35 Best Italian Restaurants near Newbury Park

“Been coming here since 2022, then it was sold and another owner called it “Gemma”? It was sold again and back to the great food and vibe. Ronaldo is exceptional at making his patrons comfortable and the staff is attentive. Great to hear the Local Table is back.“

“We had Spumoni take away for dinner and it was awesome! If I closed my eyes you could convince me I was actually sitting in a fancy Italian restaurant. It was incredible! The super family meal was enough to feed our family of four and then some! I highly recommend the chicken piccata!“

“Interesting Italian Restaurant owned by two brothers.
It was a Saturday night and they were very busy.
Food took an hour to arrive with the exception of a tasty Caesar Salad.
Two Eggplant Parmesan’s were ordered which were rich in flavor.
The Linguini and Clams were very flavorful and had a decent amount of Clams.
For Dessert we ordered the cake with ice cream and it was a little dry.
The Pear with White Chocolate was ok.
Next time I would order it with the Chocolate sauce.
Food quality overall was wonderful and will go back soon to dine again but not on a Saturday night.“

“So far the best authentic Italian pizza I have had in 10 years living in USA. And I am Italian so that says enough! Everything was perfect. High quality food. Forza ragazzi 🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹“

“I was starting to miss the flavors of home after weeks of eating American food. Luckily, my friend @Massimiliano Russomanno knew just the place to take me. Antonio Sessa's Made in Italy was a delightful surprise. Every bite transported me back to Italy. The food was prepared with such care and passion that it was clear this Italian Chef had a truly deep love for our cuisine. If you're craving authentic Italian food, I highly recommend giving this place a try 🥰🥰👍🏻🫶🙌🏻🙌🏻“

“From the moment we arrived, the experience was exceptional. The atmosphere was elegant and inviting, with beautiful decor and just the right level of ambiance for a relaxing evening.

Every dish was beautifully presented and prepared to perfection, with outstanding flavors.

This restaurant truly delivers first-class service, exquisite cuisine, and a sophisticated atmosphere. We have already returned. We highly recommend this place whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for an outstanding meal and excellent service.“

“We celebrated my mom’s 90 th birthday last night at Ottavios. We have had prior celebrations in the past, 44 years ago we had our Wedding Rehearsal dinner there ! The back private room is so nice to have a dinner party! We were allowed to arrive early and decorate. All the staff were very attentive and friendly! The food was delicious and huge portions! The service was excellent! I highly recommend Ottavios if you are looking for the perfect dinner party location!“

“This restaurant surprised me, fun vibrant atmosphere suitable for adults... not for little kids. Full bar, experienced bartenders who have been working here for years. Food was delicious and well thought out. Parking was easy and plentiful.“

“Friendly people, amazing food. Very nice to their musicians. 🙏🎶“

“Good food and nice people.“

“Thanks for supporting our non profit and having affordable food for our family.“

“Food is excellent - pricey but well worth the money. Overall service also excellent as you’d expect from a fine dining restaurant. Servers very attentive and courses are perfectly paced. We loved that it was fine dining but provided both an elegant atmosphere indoors and a more casual atmosphere out on the patio. The bruschetta and fried calamari appetizers were fantastic. So was the Chicken Marssla w/mash and Grilled Salmon w/risotto. But the Grilled Rack of Lamb w/mash and the Chilean Bass w/risotto were just unbelievable!! We will definitely go back!“

“Great food and drinks. Service was awesome.“

“Great food and really nice atmosphere. Family owned restaurant.“

“Marcello Ristorante offers a wonderful dining experience with authentic flavors, attentive service, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. From the moment I arrived, I felt welcomed by the friendly and professional staff. The food was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented, with every dish showcasing quality ingredients and careful preparation. The atmosphere was elegant yet comfortable, making it an excellent choice for both casual dinners and special occasions. I appreciated the attention to detail throughout the entire experience, from the service to the presentation of each meal. Everything exceeded my expectations, and the overall hospitality made the visit truly memorable. I would highly recommend Marcello Ristorante and look forward to dining here again in the future.“

