50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sierra Madre

“I got a slice of the NY style pepperoni and sausage. It was warmed up perfectly! The crust was crispy, but not hard. The pepperoni has some spice to it and the sauce had a pinch of sweetness.

My husband got a slice of Detroit style pizza. It could have been warmed up longer as the cheese wasn't melted except for the edges. He said the crust was really good“

“Located in downtown Sierra Madre, Sierra Madre Pizza co serves a wide array of various pizzas and toppings and assorted other items as well as offering lunch pizza slice specials parking can be found in the back in the front of the location or you can park in the public parking lot and walk across the street, some of the best pizza I've had.“

“Last night, someone dropped off a bunch of pizza at the food pantry in Eagle Rock, which serves lots of people in the area. I managed to snag a couple of slices while making a dropoff and cleaning the community fridge. I wanted to first say THANK YOU, but perhaps more to the point, I am a pizza snob and even free pizza won't win me over if it's not good. This was shockingly great pizza. Simple, flavorful, the right amount of everything and reminds me of home (a large pizza loving city back east). So even though your generous deed wasn't wasn't intended as a promotion, I will absolutely be a new customer of your store. Thanks again! Delicious (even cold)! Please come back every friday night ;)“

“Always good food. Always a good time.“

“We moved here from New York and we LOVE this pizza! It's taken 8 years to find good pizza in LA and we found it in Pasadena. The crust is out of this world and the ingredients are high quality. The sides, including the salad are not only delicious, but they're made with great care. My husband and I feel honored to be there customers.“

“I had a great experience with this place .i had a party so i made a order a day before and had to pick up at 1pm i showed up and it was ready on time plus still hot and fresh. I highly recommend this place the taste is great and the sizes are perfect for partys also they design your pizza my son was pleased . Thanks Tiger you were awesome“

“We came in very close to closing time. The staff was very polite, friendly and quick with service. We really appreciated it, especially since we came after Disneyland. The kids wanted to eat pizza for dinner and we got the drive over with to eat closer to home. Because of closed lanes on the freeway, we barely made it in time. I am so grateful that the staff was not frustrated or rude in any way. It was very much appreciated.“

“This Shakey’s in Alhambra is one of the best they provide great customer service their food is always fresh they have big tvs to watch the games I enjoy going when dodger’s are playing because I get to enjoy a beer“

“Bball Team banquet held there“

“NO WORDS TO DESCRIBE THIS PLACE!!
YES THIS PIZZA IS THE BEST , WE CAME FROM LOS ANGELES FOR AN APPOITMENT AS WE WERE WALKING BY
THE KITCHEN COOKER SAID COME ON IN GUYS WE HAVE PIZZA BY THE SLICE , WE BOUGH 4 SLICES , NO ARTIFICIAL FLAVORS ON IT SOOO YUMIII OF COURSE WERE COMING BACK !!
KEEP WORKING LIKE THAT WITH NO ARTIFICIAL FLAVORS —— MY 1ST PLIZZA PLACE NOW !!“

“I wanted to take a moment to recognize the exceptional customer service provided by Miles during my recent visit. He went above and beyond to ensure everything was fresh and always made sure we had exactly what we needed. Miles took the time to explain each pizza as it came out during the lunch buffet, which added a personal touch to the experience. When I asked if he was the manager, he humbly mentioned that he wasn’t, which only further highlighted how dedicated he is to his role. It’s clear that he takes great pride in delivering excellent service. I hope the team sees this review because Miles truly deserves recognition for his outstanding work. I always enjoy visiting this location, and I’m looking forward to my next visit, hoping to see him there again!“

“Omg! The lemon pepper boneless wings are to die for! So delights they are addicting, yummy, great service and affordable“

“I love this place. The pizza is super yummy: plenty of toppings, fresh veggies, nice crisp crust. And the service is nice and fast.“

“the food its just delicious.“

“Great food and drinks. Nice and clean restaurant with friendly staff and fast-service.

Con: Small parking lot and limited menu

Pros: Delicious food and drinks. The adult Arnold Palmer was the best, the chicken pesto pizza, the chicken buffalo bites are a must-try.“

“The pizza is so good!! And they have great family specials 😃“

“been going to Rios for years best pizza in town 🥰🤗😁😎“

“I’ve been to the DTLA Arts District location so many times, so I was shocked (in the best way) to discover this one so close to home. The space is modern, clean, and has a cool vibe — though I still lean toward the unique Arts District atmosphere. What really stands out is the pizza: same incredible quality as DTLA. Blindfold me and I wouldn’t be able to tell the difference.

The only thing to keep in mind is that pizza by the slice can add up — if you’re thinking of grabbing more than two, a fresh pie might be the smarter move. Either way, I’m thrilled to have another amazing spot nearby!“

“wish that they would come to Kentucky“

“First time visiting. Ordered a round Pepperoni. 1/2 hour wait. Smelled good. Crust was very good. Barely had enough cheese. Could use more. A little on the pricey side. Would order again.“

“Very good food , friendly and attentive waiters especially Antonio and Claude thank you for your hospitality“

“I've been coming to the shakeys since I was a little girl..I am now forty eight years old.And I still come here because I enjoy the food.The atmosphere and it feels like home to me.Because I grew up in this city, and this was the shakeys i came to always. Today's visit was extra special, Valerie who works there made sure we had clean plates and welcomed us upon arrival.“

