43 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bethlehem

“Fast and friendly service large portions and the margarita was perfect! We will be back!“

“awesome in every way. People are awesome. food is always top notch“

“excellent pie, right up there with the New Haven bests.“

“We happened to be driving through and stopped for lunch. We were so glad that we did. Great chicken cutlet sandwich. Awesome chicken piccata. But we would come back for the soup alone. The Mona Lisa soup is hands down the best soup I have had out at a restaurant. It’s chicken, rice, spinach, lemon and some magical seasonings..with homemade croutons and sliced lemon on the side. Absolutely delicious. We ordered more to take home. Our server was friendly and helpful and really knew the menu. She was great. We will definitely back.“

“tired Anthony’s for the first time tonight and OMG what a great place! from the atmosphere to the food it was hands down the best! our waitress was amazing and the food was GREAT! highly recommend! 10/10!“

“This place is a diamond in the rough…. The Gibson sauce is to die for. I really really enjoyed our dinner ….. it’s my new favorite pizza place in CT - wow wow wow 10 stars - I’m in love !!!“

“Food was amazing. I tried the “Mamo” it was so good! The environment was great. Definitely recommend Fino to anyone in the area!“

“Great family owned and run pizza place.. Teryaki chicken Grinder is the best.. great menu options..“

“Great pizza one of the best in town“

“We love Litchfield Pizza. We think nothing of driving from Watertown to get take out! Their pizza is truly New York style delicious pizza! Their dinners are absolutely delicious and specials are definitely special! Don’t miss this place! You’ll be glad you tried it!“

“Consistently delicious pizza and very friendly staff. I order about once a week and am always happy with the food. The pizza is crispy, chewy and has just the right amount of sauce and cheese. I love the garlic knots too. Its the best pizza in the area hands down.“

“Great Pizza“

“I think my husband and I found our new go to restaurant. Food is delicious, tried the pizza last night will definitely order another pizza My husband tried the Philly Cheesesteak said best cheesesteak he has ever eaten.“

“Tried their pizza tonight and it is by far the best pizza I have had in a long time. We had the pup in the car for pickup and they even brought it out to us with plates and napkins. The ingredients tasted so fresh and homemade. We will make the trip from Watertown from now on to go here. Great job to all who work here and own this restaurant!“

“only place in Thomaston I will order from. only place in town that has slices also. the food is fantastic, I've never been disappointed and I've been ordering from there for 20+ years.“

“You can’t beat them, local, great food and fast.“

“We live in Oakville and we have been getting our take out from Paradise for over 15 years. We just love everything there. We are never disappointed. They have saved us on many occasions with their party pizza, which is so reasonably priced. My kids would always have a lot of friends over, we can feed everyone and not break the bank. Dave and his staff are so friendly. We are actually on a first name basis because I am in there so often. The delivery drivers are awesome. If you haven't tried their food, please do.“

“If I choose to dine in or take out the experiences the same; Enjoyable from beginning to end. A lot of people like to write reviews after their perturbed with service and management refuses to make it right however I like to praise businesses when they're doing great and focus on the positive. Sometimes I like to eat alone so I'll get a medium pie and ask for it well done. It's consistent every time“

“Great food service and extremely reasonable prices. I got corned beef dinner and my husband got a pizza. Left overs for days. our bill was less than 50.00. it's cheaper than making it at home.“

“The absolute best!! Consistantly awesome!“

“A great local pub and craft beer spot with a fantastic selection, and good prices!“

“Best pizza I have had besides New York pizza! Staff awesome!“

“Stopped in last night. A wonderful vibe at the bar. Made some new friends. The bartender was great. Very friendly. The pizza was excellent! We will be back.“

“They have a great staff which makes the food even better tasting I've been coming here since they oppened and have never had anything on the menu that wasn't excellent !!!!! 10/10 in my book. Update 24Jul25, ordered a pizza for delivery. It wasn't anywhere near what it used to be when they 1st opened!! Maybe staff or owners have changed, I don't know but it wasn't what I remember it being. Crust was a bit hard and it had an Oily Glaze on the cheese!? I thought it would have been much better?“

