14 Best Ice Cream Shops in Petaluma

“Crumbl Cookies Petaluma has quickly become our family’s go-to spot for those special moments that deserve something extra sweet. What sets this place apart isn’t just the incredible rotating menu of gourmet cookies it’s the genuine warmth you feel the moment you walk in. The staff here treats every customer like they’re picking out cookies for their own family. They’re patient with indecisive kids, generous with samples, and always happy to explain what makes each week’s flavors special. Last visit, they even helped my daughter choose the perfect birthday surprise cookies for her teacher. The cookies themselves are works of art thick, soft, and loaded with quality ingredients you can actually taste. Whether it’s their classic chocolate chip (which somehow tastes like childhood perfected) or one of their creative weekly specials, each bite feels like a small celebration. The pink boxes have become a symbol of good news in our house!“

“Super fun location in the Alley! It was busy, but from order to received item was maybe 5 minutes. Soft serve was ok. We got a slush shake and it was good. There’s a lot to read on the menu and it all scrunched up on a board. Had different things you could add to your slush.“

“pretty tasty !!! got try it“

“Yesterday my family had Mariapalar ice cream at an event, and it was absolutely delicious! I love the berries and cream bar! My Husband and son loved their Chocolate Dipped PB and Chocolate dipped vanilla. And we heard rave reviews from others at the event about the Peaches and Cream, Chocolate dipped mint and Cherry Lime. Can wait to try more!“

“Visited the Creamery stand at the Phoenix Uptown Farmer's market, and they gave me the last chunk of sample pepper jack for free since they'd sold out. So thoughtful! The cheese is delicious. I highly recommend.“

“I’ve been here twice now, and can’t get enough! I tried the minty chocolate ice cream that they had, can’t remember the name and it was delicious. But my absolute favorite was the lavender ice cream with the gluten-free waffle cone. I do not have a gluten intolerance, but I ordered it because the waffle cone was cinnamon flavored and it was amazing.“

“I really like this place. There aren't a lot of options because the store is so small, but they have good Mexican street food, ice cream, candy, and occasionally baked goods. Don't take my less-than-5-stars rating as a negative. I'm very hard to please and I still recommend coming here.“

“Best location with excellent coffee drinks.“

“We ordered coconut, bubblegum, strawberry cheesecake, pistachio, and rose petal.

The coconut and pistachio tasted really natural. The coconut had a lot of chunks and wasn’t too heavy or too light, just the right amount of sweetness. The pistachio looked a bit too bright at first so I was worried it might taste artificial, but it actually had a lot of real pieces and didn’t taste fake at all.

For the rose petal, I’ve had similar flavors at other places that ended up tasting like soap or even fabric softener. This one actually tasted like rose in a good way. It was light and really well balanced.

The strawberry cheesecake tasted exactly like what you would expect, in a good way. It’s sweet since it’s cheesecake, and the strawberry part tasted like jam. It is a little on the sweeter side, but not to the point where it’s overwhelming.

The bubblegum flavor is definitely artificial, but that’s kind of expected. It’s bright blue and the flavor is really strong. What surprised me was that there are actual pieces of pink gum inside, so you end up chewing gum while eating the ice cream. It was a really unique experience. Also cone is not too bad but not too good. Just mid lol

Overall, I didn’t have high expectations but everything tasted great. The only reason I’m giving 4 stars instead of 5 is because the staff didn’t seem very friendly. There was no line and I didn’t take long to decide, but the overall vibe felt a bit unwelcoming. Hope they’re having a better day next time. Next time I’ll probably just use the kiosk :)“

“Bella is amazing! She's fast, polite and very efficient! I was amazed just watching her service the customer, clean the store, make pick-up orders and basically run the entire store by herself. If I had a company, I would hire her in a second!“

“One of the best features of having moved to Las Vegas is actually being able to get these Strauss products: the chocolate milk, milk, Greek yogurt and kefir, are incredibly delicious. I find them at both sprouts and whole foods grocery stores. I also appreciated that they use glass jars for their milk and kefir products, so we put less plastic into our environment. Thank you for making such wonderful quality products!“

“My son loved his birthday cake!!!“

“Kids loved a lot of flavors“