“Best pizza in town 🍕😍😋 Kids love it ❤️“

“I love the food my favorite is the linguine clams which is made with a white wine sauce but you can ask for red if you desire. Everywhere you go now a days is expensive but at least portions are large and shareable. It surprises me to read the reviews and see that people enjoyed the Tyson frozen wings they use to serve at Vittoria’s for years. I also would like to note that I love the antipasto salad and it doesn’t have only one meat as I read on one of the reviews.Also everywhere that has delivery service charges more when ordered on the app. Update: they are no longer charging for water. I can say that yes they are short staffed sometimes as well as many other restaurants have been ever since COVID. I really love the service and I will continue to be a customer for many years!! It always amazes me that people can’t see when it’s busy and aren’t understanding.“

“Alitalia Pizza is literally the only place we pick up pizza! The crust is delicious as is their sauce and fresh ingredients, definitely different than your average pizza. They also have many other options and we often order a salad on the side. Their salads are large and always, consistently fresh. They don’t cut corners and the owners and staff could not be more accommodating and delightful! Great local business to support and a hidden gem if you have not tried it!“

“Just wanted to say I enjoyed our time at Pizza Guys the Staff were very pleasant and accommodating. We were visiting from down the street at the rehab. Took our buddy to grab a bite to eat. Had a Blast Racing him up the street in his Wheely Chair. Lol
We Love you Eric“

“Best pizza in town 🍕😍😋 Kids love it ❤️“

“We recently ordered from Brooklyn Square Pizza in Pasadena, and it was a great experience from start to finish. The pizza arrived fresh, hot, and clearly made with quality ingredients. The square slices were perfectly baked with a crisp, flavorful crust and just the right balance of sauce and cheese.

We also ordered two of their hot sandwiches, and they were a big hit—packed with flavor, generously portioned, and just as fresh and satisfying as the pizza.

You can really taste the classic New York–style influence, and the portions were generous—great for sharing. Everything was well packaged and arrived on time, which made ordering easy and stress‑free.

If you’re looking for delicious, hearty pizza with authentic flavor in Pasadena, Brooklyn Square Pizza is definitely worth checking out. We’ll absolutely be ordering again.“

“I was welcomed by several friendly women. I ordered two of the stuffed crust and some bread sticks. They have readily made pizza but the specialty pizza takes around 20 minutes or so. Excellent service and low wait times. My parents and I loved the food. Prices are decent too.“

“Very clean, bright and stylish newly renovated banquet hall ideal for different types of parties and gatherings. Great attention to detail with ample parking across the street.“

“Had a great experience at Blaze Pizza. The pizza was delicious and they added all the toppings exactly how I wanted. I asked for it well done and it was cooked perfectly to my liking. The restaurant was also very clean and fully stocked with condiments. Definitely coming back!“

“The food was FABULOUS!!!!! Will definitely 👍 be going back for more!!!!!“

“Everything was good!! Service, food and wine!“

“Great New York-style pizza by the slice, always with a crispy crust. There is counter service, and a few tables outside along a narrow walkway shared with Jones Coffee. You can bring your dog here, but given the tight space, he needs to be really well trained.“

“Address is on Arrow Hwy not Lark Ellen Ave. Arrow Hwy and Azusa Ave. 942 w. Arrow Hwy.“

“I recently realized that I was wrongly taking my business to the wrong place (little cesars pizza), cause last week I went to cesar pizza place and it was a waiting time for more than an hour to get one pizza that I think is over rate, so I remember that my son told me about this very good place (JC's pizza) so we tried them and is a no brainer, really good pizza, actually awsome pizza, better price than the other place and fast service, my new pizza spot.“

“We ordered takeout and decided to do half a pizza of ROASTED MUSHROOM AND SHALLOT + half of SAUSAGE, ROASTED FENNEL & FONTINA.

The pizzas are pricey compared to the major chains, but do note that they do give you plenty of toppings on your pizzas and it's not a sprinkle only.

The roasted mushrooms one had plenty of mushrooms and it was delicious.

The sausage and fennel one had plenty of fennel but not much sausage though.

Service was fairly fast and is a very casual takeout experience. I'd definitely go back for the mushroom pizza.“

“First thing is I might be very lucky, only times I have ever been here it’s little to no line & the employees are ALWAYS working behind the scenes .. today I got Fany ! She is so pretty & friendly, I’ve been to other blazes & they make your pizza sloppy & just thrown together .. Fany made me a beautiful pizza with the perfect amount of toppings & that really turned this transaction into an experience, I’m leaving knowing I will enjoy every bite because Fany cared about my meal. Thank you Fany & thank you blaze team for always being amazing !“

“This place is the best in town good customer service always hot always on time and good prices. I’m a loyal customer and I would never go anywhere else.“

“The best Hoagie on the planet, an the owner and staff are excellent“

“Pizza is so good !! Love the $5 meal really comes in clutch when you want something small. Love the the saucy Buffalo wings so meaty yum. Service is fast and the atmosphere is old school which is cool. This place is now my go to place for pizza and meaty wings!“

“Joey is super friendly and helpful!“

“BEST PIZZA IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA“

“Pizza was fantastic!!! Rivaled Chicago!“

“Excellent customer service and food!“

“Great food at good prices“

“Quick service good pizza & chicken“

“great food, great service, very clean. And spacious. Our family hangout“

“We had a slice of pizza, Caesar salads, and pastas. Everything was AMAZING! Can’t wait to bring everyone I know!“

“this place is on point!!!!“