“I'm so glad we stopped here. Wonderful staff, delicious food, and it was all decently cheap. My family would definitely come back.“

“Very Friendly! Not Expensive At All! Quick Delivery! Oh, and BEST STROMBOLI IN TOWN!!! HIGHLY Recommend!!!“

“I’ve eaten their pizza since they opened. Best pizza I’ve ever eaten in my life! in fact, it’s the only pizza that I would eat! Highly recommended and you get a ton of pizza for your money :-)“

“Bantam Pizza is a beautiful place with a very warm atmosphere. The pizza is delicious, you can really taste the quality and flavor. I especially want to highlight Linda’s service she was so kind and caring, which made the whole experience even more special. I’ll definitely be coming back!! ❤️🪻🌸“

“ordered from ollies for the first time last week. theyre new on slice! placed my order, and everything I put in the "special request" spot, was not done, I called them, they were SOOOOOO friendly and explained that it was a new system, and it was written very small, they made my food correct, and none of them could've been any more apologetic! I felt bad, since they had to bring it all the way back to Torrington. Again the person that delivered was apologetic, and they gave me a free desert. I cant tell you enough how friendly these guys ALL are, we even ordered from them again tonight. the food is sooo good, on top of good service, you can't go wrong...everyone needs to try them, you won't be disappointed! Kudos Ollies! ♥️♥️“

“Everything is wonderful! Take out for us every Saturday!“

“It’s a vibe. Awesome pizza.“

“We visited for the first time this afternoon! staff is very friendly. purchased some fresh linguine & vodka sauce. came home, cooked it up with chicken & it was SO delicious. The best pasta I've ever had! HIGHLY recommend Pasta Heaven! ❤️“

“Absolutely the best lunch we have ever had. Staff exceptional and Chef over the top. We will definitely be back for many more lunches. All of you are top of the line oh and the food is unbelievable“

“Wasn't sure about this place when we pulled in to the parking lot but so glad we gave it a try . I ordered the Zuppa di pesce ( one of my favorite hard to find meals ) absolutely everything I was hoping it would be and more . Very extensive menu if you can't find something here to tickle your taste buds maybe your not human . The service was awesome. The restaurant itself ain't very fancy but a steady flow of traffic of people picking up and calling in for orders . They are definitely doing something right . Me and the wife was in from out of town for a funeral. And we was very satisfied with our meals and service . So if your in the area this place is definitely worth the stop .“

“Such a happy accident finding this restaurant! Cozy ambiance and staff is super friendly. Our server was very attentive and our breakfast was delicious! Can’t wait to go back!“

“great food .service not so good . had to ask to have dirty dishes removed . staff walking around eating pizza . will try again soon .“

“First time trying, got some takeout … pizza: was great… plenty of toppings and cooked well! Quesadillas: were delicious, stuffed perfectly and great portion as well! The pasta fagioli hit the spot! We will definitely be back to try more!“

“My husband and I had the very best chicken franchise and seafood cippiono . Shout out to the chef! Well done.“

“Late-night MVPs!
Walked in at 11 PM on Wed, 7/9 and Christian (the general manager) and the exceptionally accommodating staff were welcoming and attentive.

Service was fast, friendly, and genuinely thoughtful. Full-on five-star hospitality from both. They took time to answer my questions about the menu and made sure everything was as ordered. Honestly felt more like a family-owned pizzaria than a national chain.

We had the thin crust pizza. Absolutely delicious and perfectly crispy. Best pizza we've had in years.

We'll definitely be back soon.

Domino's offers oven-baked sandwiches, wings, loaded tots, pasta bowls, cheesy bread, salads, desserts... It's like a full buffet disguised as a pizza joint. Can't wait to try more of the menu.“

“Pizzas deliciosas, massa muito bem assadas e finas Perfeitas“

“Great food. Need to get rid of that rude waitress. We have been there several times,and She is not nice at all. Seems to be mad all the time.“

“Superior customer service, friendly atmosphere and food is exceptional. Try the Linguine Gamberi. Sooo good.“

“Lovely dinner and dessert❤️“