“i dont even know where to begin with this place, we stumbled in on a total whim and honestly it was one of those nights where everything just clicked. tried the veal piccata and it was so tender, the sauce had that perfect lemony capers taste that i alwasy crave but could never replicate at home. the service was great too, our waitress was super chill and didnt hover but somehow always showed up right when we needed a refill on drinks. my friend got the pasta and the plate was completely clean by the time we paid, she couldnt stop talking about it. the whole vibe inside felt really cozy but not cramped, like somehow it was exactly the right balance. would definately go back again next time im in agoura, no question about it. honestly i havent felt that happy leaving a restaurant in a while.“

“Four of us went to Tuscany for dinner on Friday night. Made a reservation for 6pm and sat outside. The weather was perfect, the staff was super friendly and the food was great.“

“The food was delicious, service by Danielle was fabulous. No rush just plenty of time to total enjoy our food. The food cook by Eddie was more them delicious it's was fabulous.
Thank you all for a special night out just to enjoy good meal and great company with my huddy. ❤️“

“I placed a very large order with short notice to Ameci. Wildfires displaced our crews and I was really looking for a place to be able to buy everyone (30 +) lunch. Everything came out not only on time but with smiles and the pizza was to die for. Couldn't have asked for better!“

“A group of 4 friends went to have dinner Sunday July 12th in the Olive garden in Camarillo. Our waiter went over and beyond in helping getting our food kept checking up on us. Great attitude and very friendly. From ordering our drinks to getting our food plus we ordered food to go , no problem. I did not get his name we will be back for sure.“

“Had the greatest time. Not a huge wine fan but their options are so vast and a very knowledgeable sommelier. A wine for every person. The entire spectrum from white to red and every shade in between. I loved the place.“

“A++++ FOOD AND STAFF ARE GREAT!!!! -ROANESYMON“

“Very friendly and great service. Sandwiches are so tasty, my favorites the #2! Will always recommend friends and family 😁“

“Talk about authentic Italian deserts! I spent more on desert than dinner. The food - service - atmosphere and entertainment were all amazing. Can’t recommend this place enough!“

“Great vibe fantastic pizza and the best antipasto salad 😁 keto lovers they offer cauliflower crust we are trying next“

“Food was reasonable fresh & good just got a sub glad I went here !! Better service & fast then subway which next door !! Looked at menu everything was looking good“

“Absolutely delicious pizza! Different styles of pizza are available. I look forward to trying them all. Nice restaurant. Casual and comfortable.“

“quick hot and tasty was my slice! enjoyed i a lot thx Tony's“

“Great experience. Will definitely bring my kids and all visitors here“

“Breakfast at Tony’s is so good! We had eggs Benedict with the home fried potatoes and the eggs Florentine with hash browns. Both were delicious. The Benedict sauce was so good with a hint of sweet, maybe from the ham ? The potatoes were so good and done perfectly with onions and peppers. A perfect combination. Eggs Florentine with hash browns didn’t disappoint either. Both meals were yummy. I highly recommend Tony’s .“

“i’ve been coming here for the past two months. I love New York style pizza. I was very impressed with their thin crust pizza. Highly recommended if you’d like back east type of pizza The actual establishment is very nice inside great music and they have two TVs with sports and news“

“The best Pizza in town! I highly recommend!“

“Absolutely amazing experience at Greco’s Pizza! The moment I walked in the door, Ricardo and his wife welcomed me with the warmest, most genuine hospitality. You can instantly tell this is a family-owned spot run by an authentic Italian family, and that makes all the difference. The place is super clean, well-kept, and gives off those classic neighborhood pizzeria vibes.

Now the pizza… WOW. Freshly made, full of flavor, and everything you'd hope for in authentic New York-style Italian pizza. You can’t go wrong here. The crust, the sauce, the cheese—it’s all on point. I left full, happy, and already thinking about my next visit.

Highly, highly recommend!“

“great service good food & portions“

“I’ve been visiting Mediterraneo as long as it has been open. It is one of my all-time favorite restaurants based on service, amazing menu, quality food, decor, atmosphere, and of course the dessert & bar. Truly perfect for everything from a business meeting, family gathering, or romantic date night. All- around phenomenal-I rate 5-stars. DianeBrewer“