18 Best Ice Cream Shops near Forestville

“We love the handmade ice cream sandwich. Two vegan cookies—chocolate chip seems to be the standard flavor—with your choice of vegan ice cream. The portion is BIG. Forestville itself is a hidden gem. Ample seating inside and outside. Updated from previous review on 2026-09-19“

“The nicest ice cream scoopers ever!! We tried all the ice cream spots around Central Healdsburg and this is the best. So many nice flavors and flavor combos…..plus they’ll do a split scoop so that you can enjoy two flavors. Several great vegan flavors and not just sorbet.“

“a lot variety of delicious and autentic mexican ice cream flavors“

“This is the very best ice cream I’ve ever had! ❤️“

“Best yogurt store ever. We love this place. They always have multiple flavors and lots of toppings. The peanut butter flavor is to die for, You are greeted so sweetly as you come in the door, Emily is so sweet and helpful. This is our go to every week.“

“I am a huge ice cream lover and evaluator. The quality of ice cream here is incredible! It was extremely cold and melted in your mouth! Other places (even Salt n Straw), make it too creamy and sugary. You really don’t get better ice cream than Nimble and Finn’s. I had the vanilla, coffee single scoop split. I savored every drop and will be back next summer to bask in the deliciousness.“

“The service was good, the flavor was phenomenal, the texture was a bit off like it had ice crystals formed in it--not very creamy, and the atmosphere was... well, bougie tourist town, what do you expect? The price is absolutely absurd. I paid $7 for a single small scoop in a cone so bland and stale that I felt like I was eating a paper cup and wished I had just asked for one instead of having to keep biting through the gross waffle. I had the bourbon plum ice cream and I'd highly recommend that flavor if you want to try this place out.“

“Yummy toppings and nice staff“

“Yes, I recommend Screamin’ Mimi’s, but after today’s visit I may need a new neck. SM’s has always had at least 2 easy-to-read menus viewable, at least one inside and one outside. Not now. Now the ice cream flavors are on just one electronic screen right by the cash register and it’s really high. As in Really HIGH. Lots of small print. I was wondering what kind of neck damage I was incurring while trying to read the menu. The group behind me had some little kids and the adults were having a hard time trying to read and translate (what’s lavender?) the list to them. Or, if you prefer a QR code, it’s also right next to the cash register. Don’t forget your phone! In other words, everyone who hasn’t seen today’s menu before they arrive will be stuck trying to figure out their order while standing next to the cash register, peering at a complex menu, creating a traffic jam and longer line. Please, Mimi’s, don’t have the list so high and don’t put it just before the cash register.“

“I love the ice cream it was so good I love it“

“Yummy toppings and nice staff“

“I had the pleasure of visiting Colores Juice and Ice Cream Shop, and I must say it was a delightful experience from start to finish. This charming establishment has quickly become my go-to spot for refreshing and delicious treats.First and foremost, their selection of juices is outstanding. I couldn't get enough of their carrot and mango juice, which was the perfect blend of sweet and tangy. The green juice was equally refreshing and packed with nutritious goodness. Whether you're a health-conscious individual or simply looking for a tasty way to quench your thirst, Colores has you covered with their fantastic juice offerings. But what truly sets Colores apart is their exotic ice cream selection. They offer a wide range of flavors that you won't find at your typical ice cream shop. From unique tropical options to classic favorites, there's something for everyone.“

“Delicious and aleays fresh“

“La nieve y paletas 💯 lo máximo 🙏🙏🙏“

“Love this spot for ice cream — local flavors, they mix it up seasonally and great quality, creamy stuff. Superb toppings bar and yes, they make a Choco Taco!

The product is made with liquid nitrogen for added smoothness, and I am partial to the berry/crisp/cookies/cream flavors, but Smores, Thai Tea, Vanilla and variations on chocolate get high marks with our crew.

Friendly staff — quality operation!“

“Their Breakfast sandwich was to die for Yum and ruegela cookies awesome“