5 Best Italian Restaurants in Ojai

“Our first time here, this place has been on our list for over a year and the timing finally lined up for us to check it out. The place is quaint and elegant. Our server, Anthony, was very attentive and had a great recommendation for the roasted beet ravioli. We split a salad, a soup and a pasta which they plated separately for us and did not charge us a split plate fee. I was pleased with each dish. They were pretty spaced out and if we hadn’t needed to catch our movie after, we would have felt more relaxed to stay. All in all it was a lovely experience and we will be back to try the spaghetti!“

“We celebrated my wife's birthday at Olivella, and it was truly unforgettable. From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel special—warm, attentive, and perfectly timed in their service. The ambiance was elegant yet relaxed, perfect for a romantic evening. Every course was exceptional: the pasta was handmade and perfectly cooked, the wine pairing was spot-on, and the dessert was a beautiful surprise that made my wife smile ear to ear. It felt like the kind of place where every detail is crafted with care. Olivella made a special night feel even more magical—absolutely worth every moment.“

“Great atmosphere inside and on patio. Excellent food. We had the house salad, two pizzas, and Gelato. All WERE EXCELLENT! Staff was friendly and helpful. We thoroughly enjoyed our visit and highly recommend it. Chain pizza restaurants don't compare!“

“Highly recommend!!!! The food is amazing!!! The calamari with polenta is absolutely to die for!! I had the most amazing fettuccine cognac w/ filet & mushrooms also recommend the tiramisu 5 star!!!!!“

“Love the strawberry shortcake.“