this place is hard to beat!!Thanks again guys for making my night and correcting the item!! ♥️?

Vegetarian options: Can get anything veg

Kid-friendliness: Great game area and kid friendly restaurant“

“Pizza was a little undercooked a little doughy just put it in the oven for a while and it was fine there is no atmosphere It's just a counter And I pulled it out of a locked oven with a code so there was no service I gave myself my service I guess I would say yeah it was great service I did it myself lol“